Effects of a symptom-free waiting period on clinical outcome and risk of reinjury after sport-related concussion

Neuroscience Center, Waukesha Memorial Hospital, Waukesha, Wisconsin 53188, USA.
Neurosurgery (Impact Factor: 3.62). 11/2009; 65(5):876-82; discussion 882-3. DOI: 10.1227/01.NEU.0000350155.89800.00
Source: PubMed


This study is the first to investigate the influence of a symptom-free waiting period (SFWP) on clinical outcome and risk of repeat injury after sport-related concussion.
This was a prospective, nonrandomized study of 16 624 player seasons from 1999 to 2004, including a cohort of 635 concussed high school and college athletes grouped on the basis of an SFWP or no SFWP observed after their concussion. Clinical outcome in symptoms, cognitive functioning, and postural stability 45 and 90 days postinjury was compared with preinjury baseline. Data on SFWP and same-season repeat concussion were recorded.
An SFWP was observed in 60.3% of cases. There were no significant differences between the SFWP and no SFWP groups in acute injury characteristics or clinical outcome with respect to symptom recovery or postinjury performance on formal neuropsychological and balance testing. Most repeat concussions (79.2%) occurred within 10 days of the initial injury. The rate of repeat concussion was actually higher in the SFWP group (6.49%) than the no SFWP group (0.90%) (P < 0.005), but the repeat concussion subgroup's SFWP was 2.82 days shorter (95% confidence interval, 0.61-5.03; P < 0.01) and these athletes resumed participation 3.55 days sooner (95% confidence interval, 0.06-7.04; P < 0.05) than those in the SFWP group in which there was no repeat concussion.
Our findings suggest that an SFWP did not intrinsically influence clinical recovery or reduce risk of a repeat concussion. The overall risk of same-season repeat concussion seems to be relatively low, but there may be a period of vulnerability that increases risk of repeat concussion during the first 7 to 10 days postinjury. Further study is required to investigate this preliminary finding and help determine whether this risk can be reduced further with specific injury-management strategies.

Download full-text


Available from: William B Barr,
  • Source
    • "Since this cerebral vulnerability is thought to last beyond the window of observable clinical recovery (Aubry et al. 2002; McCrory et al. 2005), most guidelines recommend waiting several days after symptom resolution to return to play. Despite the theoretical support for a SFWP, only one large-scale prospective study has investigated the assumption that a SFWP affects clinical outcome (McCrea et al. 2009). Counter-intuitively, the rate of repeat concussion was higher in the SFWP group (6.49 "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Concussion is a highly prevalent injury in contact and collision sports that has historically been poorly understood. An influx of sport-concussion research in recent years has led to a dramatic improvement in our understanding of the injury's defining characteristics and natural history of recovery. In this review, we discuss the current state of knowledge regarding the characteristic features of concussion and typical acute course of recovery, with an emphasis on the aspects of functioning most commonly assessed by clinicians and researchers (e.g., symptoms, cognitive deficits, postural stability). While prototypical clinical recovery is becoming better understood, questions remain regarding what factors (e.g., injury severity, demographic variables, history of prior concussions, psychological factors) may explain individual variability in recovery. Although research concerning individual differences in response to concussion is relatively new, and in many cases limited methodologically, we discuss the evidence about several potential moderators of concussion recovery and point out areas for future research. Finally, we describe how increased knowledge about the negative effects of and recovery following concussion has been translated into clinical guidelines for managing concussed athletes.
    Neuropsychology Review 11/2013; 23(4). DOI:10.1007/s11065-013-9240-7 · 4.59 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Rapid assessment is needed in the military theater and on the playing field to determine if it is safe for the soldier or athlete to return to his or her unit or team. Indeed, studies in high school and college football players suggest that there may be a period of increased vulnerability to repeat concussion for 7–10 days after a concussion [28]. In the military theater, screening is complicated because TBI occurs in the context of sleep deprivation, nutritional changes, emotional stress, polytrauma, and difficult environmental factors. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Traumatic brain injury (TBI) and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are signature injuries of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and have been linked to an increased risk of Alzheimer's disease (AD) and other dementias. A meeting hosted by the Alzheimer's Association and the Veterans' Health Research Institute (NCIRE) in May 2012 brought together experts from the U.S. military and academic medical centers around the world to discuss current evidence and hypotheses regarding the pathophysiological mechanisms linking TBI, PTSD, and AD. Studies underway in civilian and military populations were highlighted, along with new research initiatives such as a study to extend the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) to a population of veterans exposed to TBI and PTSD. Greater collaboration and data sharing among diverse research groups is needed to advance an understanding and appropriate interventions in this continuum of military injuries and neurodegenerative disease in the aging veteran.
    Alzheimer's & dementia: the journal of the Alzheimer's Association 07/2013; 9(4):445-51. DOI:10.1016/j.jalz.2013.03.005 · 12.41 Impact Factor
    • "Several authors have suggested there is likely a critical window that increases the likelihood of a repeat concussion in humans within the first 7–10 days post injury.[5793] Rodent models have demonstrated that when the animals were subjected to a second mTBI within 5 days of the initial injury, the axonal injury, astrocytic activity, and memory impairment were significantly worse than the animals with only a single injury. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: There has been a tremendous amount of interest focused on the topic of concussions over the past few decades. Neurosurgeons are frequently consulted to manage patients with mild traumatic brain injuries (mTBI) that have radiographic evidence of cerebral injury. These injuries share significant overlap with concussions, injuries that typically do not reveal radiographic evidence of structural injury, in the realms of epidemiology, pathophysiology, outcomes, and management. Further, neurosurgeons often manage patients with extracranial injuries that have concomitant concussions. In these cases, neurosurgeons are often the only "concussion experts" that patients encounter. The literature has been reviewed and data have been synthesized on the topic including sections on historical background, epidemiology, pathophysiology, diagnostic advances, clinical sequelae, and treatment suggestions, with neurosurgeons as the intended target audience. Neurosurgeons should have a fundamental knowledge of the scientific evidence that has developed regarding concussions and be prepared to guide patients with treatment plans.
    Surgical Neurology International 02/2012; 3(1):16. DOI:10.4103/2152-7806.92930 · 1.18 Impact Factor
Show more