Acoustic intensity causes perceived changes in arousal levels in music: an experimental investigation.

MARCS Auditory Laboratories, University of Western Sydney, Milperra, New South Wales, Australia.
PLoS ONE (Impact Factor: 3.53). 04/2011; 6(4):e18591. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0018591
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Listener perceptions of changes in the arousal expressed by classical music have been found to correlate with changes in sound intensity/loudness over time. This study manipulated the intensity profiles of different pieces of music in order to test the causal nature of this relationship. Listeners (N = 38) continuously rated their perceptions of the arousal expressed by each piece. An extract from Dvorak's Slavonic Dance Opus 46 No 1 was used to create a variant in which the direction of change in intensity was inverted, while other features were retained. Even though it was only intensity that was inverted, perceived arousal was also inverted. The original intensity profile was also superimposed on three new pieces of music. The time variation in the perceived arousal of all pieces was similar to their intensity profile. Time series analyses revealed that intensity variation was a major influence on the arousal perception in all pieces, in spite of their stylistic diversity.

1 Bookmark
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In real-world listening domains such as speech and music, acoustic intensity and perceived loudness are dynamic and continuously changing through time. The percept of loudness change in response to continuous increases (up-ramps) and decreases (down-ramps) of intensity has received ongoing empirical and theoretical interest, the result of which has led to conflicting findings from a range of key paradigms. Therefore, the aim of this brief review is to: (a) describe key paradigms used to measure changes in loudness in response to continuous intensity change; (b) identify methodological issues associated with each paradigm; and (c) discuss the mechanisms proposed to explain differences in loudness change when methodological constraints and response biases are controlled. It is concluded that direct and indirect measures of loudness change reflect two distinct aspects of auditory perception. Specifically, magnitude estimation and continuous loudness paradigms reflect changes in perception associated with a ramp’s direction and magnitude of intensity change, and empirical evidence supports the conclusion that greater loudness change in response to down-ramps relative to up-ramps is the real-time perceptual outcome. On the other hand, retrospective global judgements of loudness change are disproportionally weighted on end-level intensity rather than magnitude of intensity change. However, an up-ramp-specific effect of duration on global loudness change is evident when end-level response bias is controlled, and this may be associated with end-point time-of-arrival responses to real and apparent looming auditory motion.
    Acoustics Australia / Australian Acoustical Society 12/2014; 42. · 0.36 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We use time series analysis methods to detect differences between individuals and expertise groups in continuous perceptions of the arousal expressed by Wishart's electroacoustic piece Red Bird. The study is part of a project in which we characterise dynamic perception of the structure and affective expression of music. We find that individual series of perceptions of expressed arousal often show considerable periods of stasis. This may challenge conventional time series methodologies, so we test their validity by application of a general linear autoregressive moving average (GLARMA) approach, which supports it. Acoustic intensity is a dominant predictor of perceived arousal in this piece. We show that responses are time-variant and that animate sounds influence the conditional variance of perceived arousal. Using vector autoregression and cross-sectional time series analysis (which preserves the integrity of each individual response series), we find differences between musical expertise groups (non-musicians, musicians, and electroacoustic musicians). Individual differences within each group are greater than those between expertise groups. The companion paper applies the developed methods to all four pieces in our overall project (Dean, R.T., F. Bailes, and W.T.M. Dunsmuir. 2014. “Shared and Distinct Mechanisms of Individual and Expertise-Group Perception of Expressed Arousal in Four Works.” Journal of Mathematics and Music 8 (3): 207–223). An Online Supplement is available at
    Journal of Applied Statistics 09/2014; 8(3). · 0.45 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of this work was to investigate perceived loudness change in response to melodies that increase (up-ramp) or decrease (down-ramp) in acoustic intensity, and the interaction with other musical factors such as melodic contour, tempo, and tonality (tonal/atonal). A within-subjects design manipulated direction of linear intensity change (up-ramp, down-ramp), melodic contour (ascending, descending), tempo, and tonality, using single ramp trials and paired ramp trials, where single up-ramps and down-ramps were assembled to create continuous up-ramp/down-ramp or down-ramp/up-ramp pairs. Twenty-nine (Exp 1) and thirty-six (Exp 2) participants rated loudness continuously in response to trials with monophonic 13-note piano melodies lasting either 6.4 s or 12 s. Linear correlation coefficients >.89 between loudness and time show that time-series loudness responses to dynamic up-ramp and down-ramp melodies are essentially linear across all melodies. Therefore, ‘indirect’ loudness change derived from the difference in loudness at the beginning and end points of the continuous response was calculated. Down-ramps were perceived to change significantly more in loudness than up-ramps in both tonalities and at a relatively slow tempo. Loudness change was also greater for down-ramps presented with a congruent descending melodic contour, relative to an incongruent pairing (down-ramp and ascending melodic contour). No differential effect of intensity ramp/melodic contour congruency was observed for up-ramps. In paired ramp trials assessing the possible impact of ramp context, loudness change in response to up-ramps was significantly greater when preceded by down-ramps, than when not preceded by another ramp. Ramp context did not affect down-ramp perception. The contribution to the fields of music perception and psychoacoustics are discussed in the context of real-time perception of music, principles of music composition, and performance of musical dynamics.
    Acta Psychologica 05/2014; 149:117-128. · 2.26 Impact Factor

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
May 21, 2014