El desarrollo de los procesos cognitivos: investigaciones transculturales

Estudios de Psicología (Impact Factor: 0.28). 01/1982; DOI: 10.1080/02109395.1982.10821294
Source: OAI


Mario Carretero reviews the last ten years� research work on cognitive process development from a transcultural perspective. He also delimits himself to the main investigation approaches and the most relevant methodological contributions. Among those, the author focuses on the ecological/differential tendency, reviewing as well some Piagetian contributions and the main ethnographic approach principles. The author presents a general view on transcultural investigations into perceptual development and the field independence/dependence, insisting on the ecological model and on the existing relation between some socialization practices and the above mentioned cognitive style development. To conclude, it is stressed that some common traits between different tendencies are appearing and that the most discussed methodological aspect is the one referred to which of both views, the cognitive or the correlational one, is the most adequate. Finally, he mentions the cognitive universals, maintaining that universal cognitive products almost do not exist but common processes to all cultures do, and the Evolutive Psychology supports an interactionistic approach to development. Mario Carretero revisa las investigaciones de los últimos diez años que han estudiado el desarrollo de los procesos cognitivos desde una perspectiva transcultural. También delimita los principales enfoques de investigación y las aportaciones metodológicas más pertinentes. Entre estos enfoques el autor se centra fundamentalmente en la tendencia ecológico-diferencialista, repasando también algunas investigaciones piagetianas y los principales fundamentos del enfoque etnográfico. El autor presenta una panorámica general de las investigaciones transculturales sobre el desarrollo de la percepción y la dependencia-independencia de campo, haciendo hincapié en el modelo ecológico y en la relación existente entre determinadas prácticas socializadoras y el desarrollo del citado estilo cognitivo. En las conclusiones se destaca que están apareciendo algunos rasgos comunes entre las distintas tendencias y que el aspecto metodológico más discutido es el que se refiere a cuál de los dos enfoques, experimental o correlacional, es el más adecuado. Por último alude a los universales cognitivos, sosteniendo que apenas existen productos cognitivos universales pero sí muchos procesos comunes a todas las culturas y que la psicología evolutiva transcultural está apoyando la concepción interaccionista del desarrollo.

Download full-text


Available from: Mario Carretero, Jul 14, 2014
69 Reads
  • Child Development 04/1965; 36(1):21-55. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-8624.1965.tb05281.x · 4.72 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Presents a developmental model of expected age trends and sex differences in the acquisition of 3-dimensional picture perception (3DPP). 212 Chinese males and 240 females from nursery, elementary, and secondary schools completed a battery of psychological tests, including the Chinese 3DPP Test, measures of photographic depth perception, the Chinese Socialization Scale, and the Rod and Frame Test. Data support the expected increase in 3DPP in Ss aged 3-17 and the expected superiority of males in 3DPP after age 8; these differences are thought to stem from increased testosterone output after that age, which stimulates the development of cholinergic inhibitory perceptual processes, and interacts with the appropriate cultural-educational stimuli to result in better 3DPP skills in male Ss. Lower socioeconomic levels, field dependence, "harsher" socialization, and more traditional attitudes were associated with lower 3DPP scores, while data from J. W. Berry's (see record 1967-02758-001) study of Eskimo Ss suggest that Eskimos had higher 3DPP scores than the Hong Kong Chinese. (29 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
    Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 02/1974; 5:3-22. DOI:10.1177/002202217400500101 · 1.42 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Two separate traditions of research into the Müller-Lyer illusion have existed for at least 70 years: the ecological and the developmental. To assess the ecological hypothesis, a sufficient range in visual ecology typically has been sought in cross-cultural comparisons; however, many of these comparisons have been inconclusive, especially when other ethnic variables have been held constant. These insignificant findings are considered to result from a confounding of the ecological and developmental variables. Appropriate sampling from Temne and Eskimo populations (enabling, in turn, one variable to be matched while the other is varied) demonstrates this confounding within cultures and, when eliminated, the significant influence of each variable on susceptibility to the Müller-Lyer illusion. Further work, however, is needed to discover other factors which will account for variance in susceptibility between cultures.
    British Journal of Psychology 09/1968; 59(3):205-10. DOI:10.1111/j.2044-8295.1968.tb01134.x · 2.37 Impact Factor
Show more