Staffing, skill mix and the model of care

Centre for Health Services Management, Faculty of Nursing, Midwifery and Health, University of Technology, Sydney, PO Box 123, Broadway, NSW 2007, Australia.
Journal of Clinical Nursing (Impact Factor: 1.23). 08/2010; 19(15-16):2242-51. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2702.2010.03225.x
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT The study aimed to explore whether nurse staffing, experience and skill mix influenced the model of nursing care in medical-surgical wards.
Methods of allocating nurses to patients are typically divided into four types: primary nursing, patient allocation, task assignment and team nursing. Research findings are varied in regard to the relationship between these models of care and outcomes such as satisfaction and quality. Skill mix has been associated with various models, with implications for collegial support, teamwork and patient outcomes.
Secondary analysis of data collected on 80 randomly selected medical-surgical wards in 19 public hospitals in New South Wales, Australia during 2004-2005.
Nurses (n = 2278, 80.9% response rate) were surveyed using The Nursing Care Delivery System and the Nursing Work Index-Revised. Staffing and skill mix was obtained from the ward roster and other data from the patient record. Models of care were examined in relation to these practice environment and organisational variables.
The models of nursing care most frequently reported by nurses in medical-surgical wards in this study were patient allocation (91%) and team nursing (80%). Primary nursing and task based models were unlikely to be practised. Skill mix, nurse experience, nursing workload and factors in the ward environment significantly influenced the model of care in use. Wards with a higher ratio of degree qualified, experienced registered nurses, working on their 'usual' ward were more likely to practice patient allocation while wards with greater variability in staffing levels and skill mix were more likely to practice team nursing.
Models of care are not prescriptive but are varied according to ward circumstances and staffing levels based on complex clinical decision making skills.
Variability in the models of care reported by ward nurses indicates that nurses adapt the model of nursing care on a daily or shift basis, according to patients' needs, skill mix and individual ward environments.


Available from: Michael Anthony Roche, May 12, 2014
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: AimTo explore the influence of workplace culture on sickness absences, overtime work and occupational injuries in municipal primary health care.Background The need to improve nursing sensitive outcomes has been highlighted. Therefore, an adequate understanding of the influence of workplace culture on nursing-sensitive nurse outcomes is essential for nurse managers to meet the requirements of improving nursing outcomes.MethodsA cross-sectional survey design was used to incorporating the data from 21 inpatient acute care units of nine organisations at the Finnish municipal primary health care system from 2011 to 2012.ResultsFindings emphasise in particular the importance of the practice environment as being an interpretative factor for nurses' absences owing to sickness, overtime work and occupational injuries.Conclusion and implications for nursing managementTo ensure favourable nursing sensitive outcomes it is essential that there is a shared interest in the unit to invest in the creation of a supportive practice environment. Outcome improvements require a special focus on issues related to nursing management, adequate staffing and resources and intention to leave.
    Journal of Nursing Management 05/2014; DOI:10.1111/jonm.12237 · 1.14 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: OBJECTIVE: The aims of this study were to design, pilot, and evaluate a care team model of shared accountability on medical-surgical units. BACKGROUND: American healthcare systems must optimize professional nursing services and support staff due to economic constraints, evolving Federal regulations and increased nurse capabilities. METHODS: A redesigned model of RN-led teams with shared accountability was piloted on 3 medical/surgical units in sample hospitals for 6 months. Nursing staff were trained for all functions within their scope of practice and provided education and support for implementation. RESULTS: Clinical outcomes and patient experience scores improved with the exception of falls. Nurse satisfaction demonstrated statistically significant improvement. Cost outcomes resulted in reduced total salary dollars per day, and case mix-adjusted length of stay decreased by 0.38. CONCLUSION: Innovative changes in nursing care delivery can maintain clinical quality and nurse and patient satisfaction while decreasing costs.
    JONA The Journal of Nursing Administration 07/2014; 44(7/8):388-94. DOI:10.1097/NNA.0000000000000088 · 1.37 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Objetivos: Conocer el grado de implementación de un modelo de personalización de cuidados en 4 hospitales del Servicio Andaluz de Salud y determinar si existe relación entre este modelo y la percepción de confianza en la enfermera por parte del paciente. Método: Estudio transversal, que incluyó a pacientes dados de alta durante 12 meses en unidades de 4 hospitales públicos organizadas según el modelo de Personalización de Cuidados del Servicio Andaluz de Salud (basado en el modelo Enfermería Primaria). La implementación del modelo se evaluó mediante el Índice de Personalización de Cuidados (IPC), tipo informe de usuario, y la percepción de confianza mediante una pregunta realizada simultáneamente con el IPC. El análisis incluyó estadística descriptiva, test de Chi cuadrado, regresión logística simple y multivariante, estratificando y sin estratificar por unidades hospitalarias. Resultados: Se incluyeron 817 pacientes. La implementación del modelo de personalización de cuidados osciló entre el 62 y el 79%. El valor del IPC presenta una fuerte asociación con la percepción de confianza del paciente en la enfermera: por cada aumento en un punto del IPC, la probabilidad de percibir confianza aumenta entre un 50 y un 130% (0,12 < r2 > 0,58). Conclusión: La implementación del modelo a estudio se realizó en un porcentaje bastante alto en las unidades quirúrgicas y aceptable en las unidades médicas. Se ha constatado la influencia de la personalización de los cuidados, medida mediante el IPC, sobre la confianza que el paciente tiene en la enfermera que lo cuida. Esta confianza es la base de una relación terapéutica. Objetives To determine the level of implementation of an inpatient personalized nursing care model in four hospitals of the Andalusian Health Service, and to determine if there is an association between this model and the perception of trust in the nurse by the patient. Method An observational cross-sectional study included the patients discharged during a period of 12 months from hospital wards that used the Inpatient Personalized Nursing Care Model of the Andalusian Health Service (based on Primary Nursing Model). The level of implemention was evaluated using the Nursing Care Personalized Index (IPC), made by «patient report» methodology, and the nurse-patient trust relationship was evaluated at the same time as the IPC. Statistical analysis included descriptive data analysis, Chi-squared test, and bivariate and multivariate logistic regression, with and without stratifying by hospitals wards. Results A total of 817 patient were included. The implementation of the inpatient personalized nursing care model varied between 61 and 79%. The IPC values showed a strong association with the nurse–patient trust relationship, and that for each point increase in the IPC score, the probability of a nurse–patient trust relationship increased between 50 and 130% (0.12 < r2 > 0.58). Conclusion The implementation of a personalized nursing care model in the wards studied was higher in the surgicals wards and at regular level in medical wards. Furthermore, the influence of the inpatient personalized nursing care model on the nurse–patient trust relationship has been demonstrated using the IPC model. This trust is the main component for the establishment of a therapeutic relationship.
    Enfermería Clínica 11/2013; 23(6):243-51.