Evidence of the Trade-Off between Starvation and Predation Risks in Ducks

Université de Strasbourg, IPHC, Strasbourg, France.
PLoS ONE (Impact Factor: 3.23). 07/2011; 6(7):e22352. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0022352
Source: PubMed


The theory of trade-off between starvation and predation risks predicts a decrease in body mass in order to improve flight performance when facing high predation risk. To date, this trade-off has mainly been validated in passerines, birds that store limited body reserves for short-term use. In the largest avian species in which the trade-off has been investigated (the mallard, Anas platyrhynchos), the slope of the relationship between mass and flight performance was steeper in proportion to lean body mass than in passerines. In order to verify whether the same case can be applied to other birds with large body reserves, we analyzed the response to this trade-off in two other duck species, the common teal (Anas crecca) and the tufted duck (Aythya fuligula). Predation risk was simulated by disturbing birds. Ducks within disturbed groups were compared to non-disturbed control birds. In disturbed groups, both species showed a much greater decrease in food intake and body mass during the period of simulated high risk than those observed in the control group. This loss of body mass allows reaching a more favourable wing loading and increases power for flight, hence enhancing flight performances and reducing predation risk. Moreover, body mass loss and power margin gain in both species were higher than in passerines, as observed in mallards. Our results suggest that the starvation-predation risk trade-off is one of the major life history traits underlying body mass adjustments, and these findings can be generalized to all birds facing predation. Additionally, the response magnitude seems to be influenced by the strategy of body reserve management.

