Cause-specific mortality patterns among hospital deaths in Thailand: Validating routine death certification

School of Population Health, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia. .
Population Health Metrics (Impact Factor: 2.11). 05/2010; 8(1):12. DOI: 10.1186/1478-7954-8-12
Source: PubMed


In Thailand, 35% of all deaths occur in hospitals, and the cause of death is medically certified by attending physicians. About 15% of hospital deaths are registered with nonspecific diagnoses, despite the potential for greater accuracy using information available from medical records. Further, issues arising from transcription of diagnoses from Thai to English at registration create uncertainty about the accuracy of registration data even for specified causes of death. This paper reports findings from a study to measure validity of registered diagnoses in a sample of deaths that occurred in hospitals in Thailand during 2005.
A sample of 4,644 hospital deaths was selected, and for each case, medical records were reviewed. A process of medical record abstraction, expert physician review, and independent adjudication for the selection and coding of underlying causes of death was used to derive reference diagnoses. Validation characteristics were computed for leading causes of hospital deaths from registration data, and misclassification patterns were identified for registration diagnoses. Study findings were used to estimate cause-specific mortality patterns for hospital deaths in Thailand.
Adequate medical records were available for 3,316 deaths in the study sample. Losses to follow up were nondifferential by age, sex, and cause. Medical records review identified specific underlying causes for the majority of deaths that were originally assigned ill-defined causes as well as for those originally assigned to residual categories for specific cause groups. In comparison with registration data for the sample, we found an increase in the relative proportion of deaths in hospitals due to stroke, ischemic heart disease, transport accidents, HIV/AIDS, diabetes, liver diseases, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
Registration data on causes for deaths occurring in hospitals require periodic validation prior to their use for epidemiological research or public health policy. Procedures for death certification and coding of underlying causes of death need to be streamlined to improve reliability of registration data. Estimates of cause-specific mortality from this research will inform burden of disease estimation and guide interventions to reduce avoidable mortality in hospitals in Thailand.

Download full-text


Available from: Junya Angsachon Pattaraarchachai,
  • Source
    • "In this case, the reliability of causes of death at registration remains uncertain and data should be handled carefully for epidemiological surveys and health policy. For deaths occurring in hospitals, 15% are registered with non-specific diagnoses (Pattaraarchachai et al., 2010). This lack of data on cause-of-death raises the possibility, for some specific diseases, of unreported human cases where pathogens and their reservoirs and vectors, have been identified in the environment and animal population. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Zoonoses are an issue of growing interest in South-East Asia, where environmental factors and socio-economic context favor the endemization of well-known diseases and the emergence of new pathogens at the human-wildlife interface. However, the health status of the region with respect to many zoonotic diseases remains poorly defined, despite the high overall burden of zoonoses on the countries of the area, and the global risk of new biological threats in the region. The first objective of this paper was to provide an update of data on the zoonoses commonly described by the scientific community and reported by governmental institutions and international organizations in continental South-East Asia. The analysis of the available data led to the identification of some trends in the evolution of the diseases, as well as some gaps in knowledge and in the current surveillance and control networks. In light of these findings, we discuss measures for effectively addressing zoonotic disease issues in South-East Asia, such as the allocation of funds for research and for surveillance and control programs, and a multi-sectoral and multi-disciplinary approach at various levels.
    Animal Health Research Reviews 06/2013; 14(01):40-67. DOI:10.1017/S1466252313000017
  • Source
    • "By law, each death must be notified within 24 h to the Bureau of Registration and Administration (BORA). For deaths that occur in hospitals, and unnatural deaths outside hospitals, a physician records one cause of death in Thai that is sent electronically to the national registration database (Pattaraarchachai et al. 2010). For natural deaths outside hospitals, the local registrars record one cause of death in Thai after inquiring the cause of death from the family. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This study provides strong evidence from an LMIC that urbanization is associated with mortality from three lifestyle-associated diseases at an ecological level. Furthermore, our data suggest that both average household income and number of doctors per population are important factors to consider in ecological analyses of mortality. Cette étude fournit des preuves solides à partir d'un pays à revus faibles et intermédiaires que l'urbanisation est associée à la mortalité dans trois maladies associées au style de vie à un niveau écologique. En outre, nos données suggèrent que le revenu moyen du ménage et le nombre de médecins par habitant sont des facteurs importants à prendre en compte dans les analyses écologiques de la mortalité. Este estudio provee evidencia sólida de un país en vías de desarrollo de que la urbanización está relacionada con la mortalidad por tres enfermedades asociadas al estilo de vida a nivel ecológico. Más aún, nuestros datos sugieren que tanto los ingresos promedio del hogar como el número de médicos por habitante son factores importantes que considerar en los análisis ecológicos de mortalidad.
    Tropical Medicine & International Health 12/2012; 18(2). DOI:10.1111/tmi.12038 · 2.33 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "We used the best available RTI data for estimating the burden of RTIs in Thailand in an effort to avoid the limitations that often affect studies in low- and middle-income countries, such as underenumeration, limited reporting systems, and large uncertainties in the number of cases and deaths from specific causes of injury [5]. First, estimates of the number of fatal RTIs were obtained from the recent cause of death study [18,19]. This study reduced the number of deaths attributed to ill-defined codes and those missed through underregistration, major limitations of fatal RTI data in Thailand and other developing countries [5,16,29]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This study quantifies the burden of road traffic injuries (RTIs) in Thailand in 2004, incorporating new Thai data on mortality and the frequency and severity of long-term disability. We quantified the uncertainty around national RTI mortality estimates based on a verbal autopsy study that was conducted to correct for the large proportion of ill-defined deaths in the vital registration system. The number of nonfatal RTI victims was estimated using hospital and survey data. We used the proportion and severity of long-term disabilities from a recent Thai study, instead of the standard Global Burden of Disease assumptions, to calculate the burden due to long-term disability. To evaluate changes over time, we also calculated the burden of RTIs in 2004 using the method and assumptions used in 1999, when standard Global Burden of Disease assumptions were used. The total loss of disability-adjusted life years due to RTIs was 673,000 (95% uncertainty interval [UI]: 546,000-881,000). Mortality contributed 88% of this burden. The use of local data led to a significantly higher estimate of the burden of long-term disability due to RTIs (74,000 DALYs [95% UI: 55,400-88,500] vs. 43,000 [UI: 42,700-43,600]) using standard Global Burden of Disease methods. However, this difference constituted only a small proportion of the total burden. The burden of RTIs in 2004 remained at the same high level as in 1999. The use of local data on the long-term health consequences of RTIs enabled an estimate of this burden and its uncertainty that is likely to be more valid.
    Population Health Metrics 01/2011; 9(1):2. DOI:10.1186/1478-7954-9-2 · 2.11 Impact Factor
Show more