Validation of a self-efficacy instrument and its relationship to performance of crisis resource management skills

Department of Pediatrics, University of California Davis, Sacramento, 95817, USA.
Advances in Health Sciences Education (Impact Factor: 2.71). 12/2011; 16(5):579-90. DOI: 10.1007/s10459-011-9274-7
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Self-efficacy is thought to be important for resuscitation proficiency in that it influences the development of and access to the associated medical knowledge, procedural skills and crisis resource management (CRM) skills. Since performance assessment of CRM skills is challenging, self-efficacy is often used as a measure of competence in this area. While self-efficacy may influence performance, the true relationship between self-efficacy and performance in this setting has not been delineated. We developed an instrument to measure pediatric residents' self-efficacy in CRM skills and assessed its content validity, internal structure, and relationship to other variables. After administering the instrument to 125 pediatric residents, critical care fellows and faculty, we performed an exploratory factor analysis within a confirmatory factor analysis as well as a known group comparison. The analyses specified four factors that we defined as: situation awareness, team management, environment management, and decision making. Pediatric residents reported lower self-efficacy than fellows and faculty in each factor. We also examined the correlation between self-efficacy and performance scores for a subset of 30 residents who led video recorded simulated resuscitations and had their performances rated by three observers. We found a significant, positive correlation between residents' self-efficacy in situation awareness and environment management and their overall performance of CRM skills. Our findings suggest that in a specific context, self-efficacy as a form of self-assessment may be informative with regards to performance.

Download full-text


Available from: Diane Sliwka, Jun 30, 2015
1 Follower
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Simulation-based interprofessional team training is important to ensure high-quality, safe patient care, but several barriers exist, including diverging learning needs and schedules as well as limited available resources. The authors developed an in situ, simulation-based interprofessional team training program around pediatric emergencies for physicians, nurses, respiratory therapists, and pharmacists at their institution and performed an analysis of the program's impact on self-efficacy in resuscitation skills among pediatric residents and nurses. The results showed that with a design based in best principles of team training and simulation education, interprofessional team training is feasible and sustainable. The program had a beneficial effect on self-efficacy in resuscitation skills among both residents and nurses at the authors' institution and received widespread acceptance. A collaborative approach to design and implementation of interprofessional team training can lead to a sustainable program that serves both patient safety and training requirements set forth by professional organizations.
    Clinical Pediatrics 04/2011; 50(9):807-15. DOI:10.1177/0009922811405518 · 1.26 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: La pratique médicale inclut un savoir théorique, un savoir-faire et un savoir-être. La simulation a un bénéfice dans ces trois domaines et représente un outil pédagogique considérable pour la médecine d’urgence. Les médecins anesthésistes ont été les pionniers de la simulation médicale. La simulation est une technique pédagogique, pas une technologie. Elle permet l’acquisition d’une compétence individuelle par l’utilisation de task-trainers jusqu’à développer une performance d’équipe. Elle concerne aussi bien la formation initiale que continue et vise à comprendre et à éviter les erreurs humaines, source de manque de performance. Le domaine de l’urgence offre de nombreuses possibilités d’utilisation des task-trainers pour s’entraîner aux gestes pratiques, notamment quand ils sont rares, avec un bénéfice de la simulation par rapport à l’enseignement uniquement théorique. L’utilisation de scénarios complexes avec des mannequins haute-fidélité améliore les compétences, le comportement et les interactions interindividuelles. La communication et le travail d’équipe sont les éléments essentiels de la performance d’une gestion de situation de crise (Crisis Resource Management). L’apprentissage par simulation doit être évalué selon un processus codifié jusqu’à atteindre l’évaluation de l’impact clinique. L’extension de la simulation est liée au développement d’une recherche mesurant son impact clinique, c’està-dire le passage du modèle de simulation au patient. L’essor de la simulation passe par la création de centres de simulation ainsi que la valorisation de la formation en équipe pluridisciplinaire. Les services d’urgence devraient être dans les premiers à bénéficier de cette nouvelle pédagogie. L’éthique, la technique et l’économie y seront gagnants.
    11/2012; 2(6). DOI:10.1007/s13341-012-0256-z
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Pediatrics residents are expected to demonstrate preparedness for neonatal resuscitation, yet research has shown gaps in residents' readiness to perform this skill. To evaluate procedural skills and team performance of pediatrics residents during neonatal resuscitation (NR) using a high-fidelity mannequin, and to assess residents' confidence in their NR skills before and after training. Two teams of residents (all had completed NR program training) participated in 2 separate, 90-minute sessions (2 to 3 weeks apart) in an off-site delivery room during their neonatal intensive care rotation. Residents' confidence in assisting and leading NR was surveyed before each session. Teams participated in a scenario (adapted from the NR program), which required 5 skills (positive pressure ventilation, chest compressions, endotracheal intubation, umbilical vein catheterization, and epinephrine administration). Video recording was used for debriefing and scoring. Skills were scored for technique and timeliness, and team behaviors were scored for communication, management, and leadership. Twenty-six residents (11 teams) completed 2 paired sessions. Self-confidence scores increased between the 2 sessions but were not correlated with performance. Gaps in procedural skill performance were observed, and timeliness for most skills did not meet expectations. Significant improvement in team communication was noted. Important gaps in procedural skill performance, particularly timeliness, were detected by NR simulation training; residents' improvements in self-confidence did not reflect gains in actual performance. Their relative unpreparedness for NR (despite prior certification) highlights the need for deliberate practice and specific team training before and during neonatal intensive care delivery room rotations.
    09/2013; 5(3):399-404. DOI:10.4300/JGME-D-12-00192.1