Transurethral ultrasound applicators with dynamic multi-sector control for prostate thermal therapy: in vivo evaluation under MR guidance.

Thermal Therapy Research Group, Department of Radiation Oncology, University of California, San Francisco, California 94143, USA.
Medical Physics (Impact Factor: 3.01). 06/2008; 35(5):2081-93. DOI: 10.1118/1.2900131
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT The purpose of this study was to explore the feasibility and performance of a multi-sectored tubular array transurethral ultrasound applicator for prostate thermal therapy, with potential to provide dynamic angular and length control of heating under MR guidance without mechanical movement of the applicator. Test configurations were fabricated, incorporating a linear array of two multi-sectored tubular transducers (7.8-8.4 MHz, 3 mm OD, 6 mm length), with three 120 degrees independent active sectors per tube. A flexible delivery catheter facilitated water cooling (100 ml min(-1)) within an expandable urethral balloon (35 mm long x 10 mm diameter). An integrated positioning hub allows for rotating and translating the transducer assembly within the urethral balloon for final targeting prior to therapy delivery. Rotational beam plots indicate approximately 90 degrees-100 degrees acoustic output patterns from each 120 degrees transducer sector, negligible coupling between sectors, and acoustic efficiencies between 41% and 53%. Experiments were performed within in vivo canine prostate (n = 3), with real-time MR temperature monitoring in either the axial or coronal planes to facilitate control of the heating profiles and provide thermal dosimetry for performance assessment. Gross inspection of serial sections of treated prostate, exposed to TTC (triphenyl tetrazolium chloride) tissue viability stain, allowed for direct assessment of the extent of thermal coagulation. These devices created large contiguous thermal lesions (defined by 52 degrees C maximum temperature, t43 = 240 min thermal dose contours, and TTC tissue sections) that extended radially from the applicator toward the border of the prostate (approximately15 mm) during a short power application (approximately 8-16 W per active sector, 8-15 min), with approximately 200 degrees or 360 degrees sector coagulation demonstrated depending upon the activation scheme. Analysis of transient temperature profiles indicated progression of lethal temperature and thermal dose contours initially centered on each sector that coalesced within approximately 5 min to produce uniform and contiguous zones of thermal destruction between sectors, with smooth outer boundaries and continued radial propagation in time. The dimension of the coagulation zone along the applicator was well-defined by positioning and active array length. Although not as precise as rotating planar and curvilinear devices currently under development for MR-guided procedures, advantages of these multi-sectored transurethral applicators include a flexible delivery catheter and that mechanical manipulation of the device using rotational motors is not required during therapy. This multi-sectored tubular array transurethral ultrasound technology has demonstrated potential for relatively fast and reasonably conformal targeting of prostate volumes suitable for the minimally invasive treatment of BPH and cancer under MR guidance, with further development warranted.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Purpose: Minimising treatment time and protecting healthy tissues are conflicting goals that play major roles in making magnetic resonance image-guided focused ultrasound (MRgFUS) therapies clinically practical. We have developed and tested in vivo an adaptive model-predictive controller (AMPC) that reduces treatment time, ensures safety and efficacy, and provides flexibility in treatment set-up. Materials and methods: The controller realises time savings by modelling the heated treatment cell’s future temperatures and thermal dose accumulation in order to anticipate the optimal time to switch to the next cell. Selected tissues are safeguarded by a configurable temperature constraint. Simulations quantified the time savings realised by each controller feature as well as the trade-offs between competing safety and treatment time parameters. In vivo experiments in rabbit thighs established the controller’s effectiveness and reliability. Results: In all in vivo experiments the target thermal dose of at least 240 CEM43 was delivered everywhere in the treatment volume. The controller’s temperature safety limit reliably activated and constrained all protected tissues to <9 CEM43. Simulations demonstrated the path independence of the controller, and that a path which successively proceeds to the hottest untreated neighbouring cell leads to significant time savings, e.g. when compared to a concentric spiral path. Use of the AMPC produced a compounding time-saving effect; reducing the treatment cells’ heating times concurrently reduced heating of normal tissues, which eliminated cooling periods. Conclusions: Adaptive model-predictive control can automatically deliver safe, effective MRgFUS treatments while significantly reducing treatment times.
    International Journal of Hyperthermia 10/2014; 30(7). DOI:10.3109/02656736.2014.968223 · 2.77 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Abstract Purpose: One important challenge in image-guided ablative therapies is the effect of heat diffusion which can cause damage to surrounding organs and limit the ability to achieve a conformal pattern of thermal damage. Furthermore, tissue properties such as perfusion and energy absorption can be dynamic and difficult to measure. This paper attempts to address these problems by proposing new control methods. Materials and methods: A novel predictive approach was developed to compensate for the effect of heat diffusion using a minimally invasive rotating ultrasound heating applicator for ablative therapy. This method can be merged into any closed-loop control strategy. A binary controller, a previously developed adaptive proportional-integral controller, and a model reference adaptive controller were employed and compared, all with the predictive element incorporated. The reason for choosing these controllers was that none of them needed a model of the tissue or exact values of their parameters. Results: The effectiveness of these controllers was demonstrated through both simulation and experimental studies. The results were consistent and demonstrated equivalent performance between controllers. Conclusions: The dominant influence on radial targeting accuracy was the prediction element described in this paper. A binary controller with a predictive element may provide the best balance of performance and simplicity for this application.
    International Journal of Hyperthermia 10/2014; 30(7):1-9. DOI:10.3109/02656736.2014.963702 · 2.77 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The purpose of this review is to summarise a literature survey on thermal thresholds for tissue damage. This review covers published literature for the consecutive years from 2002-2009. The first review on this subject was published in 2003. It included an extensive discussion of how to use thermal dosimetric principles to normalise all time-temperature data histories to a common format. This review utilises those same principles to address sensitivity of a variety of tissues, but with particular emphasis on brain and testis. The review includes new data on tissues that were not included in the original review. Several important observations have come from this review. First, a large proportion of the papers examined for this review were discarded because time-temperature history at the site of thermal damage assessment was not recorded. It is strongly recommended that future research on this subject include such data. Second, very little data is available examining chronic consequences of thermal exposure. On a related point, the time of assessment of damage after exposure is critically important for assessing whether damage is transient or permanent. Additionally, virtually no data are available for repeated thermal exposures which may occur in certain recreational or occupational activities. For purposes of regulatory guidelines, both acute and lasting effects of thermal damage should be considered.
    International Journal of Hyperthermia 06/2011; 27(4):320-43. DOI:10.3109/02656736.2010.534527 · 2.77 Impact Factor


Available from