Root-zone salinity: II. Indices for tolerance in agricultural crops

Crop Science (Impact Factor: 1.58). 10/2005; 45:221-232.
Source: OAI


This paper provides the tools for distinguishing levels of tolerance to root-zone salinity in agricultural crops. Such distinction rests on the response of a crop's product yield following the declining, sigmoid-shaped, modified compound-discount function (Y(r) = 1/1 + (C/C50)exp(sC50)) for plants grown as crops exposed to increasing root-zone salinity. This nonlinear function relates relative yield (Y(r)) to root-zone salinity (C) measured in equivalent saturated soil-paste extract electrical conductivity with two nonlinear parameters, the salinity level producing 50% of the nonsaline crop yield (C50) and a response curve steepness constant (s) equal to the absolute value of the mean dY(r)/dC from Y(r) = 0.3 to 0.7. These discount parameters suggest the existence of a single-value salinity tolerance index (ST-Index) equal to the 50% reduction in crop yield from that of the nonsaline yield plus a tendency to maintain some product yield as the crop is subjected to salinity levels approaching C50, i.e., ST-Index = C50 + s(C50). The explicit purpose of this study is to determine if the discount function using biophysically relevant parameters can be applied to historical data sets. Approximations for C50 and s were identified in the threshold salinity (C(t)) and declining slope (b) parameters of the well-known threshold-slope linear response function. Several procedures for converting C(t) to C50 and b to s offer the linkage between these linear and nonlinear response functions. From these procedures, two regression equations, C50 = 0.988(0.5/b) + C(t) - 0.252 and s = 1.52b, proved the most appropriate for the eight representative field, forage, and vegetable crops tested. The selected conversion procedures were applied to previously published C(t) and b values to obtain a list of the relative root-zone salinity tolerance in agricultural crops. In addition to C50 and s, values for exp(sC50) and the ST-Index were computed for each crop. The revised list provides extension personnel and plant growth modelers the parameter values from a nonlinear analog of crop yield response to root-zone salinity.

