Echo combination to reduce proton resonance frequency (PRF) thermometry errors from fat

Department of Radiology, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305-5488, USA.
Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging (Impact Factor: 2.79). 03/2008; 27(3):673-7. DOI: 10.1002/jmri.21238
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT To validate echo combination as a means to reduce errors caused by fat in temperature measurements with the proton resonance frequency (PRF) shift method.
Computer simulations were performed to study the behavior of temperature measurement errors introduced by fat as a function of echo time. Error reduction by combining temperature images acquired at different echo times was investigated. For experimental verification, three echoes were acquired in a refocused gradient echo acquisition. Temperature images were reconstructed with the PRF shift method for the three echoes and then combined in a weighted average. Temperature measurement errors in the combined image and the individual echoes were compared for pure water and different fractions of fat in a computer simulation and for a phantom containing a homogenous mixture with 20% fat in an MR experiment.
In both simulation and MR measurement, the presence of fat caused severe temperature underestimation or overestimation in the individual echoes. The errors were substantially reduced after echo combination. Residual errors were about 0.3 degrees C for 10% fat and 1 degrees C for 20% fat.
Echo combination substantially reduces temperature measurement errors caused by small fractions of fat. This technique then eliminates the need for fat suppression in tissues such as the liver.

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Numerous studies have shown that the combination of radiation therapy and hyperthermia, when delivered at moderate temperatures (40°-45°C) for sustained times (30-90 minutes), can help to provide palliative relief and augment tumor response, local control, and survival. However, the dependence of treatment success on achieved temperature highlights the need for accurate thermal dosimetry, so that the prescribed thermal dose can be delivered to the tumor. This can be achieved noninvasively with MR thermometry. However, there are many challenges to performing MR thermometry in the breast, where hyperthermia of locally advanced breast cancer can provide a benefit. These include magnetic field system drift, fatty tissue, and breathing motion. The purpose of this research was to develop a system for the hyperthermia treatment of LABC while performing MR thermometry. A hardware system was developed for performing the hyperthermia treatment within the MR bore. Methods were developed to correct for magnetic field system drift and to correct for breath hold artifacts in MR thermometry of the tumor using measurement of field changes in fat references. Lastly, techniques were developed for measuring temperature in the fatty tissue using multi-echo fat water separation methods, reducing the error of performing MR thermometry in such tissues. All of these methods were characterized with phantom and in vivo experiments in a 1.5T MR system. The results of this research can provide the means for successful hyperthermia treatment of LABC with MR thermometry. With this thermometry, accurate thermal doses can be obtained, potentially providing improved outcomes. However, these results are not only applicable in the breast, but can also be used for improved MR thermometry in other areas of the body, such as the extremities or abdomen. Dissertation
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Summary form only given. The simplest boundary condition to implement in a finite difference time domain (FDTD) code is that of the perfect conductor where the tangential electric field and the normal magnetic field are set to zero. However, many problems require a lossy boundary. This is often implemented with the creation of a layer of cells within the metal that are given a finite conductivity. Resolving the skin depth in these cells may require using cells that are much smaller than those in the rest of the problem domain. This may reduce performance by requiring a smaller time step to satisfy the Courant condition. It also adds complexity to the code and to required input. Using a surface boundary condition (rather than a volume boundary condition) is potentially more efficient and easier to implement and use. This type of boundary often suffers the difficulty of requiring a time history of the magnetic field which for problems with large boundaries and/or many time cycles can lead to prohibitively large memory requirements. We propose a finite conductivity surface boundary condition that is easy to implement and has very little computational overhead. Preliminary tests show the method to be stable and to damp fields in a predictable way. However, quantitative agreement with analytic theory for simple test problems requires the use of a non-physical problem-specific parameter by the user
    Plasma Science, 1998. 25th Anniversary. IEEE Conference Record - Abstracts. 1998 IEEE International on; 07/1998
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The purpose of this work was to validate in phantom studies and demonstrate the clinical feasibility of MR proton resonance frequency thermometry at 1.5 T with segmented gradient-echo echo planar imaging (GRE-EPI) sequences during liver tumour radiofrequency (RF) ablation. Classical GRE acquisitions and segmented GRE-EPI acquisitions were performed at 1.5 T during simultaneous RF heating with an MR-compatible RF electrode placed in an agar gel phantom. Temperature increments were calculated and compared with four optical temperature probe measurements using Bland- Altman analysis. In a preliminary clinical feasibility study, the rapid GRE-EPI sequence (echo train length = 13) was used for MR temperature monitoring of RF ablation of liver tumours in three patient procedures. For phantom experiments, the Bland-Altman mean of differences between MR and optical probe temperature measurements was <0.4 degrees C, and the 95% limits of agreement value was <1.4 degrees C. For the in vivo studies, respiratory-triggered GRE-EPI acquisitions yielded a temperature accuracy of 1.3 +/- 0.4 degrees C (acquisition time = 0.6 s/image, spatial coverage of three slices/respiratory cycle). MR proton resonance frequency thermometry at 1.5 T yields precise and accurate measurements of temperature increment with both classical GRE and rapid GRE-EPI sequences. Rapid GRE-EPI sequences minimize intra-scan motion effects and can be used for MR thermometry during RF ablation in moving organs.
    NMR in Biomedicine 10/2008; 21(8):849-58. DOI:10.1002/nbm.1267 · 3.56 Impact Factor


Available from