Article

Performance analysis of a high-bandwidth torque disturbance compensator

Dept. of Electr. Eng., Univ. of Padova, Italy
IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics (Impact Factor: 3.65). 01/2005; DOI: 10.1109/TMECH.2004.839041
Source: IEEE Xplore

ABSTRACT Recent availability of encoder with millions of counts per revolution makes it possible to enlarge the bandwidth of the torque disturbance observer (TDO) equipping a servo drive. As a consequence, the TDO dynamics are no more decoupled from those of current and the behavior of the torque disturbance compensator (TDC) is influenced by the current dynamics as well as by the discrete-time implementation of TDO. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the TDC performance under the above-mentioned circumstances. The main outcome is the underdamped or even unstable behavior of TDC. Another outcome is the limited range of values allowable for the parameter mismatch to preserve stability. The conditions on the TDO bandwidth and the parameter mismatch for TDC to be stable and to be damped are provided. Experimental tests are given, which substantiate the theoretical findings.

0 Bookmarks
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The Disturbance Observer (DOB) is widely used in many robust control applications such as robotics and industrial automation due to its simplicity and efficiency. The DOB estimates and compensates the system disturbances by using an inner-feedback loop in the range of its bandwidth. It includes the inverse of the nominal system model and a low pass filter (LPF) which determines the bandwidth of the DOB. The dynamic characteristic and bandwidth of the LPF directly affect the robust stability and performance of the system. The dynamic characteristic of the LPF can be adjusted by using Higher Order Disturbance Observers (HODOB). The bandwidth of the DOB is demanded to be as high as possible to suppress the system disturbances in a wide frequency range. However, it is bounded by the noise and robustness of the system. The conventional robustness analysis method which is based on the Small Gain theorem and unstructured uncertainties, unnecessarily limits the bandwidth of the DOB due to conservatism. The conservatism can be decreased by using the structured uncertainty based robustness analysis methods. In this paper, the robust stability and performance of the system with DOB/HODOB is analyzed by using the conventional analysis method and Singular Structured Values (SSV) that is based on the structured uncertainties. The pros and cons of these methods are shown. A general second order system model is analyzed and simulation results are given to show the validity of the proposed methods.
    Human System Interactions (HSI), 2012 5th International Conference on; 01/2012
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Several studies have been performed on the robustness of the systems with the disturbance observer (DOB). These studies are generally based on the frequency domain analysis which uses unstructured uncertainty and the Small Gain theorem. However, the frequency domain analysis can be easily implemented any kind of systems and it can properly define any kind of uncertainties of the system; it suffers by the conservatism due to the nature of the Small Gain theorem. The main drawback of the conservatism on the DOB based control system is that the bandwidth of the low pass filter (LPF) of DOB is unnecessarily limited by the conservatism. It was shown that the conservatism can be decreased by using the Structured Singular Values (SSV) method. However, this analysis is not suitable to define the constraints on the LPF of DOB in properly. The real parametric uncertainty based analysis shows us that if the bandwidth of the LPF of DOB is higher than its lower bound then the system with DOB becomes stable. The real parametric uncertainty based analysis does not suffer from conservatism however it can only consider the parametric uncertainties and the computational efficiency of this method highly depends on the system structure. These results were proved in the first paper of this research. In this paper, the stability margin of the system with DOB is analyzed and it is shown that as the bandwidth of the LPF of DOB increases the stability margin of the system also increases in the presence of the real parametric uncertainties. To show the validity of the proposed method, a general second order system with the real parametric uncertainties is analyzed and the simulation results are given.
    IECON 2012 - 38th Annual Conference on IEEE Industrial Electronics Society; 01/2012
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The Disturbance Observer (DOB) guarantees the robustness of the system if the disturbances stay within the bandwidth of the DOB. Thus, high bandwidth is demanded to compensate the disturbances in a wide frequency range. The bandwidth of the DOB is limited by the noise and robustness of the system. The noise limitation depends on the measurement plant and sampling rate. The robustness limitation depends on the robustness analysis method. Conventionally, the robustness of the system with DOB is analyzed using the unstructured uncertainty and Small Gain theorem. Due to the nature of the Small Gain theorem, the conventional analysis includes conservatism. The conservatism unnecessarily limits the bandwidth of the DOB to obtain robust stability. However, the bandwidth of the DOB is demanded to be as high as possible to increase the performance of the system. In this paper the robust stability of the system with DOB is analyzed in the presence of the real parametric uncertainties. This analysis is not conservative and it gives a lower bound on the bandwidth of the DOB to obtain robust stability. The lower bound on the bandwidth of the DOB is derived for the interval and affinely linear polynomials and it shows us that the system with DOB is robustly stable if its bandwidth is higher than the lower bound in the presence of the real parametric uncertainties. The proposed method is applied to a general second order system model with the real parametric uncertainties and the simulation results are given to show the validity of the proposed method.
    Mechatronics and Automation (ICMA), 2012 International Conference on; 01/2012