Targeting the affordability of cigarettes: a new benchmark for taxation policy in low-income and-middle-income countries

International Tobacco Control Research Program, American Cancer Society, Atlanta, GA 30303, USA.
Tobacco control (Impact Factor: 5.15). 08/2010; 19(4):325-30. DOI: 10.1136/tc.2009.030155
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT To investigate the appropriateness of tax incidence (the percentage of the retail price occupied by taxes) benchmarking in low-income and-middle-income countries (LMICs) with rapidly growing economies and to explore the viability of an alternative tax policy rule based on the affordability of cigarettes.
The paper outlines criticisms of tax incidence benchmarking, particularly in the context of LMICs. It then considers an affordability-based benchmark using relative income price (RIP) as a measure of affordability. The RIP measures the percentage of annual per capita GDP required to purchase 100 packs of cigarettes. Using South Africa as a case study of an LMIC, future consumption is simulated using both tax incidence benchmarks and affordability benchmarks.
I show that a tax incidence benchmark is not an optimal policy tool in South Africa and that an affordability benchmark could be a more effective means of reducing tobacco consumption in the future.
Although a tax incidence benchmark was successful in increasing prices and reducing tobacco consumption in South Africa in the past, this approach has drawbacks, particularly in the context of a rapidly growing LMIC economy. An affordability benchmark represents an appropriate alternative that would be more effective in reducing future cigarette consumption.

Download full-text


Available from: Evan Harold Blecher, May 18, 2015
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: General practitioners (GPs) working as clinical teachers are likely to influence medical students' level of community-based learning. This paper aimed to ascertain clinical teachers' views in relation to The University of Auckland about their clinical learning environment. A total of 34 clinical teachers working in primary care contributed to this study. To gauge their level of involvement in teaching and learning, the clinical teachers were asked about issues such as their confidence, available time, sufficient clinical learning opportunities, clear learning objectives to teach students and what they would like changed. The GPs appeared confident, felt there were sufficient learning opportunities for students and that their students were part of the team. Less experienced teachers expressed less confidence than more experienced peers. There was some hesitancy in terms of coping with time and feedback. Some clinical teachers were unclear about the learning objectives presented to students. Several issues that emerged--including available time and financial rewards--are difficult to resolve. Curriculum and selection are evolving issues requiring constant monitoring and alignment with increasing numbers of students studying medicine, increased ethical awareness, more diverse teaching systems and more advanced technologies. Non-faculty clinicians need adequate representation on curriculum committees and involvement in clinical education initiatives. Issues of cultural competency and professional development were raised, suggesting the need for more established links between university and GPs.
    Journal of primary health care 01/2011; 3(4):298-306.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Effective immunisation programmes require a stable cold chain to maintain potency of vaccines from national stores through to delivery sites. To assess the effectiveness of the New Zealand cold chain and examine the possible impacts of policy changes over the same time period on cold chain effectiveness. Heat- and freeze-sensitive monitors were attached to 5% of randomly selected childhood vaccines from 2002 to 2008. Six-monthly reports on data collected from monitor cards were collated and analysed to look for changes over time in freeze and heat exposure failures for vaccines. From December 2002 to June 2008 a total of 21,431 monitor cards were included in vaccines distributed from the national store; 9474 (44.2%) of all cards were returned and 8249 (38.5% of total) were correctly completed. Over this period the percentage of valid returns recorded as heat exposed decreased from 38% to 7% (χ² 371, p<0.001); heat failures decreased from 3% to 0.3% (χ² 371, p<0.0001); freeze failures decreased from 16% to 2% (χ² 134.228, p<0.0001), and overall wastage from 17% to 2% (χ² 163.83, p<0.0001), giving estimated annual savings of nearly NZ$4 million. Significant improvements can be made in cold chain management with resulting savings in vaccine wastage. This study demonstrates that such improvements have been made in New Zealand in recent years. This is likely to be due to a combination of improving equipment, systems, education and training, increased provider attention and quality standards.
    Journal of primary health care 01/2011; 3(4):278-82.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Clinical reminders have been shown to help general practice achieve an increase in some preventive care items, especially if they identify a patient's eligibility for the target item, prompt clinicians at the right time, provide a fast link to management tools and facilitate clinical recording. WRPHO has introduced the Patient Dashboard clinical reminder and monitored its impact on health targets. This paper reports the impact of a computerised colour-coded clinical reminder on achieving agreed health targets in Whanganui regional practices. Patient Dashboard was developed from previous versions in Auckland and Northland and provided to Whanganui regional practices with Primary Health Organisation (PHO) support. The Dashboard was linked with existing and new clinical management tools which automatically updated clinical records. Data from practices was pooled by Whanganui Regional Primary Health Organisation and target achievement rates reported over 15 months. Over the initial 15 months of Patient Dashboard use, recording of smoking status increased from 74% to 82% and of alcohol use from 15% to 47%. Screening for diabetes increased from 62% to 74%, cardiovascular risk assessment from 20% to 43%, cervical screening from 71% to 79%, and breast screening from 60% to 80%. Patient Dashboard was associated with increased performance indicators both for those targets which were part of a PHO programme and for targets without additional support.
    Journal of primary health care 01/2011; 3(4):307-10.