Short- and Long-Term Effects of Multimarket Trading

Financial Review 08/2007; 42(3):349-372. DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-6288.2007.00175.x
Source: RePEc

ABSTRACT We analyze short- and long-term effects of multimarket trading by examining the entries of multiple markets into transacting three ETFs, DIA, QQQ, and SPY. We find that large-scale entries improve overall market quality, while small-scale entries have ambiguous effects. Our results show that the competition effect dominates the fragmentation effect over a long horizon and that market fragmentation leads to a decline in trading costs. Further, we find that the order handling rules help mitigate the fragmentation effect and facilitate the competition effect. We do not find that multimarket trading harms price efficiency or increases price volatility. Copyright 2007, The Eastern Finance Association.

Download full-text


Available from: Van Thuan Nguyen, Jun 27, 2015
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Consider a stock which is simultaneously traded on two or more venues, either because its company is cross-listed or because regulation allows multi-trading. We set the idea that these venues are 'indirectly' connected and represent a network. If the 'importance' of a venue is traditionally measured by its isolated-centrality (e.g. trading volumes observed inside it), we introduce a network measure, the degree-centrality, which includes trading activity due to its connections with other stock markets. Using trading volume data of nearly 22,000 equities we study the dynamic of market centrality among the various European trading venues between 2005 and 2009. European Regulated Stock Exchanges (SEs) and Alternative Trading Venues (ATVs), introduced in Europe in 2007, are the nodes/vertexes of our network. We observe that the birth of European ATVs (Multi-lateral Trading Facilities, Systematic Internalisers and the OTC market) eroded the isolated-centrality of certain European SEs (particularly London), but not for all. In contrast, degree-centrality significantly increased for the majority of the 48 SEs analyzed, in favor of multi-markets coexistence. Moreover, European ATVs did not act as substitute to the secondary market for cross-listed shares. Paradoxically, our results show that for medium size European SEs, cross-listing trading activity Granger-causes multi-trading on European ATVs.
    SSRN Electronic Journal 01/2012; DOI:10.2139/ssrn.1981843
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This empirical study based on data from several exchanges and trading platforms for a sample of 153 European blue chip stocks over a post-MiFID three-month period shows that the way liquidity correlates with fragmentation is diverse and depends on the market, the type of liquidity metrics, and the type of fragmentation that is considered. All in all, fragmentation seems to be more beneficial to global traders trading in several market places than to local traders trading on the primary exchange only, which confirms the crucial role of order routing systems in fragmented markets. Further, fragmentation adversely affects price quality by increasing short-term volatility. That adverse effect is assignable to market-traded order flow fragmentation but not to internalization. oui
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Preliminary review / Publisher’s description: This book discusses market microstructure environment within the context of the global financial crisis and investigates the recent econometric tools to improve financial markets dynamics in calm and turbulent times. In the first part, the market microstructure theory is examined and the main microstructure models and hypotheses are discussed. In particular, contributors focus on the main effects of the financial downturn through an examination of market microstructure dynamics, the limitations associated with standard microstructure models and the investigation of ways to improve such models. Interestingly, promising analyses based on recent high-frequency data and sophisticated models discuss new regulations, and recent developments for financial markets are provided in order to improve the understating of market microstructure evolution. As for the second part, this book focuses on Nonlinear Dynamics. Through interesting contributions concerning stock markets, exchange rate and bond markets, authors propose several new specifications to improve the modelling of key financial variables such as return, risk premium, risk, etc. Also, this part provides interesting explanations of the effects and the consequences of high-level linkages between financial markets. Finally, while analyzing the effect of the recent global financial crisis and the reaction function of investors, markets and institutions, authors specify the appropriate way to better forecast financial markets dynamics and improve investment and financial decisions. For both parts, well-known experts on market microstructure and nonlinear econometrics contribute to the chapters in the book. This book is strongly recommended for academic researchers, students and quantitative practitioners.