An examination of stage theory of grief among individuals bereaved by natural and violent causes: a meaning-oriented contribution.

Center for Health Care Evaluation, VA Palo Alto Health Care System and Stanford University Medical Centerm, Menlo Park, CA 94025, USA.
OMEGA--Journal of Death and Dying (Impact Factor: 0.44). 01/2010; 61(2):103-20. DOI: 10.2190/OM.61.2.b
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Despite its popularity, few attempts have been made to empirically test the stage theory of grief. The most prominent of these attempts was conducted by Maciejewski, Zhang, Block, and Prigerson (2007), who found that different states of grieving may peak in a sequence that is consistent with stage theory. The present study aimed to provide a conceptual replication and extension of these findings by examining the association between time since loss and five grief Indicators (focusing on disbelief, anger, yearning, depression, and acceptance), among an ethnically diverse sample of young adults who had been bereaved by natural (n=441) and violent (n=173) causes. We also examined the potential salience of meaning-making and assessed the extent to which participants had made sense of their losses. In general, limited support was found for stage theory, alongside some evidence of an "anniversary reaction" marked by heightened distress and reduced acceptance for participants approaching the second anniversary of the death. Overall, sense-making emerged as a much stronger predictor of grief Indicators than time since loss, highlighting the relevance of a meaning-oriented perspective.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Genetic counselors and other health professionals frequently meet with patients who are grieving a loss. It is thus helpful for medical professionals to be familiar with approaches to bereavement counseling. Grief theory has evolved over the last few decades, from primarily stage theories of grief such as Kübler-Ross's "five stages of grief" to frameworks that promote more complex and long-term ways to cope with a loss. Herein I present one recent grief theory - meaning-making - and describe how it can be applied to help parents of children with disabilities grieve the loss of the child that they expected. In particular, I describe a scenario that many genetic counselors face - meeting with the parents of a child with Down syndrome. I outline the research done on the reactions, grief and coping experienced by parents in this circumstance, and I present suggestions for encouraging healthy coping and adjustment for parents, based on the meaning-making perspective. The meaning-making theory can also be applied to many of the other losses faced by genetic counseling patients.
    Journal of Genetic Counseling 06/2014; · 1.75 Impact Factor
  • Source
    Studies on Social Work. 10/2011; 37(3):168-183.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We investigated the relationships of grief and depression to cancer caregiving in early bereavement. We began with 3 expectations: 1) each outcome would reflect different situational predictors; 2) grief would be more directly related to such predictors; and 3) components of grief would relate differently to the caregiving context and depressed mood. We conducted telephone interviews with family caregivers of incurable cancer patients from 2 hospitals; 199 family caregivers were interviewed at the time of the patient’s diagnosis and re-interviewed 3 months after the patient’s death. Results showed grief severity was predicted by caregiving circumstances, but bereavement depressed mood was largely unrelated to caregiving. Grief was the main predictor of depressed mood, and mediated almost all other effects. We conclude that while grief may trigger depression, the dissimilar connection to context means that the 2 emotional states should not be equated based purely on similarity of expression.
    OMEGA--Journal of Death and Dying 01/2015; 70(4):315-344. · 0.44 Impact Factor

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
May 20, 2014