Species Delimitation: A Case Study in a Problematic Ant Taxon

Department of Entomology, University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602, USA.
Systematic Biology (Impact Factor: 14.39). 03/2010; 59(2):162-84. DOI: 10.1093/sysbio/syp089
Source: PubMed


Species delimitation has been invigorated as a discipline in systematics by an influx of new character sets, analytical methods, and conceptual advances. We use genetic data from 68 markers, combined with distributional, bioclimatic, and coloration information, to hypothesize boundaries of evolutionarily independent lineages (species) within the widespread and highly variable nominal fire ant species Solenopsis saevissima, a member of a species group containing invasive pests as well as species that are models for ecological and evolutionary research. Our integrated approach uses diverse methods of analysis to sequentially test whether populations meet specific operational criteria (contingent properties) for candidacy as morphologically cryptic species, including genetic clustering, monophyly, reproductive isolation, and occupation of distinctive niche space. We hypothesize that nominal S. saevissima comprises at least 4-6 previously unrecognized species, including several pairs whose parapatric distributions implicate the development of intrinsic premating or postmating barriers to gene flow. Our genetic data further suggest that regional genetic differentiation in S. saevissima has been influenced by hybridization with other nominal species occurring in sympatry or parapatry, including the quite distantly related Solenopsis geminata. The results of this study illustrate the importance of employing different classes of genetic data (coding and noncoding regions and nuclear and mitochondrial DNA [mtDNA] markers), different methods of genetic data analysis (tree-based and non-tree based methods), and different sources of data (genetic, morphological, and ecological data) to explicitly test various operational criteria for species boundaries in clades of recently diverged lineages, while warning against over reliance on any single data type (e.g., mtDNA sequence variation) when drawing inferences.


Available from: Marina S Ascunce
  • Source
    • "Low genetic distance (498.3% identity) between M. japanica and M. mobular suggests a sister-cryptic species complex (Bickford et al., 2007; Ross et al., 2010), and supports two separate devil ray taxonomic units. Morphological differences between M. japanica and M. mobular appear to be limited to tenuous differences in tooth morphology (Adnet et al., 2012), but genetic distance data suggest a recent speciation rather than phenotypic plasticity of an isolated population (Price et al., 2003). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The giant devil ray, Mobula mobular, is a member of one of the most distinct groups of cartilaginous fishes, the Mobulidae (manta and devil rays), and is the only mobulid assessed as Endangered due its restricted distribution, high bycatch mortality and suspected population decline. The complete mitochondrial genome is 18 913 base pairs in length and comprises 2 rRNAs, 13 protein-coding genes, 22 tRNAs and 2 non-coding regions. Comparison with the partial mitogenome of M. japanica suggests a sister-cryptic species complex and two different taxonomic units. However, the limited divergence within the species (>99.9% genetic identity) may be the result of a geographically and numerically restricted population of M. mobular within the Mediterranean Sea.
    Mitochondrial DNA 08/2015; DOI:10.3109/19401736.2015.1074208 · 1.21 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Standing among very few eusocial groups of insects, ants play a ground role in providing ecological services in many terrestrial ecosystems. Despite simplified morphological structure in workers caste, ants pose serious challenges for traditional taxonomy due to high or/and complex intraspecific morphological variations (Ross et al. 2010; Blaimer 2012). Although there are some successful examples of using distance-based barcodes in ants (e.g. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: DNA barcoding has emerged as a routine tool in modern taxonomy. Although straightforward, this approach faces new challenges, when applied to difficult situation such as defining cryptic biodiversity. Ants are prime examples for high degrees of cryptic biodiversity due to complex population differentiation, hybridization and speciation processes. Here, we test the DNA barcoding region, cytochrome c oxidase 1 and two supplementary markers, 28S ribosomal DNA and long-wavelength rhodopsin, commonly used in ant taxonomy, for their potential in a layered, character-based barcoding approach across different taxonomic levels. Furthermore, we assess performance of the character-based barcoding approach to determine cryptic species diversity in ants. We found (i) that the barcode potential of a specific genetic marker varied widely among taxonomic levels in ants; (ii) that application of a layered, character-based barcode for identification of specimens can be a solution to taxonomical challenging groups; (iii) that the character-based barcoding approach allows us to differentiate specimens even within locations based on pure characters. In summary, (layered) character-based barcoding offers a reliable alternative for problematic species identification in ants, and can be used as a fast and cost-efficient approach to estimate presence, absence or frequency of cryptic species. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
    Molecular Ecology Resources 02/2015; 15(6). DOI:10.1111/1755-0998.12395 · 3.71 Impact Factor
    • "Recent studies have applied new analytical techniques that combine morphology with molecular data (Wiens & Penkrot, 2002; Page, Choy & Hughes, 2005; Birky et al., 2011), and morphometrics has also proven to be a powerful tool for detecting morphological variation commonly overlooked by traditional methods (Roe & Sperling, 2007; Milankov et al., 2009; Lumley & Sperling, 2010). Other studies infer evolutionary mechanisms of cryptic lineage divergence by integrating geographical and ecological criteria in order to test species boundaries hypotheses (Bond & Stockman, 2008; Ross et al., 2010; Arribas et al., 2013; Weigand et al., 2013). Proponents of DNA taxonomy have established new methods using single genes, or exclusive molecular data, for tackling species delimitation problems and, in part, as an effort to expedite cryptic species discovery. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Evaluating species boundaries remains a significant challenge in rare, difficult to collect, and/or understudied groups because of a lack of available data. Uninformative morphology, unknown ecologies and/or geographical distributions, inadequate comparative sequence data, and limited sample sizes present substantial challenges when applying commonly used methods for species delimitation. Here we present an approach that overcomes the challenges previously mentioned by integrating phylogeny, genetic distances, and a fixed diagnostic character (i.e. colour pattern) into the species delimitation process. The genus Entomobrya (Collembola) includes many species marked by complex and variable colour patterns. Many Entomobrya species have been named based exclusively on colour pattern, but the value of this character as a species-level diagnostic marker has been challenged. To test the hypothesis that colour forms in Entomobrya represent independent evolutionary lineages, i.e. distinct species, we used phylogenetic methods to evaluate the association between colour pattern and molecular variation in the cytochrome c oxidase I gene (COI) in 11 species of North American Entomobrya. The comparative analysis focused on 13 colour forms distributed amongst the species Entomobrya assuta, Entomobrya clitellaria, Entomobrya ligata, and Entomobrya quadrilineata. Phylogenetic analysis and genetic divergences sorted the 13 colour forms into seven independent evolutionary lineages, including three morphologically cryptic lineages diagnosable by colour pattern. However, genetic divergence did not always correlate with colour pattern variation, indicating that the diagnostic utility of colour pattern is species dependent and requires individual evaluation for each species. We propose that incorporation of the explicit species delimitation criteria developed for this study will result in a substantial advance in the identification and description of species in understudied taxa.
    Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 02/2015; 173(4). DOI:10.1111/zoj.12220 · 2.72 Impact Factor
Show more