Download full-text


Available from: Martinus Th. Van Genuchten,
    • "At the same level of root zone salinity, the yield of legumes tends to be more affected than that of cereals (Katerji et al., 2011). Information on their salinity threshold levels and slope of yield decline with salinity is extremely limited (Steppuhn et al., 2005) and old (Ayers and Eberhard, 1960). Growing food legumes and evaluating their growth and yield response in the Mediterranean region under saline conditions is important because of (i) scarcity of freshwater resources to grow food legume crops; (ii) increasing areas of irrigated land under salt-affected soils and/or irrigated with saline water in the semi-arid and arid areas; and (iii) increasing demand for food legumes due to increasing meat prices, the need to meet human requirements for protein from food legumes, and population growth. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The information on salinity threshold levels for food legumes when irrigating with saline water is limited and old. In a multi-year study at two sites in the Euphrates Basin, we aimed at (i) evaluating the potential of saline water irrigation for chickpea, faba bean and lentil production; and (ii) using the SALTMED model to determine threshold crop yields based on irrigation water salinity in equilibrium with ambient soil solution salinity. To evaluate 15 accessions each of lentil and chickpea, and 11 accessions of faba bean, three irrigation treatments were used with salinity levels of 0.87, 2.50 and 3.78 dS m-1 at Hassake and 0.70, 3.0 and 5.0 dS m-1 at Raqqa. Aggregated grain yields showed significant differences (p < 0.05) among crop accessions. Calibration and validation of the SALTMED model revealed a close relationship between actual grain yields from the field sites and those predicted by the model. The 50% yield reduction (π50 value) in chickpea, lentil, and faba bean occurred at salinity levels of 4.2, 4.4 and 5.2 dS m-1, respectively. These results suggest that of the three food legume crops, faba bean can withstand relatively high levels of irrigation water salinity, followed by lentil and chickpea.
    Irrigation and Drainage 03/2015; DOI:10.1002/ird.1912 · 0.72 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Surface water used for irrigation comes from the Kongque River, whose water quality is affected by nearby Bosten Lake and has electrical conductivity (EC) values generally between 0.9 and 1.6 dS/m (He et al. 2010). Groundwater, having EC values between about 3–5 dS/m (see Table 1), is used often also for irrigation of cotton, which is known to have a relatively high tolerance for salinity (Maas 1990; Vulkan-Levy et al. 1998; Henggeler 2004; Steppuhn et al. 2005; Chen et al. 2010). The sodium adsorption ratio (SAR) of irrigation water ranged from 3.77 to 9.97. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Field experiments were conducted in arid Southern Xinjiang, Northwest China, for 3 years to evaluate sustainable irrigation regimes for cotton. The experiments involved mulched drip irrigation during the growing season and flood irrigation afterward. The drip irrigation experiments included control experiments, experiments with deficit irrigation during one crop growth stage, and alternative irrigation schemes in which freshwater was used during one growth stage and relatively saline water in the others. The average cotton yield over 3 years varied between 3,575 and 5,095 kg/ha, and the irrigation water productivity between 0.91 and 1.16 kg/m3. Crop sensitivities to water stress during the different growth stages ranged from early flowering-belling (most sensitive) > seedling > budding > late flowering-belling (least sensitive), while sensitivities to salt stress ranged from late flowering-belling > budding > seedling > early flowering-belling. Although mulched drip irrigation during the growing season caused an increase in salinity in the root zone, flood irrigation after harvesting leached the accumulated salts to below background levels. Numerical simulations, based on the 3-year experiments and extended by another 20 years, suggest that mulched drip irrigation using alternatively fresh and brackish water during the growing season and flood irrigation with freshwater after harvesting is a sustainable irrigation practice that should not lead to soil salinization.
    Irrigation Science 01/2014; 32(1). DOI:10.1007/s00271-013-0409-x · 2.06 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Cubic regression curves were fitted to growth (stem extension rate and shoot ethanol-insoluble DM) and stomatal conductance data because these best describe the growth pattern expected for a dicotyledonous halophyte in response to increasing salinity, incorporating an optimum at moderate salinities (cf. Flowers and Colmer, 2008) with decreases in growth at salinities above the optimum (cf. the compound discount curve of Steppuhn et al., 2005). In contrast, visual inspection of the relationships between leaf Na+ or shoot water potential against external salinity showed that simple linear and quadratic relationships, respectively, could be fitted to these data (see the Results). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Soil salinity is generally spatially heterogeneous, but our understanding of halophyte physiology under such conditions is limited. The growth and physiology of the dicotyledonous halophyte Atriplex nummularia was evaluated in split-root experiments to test whether growth is determined by: (i) the lowest; (ii) the highest; or (iii) the mean salinity of the root zone. In two experiments, plants were grown with uniform salinities or horizontally heterogeneous salinities (10–450mM NaCl in the low-salt side and 670mM in the high-salt side, or 10mM NaCl in the low-salt side and 500–1500mM in the high-salt side). The combined data showed that growth and gas exchange parameters responded most closely to the root-weighted mean salinity rather than to the lowest, mean, or highest salinity in the root zone. In contrast, midday shoot water potentials were determined by the lowest salinity in the root zone, consistent with most water being taken from the least negative water potential source. With uniform salinity, maximum shoot growth was at 120–230mM NaCl; ~90% of maximum growth occurred at 10mM and 450mM NaCl. Exposure of part of the roots to 1500mM NaCl resulted in an enhanced (+40%) root growth on the low-salt side, which lowered root-weighted mean salinity and enabled the maintenance of shoot growth. Atriplex nummularia grew even with extreme salinity in part of the roots, as long as the root-weighted mean salinity of the root zone was within the 10–450mM range.
    Journal of Experimental Botany 11/2012; 63(18). DOI:10.1093/jxb/ers302 · 5.53 Impact Factor
Show more