ArticlePDF Available

Use of the Unfolding Case Study in Teaching Nurse Educator Master of Science in Nursing Students

Authors:
Syllabus Selection Innovative Learning Activity
Use of the Unfolding Case
Study in Teaching Nurse
Educator Master of Science in
Nursing Students
Currently in nursing education, the use
of interactive and transferable strategies
to narrow the gap between nursing edu-
cation and practice is imperative (Ben-
ner, Sutphen, Leonard, & Day, 2010).
Day (2011) described one such strategy
as the use of unfolding case studies in a
subject-centered classroom, which pro-
vides students with a case that slowly
unfolds as the faculty provides additional
information, rather than giving all of the
information at once, as is often done with
traditional case studies (Palmer, 2007).
Unfolding case studies provide students
with a set of data that evolves over time,
requiring them to commit to actions
based on the information they have at
a given time (Porter-Wenzlaffs, 2013).
This type of teaching promotes connected
inquiry among students and teachers.
The unfolding story must be believable,
credible, and relevant to what the class is
to accomplish (Day, 2011). Day (2011)
described four main steps in developing
an unfolding case study, based upon the
following questions:
What is the goal of the class, and
who are the learners?
What are the content areas I want
to visit during the class?
What do I want the case to do?
Who should the patient be?
In the online Master of Science in Nurs-
ing (MSN) nursing education concentra-
tion at the author’s school, students com-
plete two practicum courses in the last
two semesters of their program of study,
in which they engage in classroom, labora-
tory, clinical, and online teaching and other
activities related to the role of the nurse
educator. In the fi rst practicum course,
students read the Carnegie Foundation’s
advancement of teaching study on nursing
education (Benner et al., 2010). Four online
discussion boards for the semester center
on the implications for nursing education.
In the second practicum course, four
online discussion boards revolve around an
unfolding case study, which was developed
to address the four questions presented by
Day (2011) and adapted to the course. The
goal is to prepare students to enter the role
of the nurse educator during a time of radi-
cal transformation in nursing education.
The content areas covered provide a type
of capstone experience and deal with real-
life issues and scenarios related to the role
of the nurse educator, which come from
the experiences of the faculty member and
other nurse educators. The four discussion
boards provide scenarios related to identi-
fying faculty mentors and moving into the
role of the nurse educator, incivility and
unprofessional behavior by a student in
the clinical setting, test analysis, and aca-
demic integrity. The purposes of using this
strategy are twofold: to provide an example
of an unfolding case study for students,
and to place students in a real-life situa-
tion related to the roles of the nurse edu-
cator and engage them in discussion about
roles and issues. The faculty wrote the case
study and questions to guide the discussion
board posts. Students respond to the guided
questions regarding each scenario and dis-
cuss issues related to the scenario with their
peers. The faculty member provides a sum-
mary response to the scenario after all stu-
dents have responded and asks additional
questions to encourage further discussion
and refl ection on the issues presented.
Students are initially provided an over-
view and scenario of the case. The sce-
nario states that they are novice nurse edu-
cators with 7 years of practice experience
in an inpatient setting, who have completed
their MSN degree, with a concentration
in nursing education, within the past year.
They have just begun in a university fac-
ulty position. They are given their teach-
ing assignment, expectations for attending
faculty meetings, offi ce hours, and other
faculty responsibilities. This scenario sets
the stage for the four discussion boards.
At the time of this writing, this assign-
ment has been used for four semesters
with approximately 30 students. The un-
folding case study discussion boards have
received positive feedback from students,
who range from novice nurse educators
to those with years of experience in nurs-
ing education. Their dialogue is at a high
level, and they support their posts with
current literature. Students refl ect on what
they experience in their role as nurse edu-
cators, and those without experience in the
role are seeing the issues discussed within
their practicum settings.
At the conclusion of the course, vol-
untary, anonymous student feedback was
requested to determine whether students
felt the assignment had been benefi cial in
preparing them for their role as nurse edu-
cators. The feedback was positive, and stu-
dents felt the assignment had opened their
eyes to issues of which they were unaware.
Over the past years, the focus of nursing
education has moved from teacher centered
to student centered. With this change in
focus, teaching strategies have evolved to
be more interactive and more closely link
theory and practice, and they promote active
student involvement and interaction (West,
Usher, & Delaney, 2012). The unfolding
case study allows for applied learning that
is dynamic and engaging and replicates
real-life scenarios that face nurse educators
(Porter-Wenzlaffs, 2013). Although unfold-
ing case studies are excellent strategies to
use to promote clinical imagination, nurs-
ing education students must understand
this strategy as they enter the nurse faculty
role. Students in this course have now had
experience in learning through an unfold-
ing case study; therefore, they may be more
willing to use this strategy as educators.
References
Benner, P., Sutphen, M., Leonard, V., & Day, L.
(2010). Educating nurses: A call for radical
transformation. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-
Bass.
Day, L. (2011). Using unfolding case studies in a
subject-centered classroom. Journal of Nurs-
ing Education, 50, 447-452.
Palmer, P.J. (2007). The courage to teach: Ex-
ploring the inner landscape of a teacher’s
life. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Porter-Wenzlaffs, L.J. (2013). Unfolding multi-
course case study: Developing students’ ad-
ministrative competencies. Nurse Educator,
38, 241-245.
West, C., Usher, K., & Delaney, L.J. (2012). Un-
folding case studies in pre-registration nurs-
ing education: Lessons learned. Nurse Edu-
cation Today, 32, 576-580.