Download full-text


Available from: Cedric Zimmer, Mar 05, 2014
  • Source
    • "Hence, our study shows that the reduction of body mass in a natural situation might as much as double the effect reported in captivity. On the other hand, it is similar to the 6–16 % reduction reported for Anatidae species chased by a radio-controlled car in indoor experiments (Zimmer et al. 2011), but these large animals store much more reserves and face a much lower starvation risk than the passerines (Zimmer et al. 2011). It is also within the range of the daily variation in body mass reported for Titmice (7–12 %; Haftorn 1989) and similar to the seasonal winter variation found in Blackbirds (13 %; McLeod et al. 2005). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The body mass of birds is the result of a trade-off between predation and starvation risks. According to the mass-dependent predation hypothesis, birds reduce their body mass when predation risk increases. Many studies have supported this hypothesis, but it has rarely been possible to investigate the mass-dependent predation risk response by comparing individuals of the same species foraging simultaneously at the same location, in the field and facing a real (not simulated) risk of predation. Wintering Siskins (Carduelis spinus) are divided in two subpopulations: residents, which stay in a foraging area for several weeks or months, and transients, which only remain a few hours or days. In this paper, we present a natural experiment by comparing the body mass variation of resident and transient Siskins between a period of the wintering season without avian predators and another period with a Sparrowhawk (Accipiter nisus) that was hunting regularly. We found that resident Siskins reduced their body mass with the presence of the hawk, while transients did not. Since in a previous study with no avian predators at the study area it was found that the difference in body condition between residents and transients did not vary throughout the wintering season, we can confidently say that the reduction in body mass observed in this study was directly linked to the presence of the hawk. We additionally found that this reduction was not associated with the dominance of residents over transients. We discuss the advantages of residence related to the knowledge of actual predation risk. Our results strongly support the mass-dependent predation hypothesis.
    12/2014; 156(2):451-456. DOI:10.1007/s10336-014-1143-8
  • Source
    • "This can be done by using a widely used methodology scoring the time, the accuracy and the risk of a decision. A growing amount of literature describes economics in humans (Farmer and Foley 2009; Glimcher 2009), and eco-ethology in birds making compromises between starvation, predation and reproduction (Zimmer et al. 2011; Higginson et al. 2012; Grodzinski and Johnstone 2012; Meunier and Kölliker 2012). Numerous studies have been carried out on social cognition in primates (Addessi et al. 2011a; Pelé et al. 2011; Addessi et al. 2011b; Fletcher et al. 2012) but also birds (Mettke-Hofmann et al. 2002; Dufour et al. 2012; Krama et al. 2012) and carnivores (Topal et al. 2009; Leonardi et al. 2012), and other publications describe market or reciprocal exchanges of commodities (Fruteau et al. 2009; van de Waal et al. 2012; Wei et al. 2012). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In order to maximize their fitness, animals have to deal with different environmental and social factors that affect their everyday life. Although the way an animal behaves might enhance its fitness or survival in regard to one factor, it could compromise them regarding another. In the domain of decision sciences, research concerning decision making focuses on performances at the individual level but also at the collective one. However, between individual and collective decision making, different terms are used resulting in little or no connection between both research areas. In this paper, we reviewed how different branches of decision sciences study the same concept, mainly called speed-accuracy trade-off, and how the different results are on the same track in terms of showing the optimality of decisions. Whatever the level, individual or collective, each decision might be defined with three parameters: time or delay to decide, risk and accuracy. We strongly believe that more progress would be possible in this domain of research if these different branches were better linked, with an exchange of their results and theories. A growing amount of literature describes economics in humans and eco-ethology in birds making compromises between starvation, predation and reproduction. Numerous studies have been carried out on social cognition in primates but also birds and carnivores, and other publications describe market or reciprocal exchanges of commodities. We therefore hope that this paper will lead these different areas to a common decision science.
    Animal Cognition 04/2013; 16(4). DOI:10.1007/s10071-013-0631-1 · 2.58 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Along the Pacific coast of North America, White-winged Scoters (Melanitta fusca) winter in sites that vary widely in habitat conditions. This habitat variation likely alters the relative costs and benefits of using specific sites in terms of factors such as foraging conditions, degree of predation danger, and thermoregulatory costs. To assess how White-winged Scoters adjust their physiology and energy management in response to variation in habitat conditions, we contrasted overwinter dynamics in several physiological indicators across five sites in British Columbia and Washington. We tested the relative support for various hypotheses that considered exposure to wind and waves, water depth, predation danger, diet composition, and collection period as possible underlying causes of variation in physiological indicators. Total body mass and lipid mass were highest at an exposed offshore site, which may reflect an adaptive response to buffer against unpredictable foraging conditions and increased thermoregulatory costs. At nearshore sites where exposure was lower, scoters maintained lower lipid masses throughout the winter. Total lipid mass declined through the winter in all sites, a result consistent with findings for many waterfowl species. However, levels of plasma metabolites (triglycerides, β-hydroxybutyrate) varied little by site, suggesting that, irrespective of body composition, birds at all sites maintained physiological homeostasis. Digestive morphology was strongly related to diet, with smaller gizzards and longer intestines associated with a greater fraction of soft-bodied foods in the diet. Our results suggest that the physiology and energy management of wintering White-winged Scoters is related to local habitat conditions. A lo largo de la costa pacífica de América del Norte, Melanitta fusca inverna en sitios que varían enormemente en las condiciones de hábitat. Esta variación de hábitat probablemente altera los costos y beneficios relativos del uso de sitios específicos en términos de factores como condiciones de forrajeo, grado de peligro de depredación y costos termo-regulatorios. Para evaluar como M. fusca ajusta su fisiología y manejo de la energía en respuesta a la variación en las condiciones de hábitat, comparamos las dinámicas de varios indicadores fisiológicos a lo largo del invierno en cinco sitios en la Columbia Británica y Washington. Evaluamos el apoyo relativo a va­rias hipótesis que consideraron exposición a los vientos y olas, profundidad del agua, peligro de depredación, composición de la dieta y período de colecta como posibles causas subyacentes de variación en los indicadores fisiológicos. La masa corporal total y la masa de lípidos fueron las más altas en un sitio expuesto mar adentro, lo cual puede reflejar una respuesta adaptativa para amortiguar condiciones de forrajeo impredecibles y aumentar los costos de termo regulación. En los sitios cercanos a la costa donde la exposición fue más baja, M. fusca mantuvo masas de lípidos más bajas a lo largo del invierno. La masa total de lípidos disminuyó a lo largo del invierno en todos los sitios, lo que es consistente con los hallazgos para muchas especies de aves acuáticas. Sin embargo, los niveles de metabolitos en plasma (triglicéridos, β-hidroxibutírico) variaron poco entre sitios, sugiriendo que, independientemente de la composición corporal, las aves mantuvieron en todos los sitios la homeostasis fisiológica. La morfología digestiva estuvo fuertemente relacionada a la dieta, con mollejas más pequeñas e intestinos más largos asociados con una fracción mayor de alimentos de cuerpo blando en la dieta. Nuestros resultados sugieren que la fisiología y el manejo de la energía de los individuos invernantes de M. fusca están relacionados con las condiciones locales de hábitat.
    The Condor 01/2013; 115(4):750-761. DOI:10.1525/cond.2013.120109 · 1.00 Impact Factor
Show more