Global microbial commons: institutional challenges for the global exchange and distribution of microorganisms in the life sciences

Université catholique de Louvain (UCLouvain), Centre de Philosophie du Droit, Collège Thomas More b146, Place Montesquieu 2 box15, B-1348 Belgium.
Research in Microbiology (Impact Factor: 2.83). 07/2010; 161(6):414-21. DOI: 10.1016/j.resmic.2010.04.012
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Exchanges of microorganisms between culture collections, laboratories and researchers worldwide have historically occurred in an informal way. These informal exchanges have facilitated research activities, and, as a consequence, our knowledge and exploitation of microbial resources have advanced rapidly. During the last decades of the twentieth century, the increasing economic importance of biotechnology and the introduction of new legislation concerning the use of and access to biological resources has subjected exchanges of genetic resources to greater controls. Their access and distribution are more strictly regulated and, therefore, exchanges are becoming more and more formalized. This paper analyzes one of the main drivers of the movement toward more formal worldwide exchange regimes, which is increasing global interdependency of access to genetic resources. Its main finding is that formalization of exchange practices as such is not necessarily leading to more restrictive licensing conditions. The goal of further formalization and harmonization of institutional frameworks should therefore be to provide the broadest possible access to essential research materials (within the constraints set by biosecurity and quality management requirements), while maximizing the reciprocity benefits of access and exchange (which motivate the exchange practices to start with).

Download full-text


Available from: Tom Dedeurwaerdere, Jun 30, 2014
  • Source
    • "In any other cases of intended use the user has to negotiate the terms with the appropriate authorities in the source country. The MTA covers the transfer of material among scientist working on joint projects (Dedeurwaerdere 2010). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Access and benefit-sharing (ABS) is a market-based approach aimed at preserving biodiversity. Its effectiveness has been questioned in international discussions for many years. It is evident that the approach’s success has fallen far short of what was expected: degradation of biodiversity continues, and only few benefits arising from the commercial use of biodiversity have been shared with the providers of biodiversity. The reason for this failure is a lack of incentives. However, an analytical assessment of the effectiveness of the concept is lacking so far. The present paper raises the question how ABS must be designed in order to be effective while also helping to protect biodiversity and promote a fair and equitable sharing of benefits arising from its commercialization. This paper identifies six critical factors that determine the effectiveness of ABS governance and discusses under what circumstances a critical factor increases or decreases in effectiveness. Furthermore, the paper analyses so-called countermeasures that impact on these circumstances. In specifying the critical factors and their interplay with the countermeasures, the paper gives guidance on how to develop more effective ABS regimes. KeywordsAccess and benefit-sharing (ABS)–Convention on Biological Diversity–Biodiversity protection–Regime effectiveness–Institutional economics
    Biodiversity and Conservation 09/2011; 20(10):2243-2261. DOI:10.1007/s10531-011-0086-0 · 2.07 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "These research collections play an important role in the overall research cycle, because this is where the first selection and screening of reference materials is undertaken. On average, deposits from these research collections represent 30% of the yearly accession of new holdings in the public culture collections, while both academia (58%) and the private sector (23%) are important recipients from cultures of the public culture collections (Dedeurwaerdere, 2010a). Many of the services provided by BRCs and knowledge accumulated in these institutions are relatively unknown to the applied microbiologist or scientist. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Rapidly growing global networking has induced and supported an increased interest in the life sciences in such general issues as health, climate change, food security and biodiversity. Therefore, the need to address and share research data and materials in a systematic way emerged almost simultaneously. This movement has been described as the so-called global research commons. Also in microbiology, where the sharing of microbiological materials is a key issue, microbial commons is attracting attention. Microbiology is currently facing great challenges with the advances of high throughput screening and next-generation whole genome sequencing. Furthermore, the exploration and use of microorganisms in agriculture and food production are increasing so as to safeguard global food and feed production. Further to several meetings on the subject, a special issue of Research in Microbiology is dedicated to Microbial Research Commons with a series of reviews elaborating its major pay-offs and needs in basic and applied microbiology. This paper gives an introduction to these articles covering a range of topics. These include the role of public culture collections and biological resource centers and legal aspects in the exchange of materials, microbial classification, an internet-based platform for data-sharing, applications in agriculture and food production, and challenges in metagenomics and extremophile research.
    Research in Microbiology 07/2010; 161(6):407-13. DOI:10.1016/j.resmic.2010.06.001 · 2.83 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The deregulation and restructuring of the electric utility industry promise to transform the delivery of power and energy services. A number of new distributed generated technologies are currently available offering a combination of performance and flexibility. Distributed generation is favored particularly because of increased energy efficiency and reduced emission. These distributed generation technologies may offer improved service reliability and better economies from the customer's viewpoint, whereas, from the utilities point of view, the economic benefit needs to be balanced against safety and operational concerns. In this paper, distributed generation system reliability is evaluated to have balancing reliability and cost benefits using industrial reliability software, distributed industrial system reliability evaluation algorithm (DISREL) for validation of the reliability assessment module and tested on a 32-bus distribution system and simulated for various case studies. The distribution system reliability is evaluated based on various reliability indices.
    Transmission and Distribution Conference and Exposition, 2003 IEEE PES; 10/2003
Show more