Unique Pathways to Resilience across Cultures

School of Social Work, Dalhousie University, 6414 Coburg Road, Halifax, North Scotia, Canada B3H 2A7.
Adolescence (Impact Factor: 0.64). 02/2007; 42(166):287-310.
Source: PubMed


An international mixed methods study of resilience of 14 sites in eleven countries identified seven tensions that youth resolve in culturally specific ways. Resolution of these tensions is foundational to experiences of resilience. This paper reports on the qualitative findings from interviews with 89 youth. Results support a culturally embedded understanding of positive youth development that better accounts for young people's resilience in western and non-western countries. Specifically, the seven tensions identified include: access to material resources, relationships, identity, cohesion, power and control, social justice, and cultural adherence. Findings show that no one pattern in the resolution of these tensions predicts resilience better than another. A case study of a Palestinian boy demonstrates the intersection of the seven tensions and the uniqueness of their resolution. The implications of this work for interventions is discussed.

Download full-text


Available from: Linda Liebenberg, Nov 19, 2015
  • Source
    • "There were also varying opinions regarding the importance of culture. Uncertainty regarding the role of culture may reflect the literature to date, in which the cultural context in which resilience develops is an emerging development (Ungar et al., 2007). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: There has been a surge of interest regarding the application of resilience theory in childcare practice and how resilience can be promoted among vulnerable children, in particular, looked after children. However, little is known about how people working with looked after children understand the concept of resilience. This study aimed to explore how social workers, teachers and foster carers, working with looked after children, understand resilience and whether there is consensus as to what constitutes resilience. The study also sought to explore whether there are differences in how resilience is constructed across these groups. In total, 106 participants took part in a Delphi survey (34 teachers, 36 foster carers, 36 social workers). There was moderate consensus that resilience related to survival, coping and a sense of self-worth. Resilience was not considered a panacea but a concept that also had limitations. Participants understood resilience in ways that were both similar and different to existing conceptualisations within the literature. However, there were many aspects of resilience for which there was no consensus or significant difference of opinion between the participant groups. The need for further training and research is discussed, in order to support attempts to promote resilience among looked after children. © The Author(s) 2015.
    Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry 03/2015; DOI:10.1177/1359104515577485 · 1.03 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Qualitative data collection, concurrent with the development of the CYRM, provided further validation of the construct of resilience in each research site. In total 89 interviews were conducted with youth (Ungar et al., 2007 ) . Seven themes, or tensions, in the data emerged that were associated with resilience across all research sites: access to material resources, cultural adherence, identity, power and control, relationships, social justice, and social cohesion (including religious af fi liation). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In this chapter, we build on three propositions regarding the concept of resilience. First, we understand resilience to refer to coping under stress, and therefore a description of populations who do well when facing adversity. The term is not the same as the processes that contribute to positive development across an entire population, nor the everyday qualities that promote well-being. In fact research shows that the mechanisms that are protective under stress operate differently depending on the amount of adversity individuals and their families or communities experience (Rutter, 2009; Ungar, 2011). An external asset such as a mentor is going to account for far more of the change in a child’s development trajectory if the child has been exposed to severe and persistent neglect (Gilligan, 1999; Larson, 2006), just as an internal asset like persistence is more advantageous to a child whose schools are inadequately funded, or if she is excluded because of cultural norms regarding gender and education (Shin, Daly, & Vera, 2007).
    Resilience in Children, Adolescents and Adults: Translating research into practice, 1st edited by Sandra Prince-Embury, Donald H. Saklofske, 01/2015: chapter A Measure of Resilience with Contextual Sensitivity—The CYRM-28: Exploring the Tension Between Homogeneity and Heterogeneity in Resilience Theory and Research: pages 245-255; Springer., ISBN: 978-1-4614-4939-3
    • "They privilege the voices of majorityworld young people. In doing so, they illustrate that universally reported resilience mechanisms (Ungar et al., 2007) do account for the positive adjustment of Black SA young people but in ways that mirror these young people's women-dominated, disadvantaged context and its traditional African culture. They flag that resilience processes demand robust social ecological support that includes championship of youth-enabling social change. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Extant theories of resilience, or the process of adjusting well to adversity, privilege the voices of minority-world young people. Consequently, the resilience of marginalized, majority-world youth is imperfectly understood, and majority-world social ecologies struggle to facilitate resilience in ways that respect the insights of majority-world youth and their cultural and contextual positioning. Accordingly, this article makes audible, as it were, the voices of 181 rural, Black, South African adolescents with the purpose of explicating which resilience-supporting processes characterize their positive adjustment to disadvantaged life-worlds, and how contextual and cultural realities shape such processes. Deductive and inductive analyses of a narrative and visual data set, generated in the qualitative phase of an explanatory mixed-methods study, revealed that universally occurring resilience-supporting mechanisms inform positive adjustment. Importantly, which mechanisms these youth prioritized, and the form these mechanisms take, are shaped by contextual realities of absent men and commonplace suffering, and a cultural reality of strong women, human and spiritual care, and valorization of education. Attention to these adolescents’ voices not only prompts specific, culturally and contextually relevant leverage points for resilience but also reinforces the importance of attending to young people’s preferred pathways of resilience in order to understand and champion resilience in socially just ways.
    Journal of Adolescent Research 01/2015; DOI:10.1177/0743558415600072 · 0.87 Impact Factor
Show more