Annette I. Peery, EdD, RN, CNE
peerya@ecu.edu
East Carolina University
Greenville, North Carolina
The author has disclosed no potential confl icts
of interest, fi nancial or otherwise.
doi:10.3928/01484834-20150217-11
180
Copyright © SLACK Incorporated
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without
permission.
... Through unfolding patient case studies, case-based learning (CBL) has the potential to facilitate nurse practitioner (NP) students' application of didactic knowledge to clinical practice, thus narrowing the theory-practice gap. Research suggests that this approach reflects real-life scenarios, supports evidence-based practice, is learner centered, and encourages students to place themselves in the role of decision maker (Horntvedt et al., 2018;Peery, 2015;Thistlethwaite et al., 2012). Health care students enjoy CBL, and virtual patient cases promote active learning and the translation of theoretical knowledge into clinical reasoning (Forsberg et al., 2019;Thistlethwaite et al., 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
Through unfolding patient case studies, case-based learning has the potential to facilitate nurse practitioner (NP) student application of didactic knowledge to clinical practice, thus narrowing the theory-practice gap. The purpose of this study was to investigate NP student experience using virtual patient cases to supplement clinical learning. Bloom's cognitive taxonomy served as the framework. Seven students enrolled in the final semester of a distance family NP program completed 45 virtual patient cases over an 8-week period. Case topics covered a variety of primary care problems. Usability of the virtual learning platform was measured by the System Usability Scale. Clinical learning value was measured by the Student Satisfaction and Self-Confidence in Learning Scale. Students rated their perceived ability to manage common primary care problems at the start and end of the 8-week period. Students found the virtual learning platform highly usable and were satisfied and self-confident with their learning. Student perceived ability to manage common primary care problems increased for all virtual case topics from start to end of course. This study provides further evidence that well-designed virtual patient cases have the potential to effectively supplement NP student clinical learning. These results are important as NP faculty look for alternative forms of clinical learning to supplement direct care clinical experiences.
... Another strategy is the unfolding case study, which can incorporate apps focused on pharmacology content into an evolving patient scenario (Peery, 2015). Many apps are available for free download, designed to work on mobile platforms, and many of these have similar web-based options. ...
Chapter
Mobile technology such as smartphones, tablets, and personal digital assistants (PDAs) allow nursing students to rapidly access current evidence-based resources at the “point of care” (POC) during the actual patient encounter. The setting can be bedside, hospital or outpatient, or telehealth. The term “mHealth” refers to the application of mobile technology in healthcare, which includes clinical nursing practice and nursing education. Web/software resources for healthcare personnel include videos, podcasts, practice guidelines, clinical calculators, clinical databases, diagnostic applications (apps), and systems navigation. Some mobile apps are designed for patients as tools for disease self-management and monitoring. Integrating this technology into the nursing curriculum supports application of knowledge and reinforces the importance of safe care and health literacy. Barriers to curriculum implementation include software and hardware cost, multiple device operating systems (OS) platforms, low technology literacy, internet connection availability, small screen size, and faculty resistance. This technology should be introduced early in the nursing curriculum. Instructors can require use/purchase of specific apps as they would require any course resource, and many free cross-platform apps are available. Examples of active learning opportunities are using case studies in the laboratory and classroom, and simulation scenarios mimicking patient encounters. These can incorporate role-modeling of healthcare team members. A theory model for this teaching innovation is based on simulation as a teaching and learning tool, identifying three themes: preparedness activation and reflection. The literature reports many studies with positive outcomes when incorporating mobile technology and POC resources in the classroom, laboratory, and community settings. These studies involve undergraduate as well as graduate nursing students, as well as healthcare students in other disciplines. In the fully online setting, POC technology can be integrated into learning activities for healthcare students at all levels. For instance, students can consult clinical databases, access clinical practice guidelines, utilize clinical calculators, and complete clinical case studies. Since role-modeling by faculty is an integral aspect of this teaching method, faculty proficiency and acceptance of the technology is essential. This validates use of mobile technology as a best practice when caring for patients in the real world. Thus, program support for faculty training is imperative, including access to the software. This type of technology is well-accepted by both students and patients and reinforces the delivery of safe, current, and evidence-based care as a best practice.
Article
A single-episode online case study increases cognitive load in contrast to an unfolding online case study, which decreases cognitive load, improves academic performance, and enhances clinical reasoning. However, online utilization of unfolding case studies is limited. A one-group pretest posttest experimental design was employed with 45 nursing students in a pathophysiology course. Data were collected using Lasater’s clinical reasoning scale and quiz scores to assess academic performance. The academic performance and clinical reasoning of nursing students were significantly higher with online unfolding case studies ( p < .001), providing support for the use of the online unfolding case study method.
Article
Full-text available
The recently published report of the Carnegie Foundation's National Study of Nursing Education points out significant problems with classroom teaching in schools of nursing. This article suggests Palmer's idea of the subject-centered classroom as a way to transform nursing school classrooms into collaborative learning communities. For Palmer, the subject is the big idea of nursing practice-the nurse-patient/client/family/community relationship-that should take the lead in stimulating inquiry and discussion. The article goes on to describe how teachers can develop and use unfolding case studies to bring the subject to the center of the classroom. By doing so, the classroom becomes a place where students learn a sense of salience, develop their clinical imagination, and begin their formation as professional nurses.
Article
Providing students with learning opportunities that integrate disparate data into meaningful constructs can be a challenge for faculty. The author discusses an unfolding case study that provided simulated learning opportunities related to administrative student competencies, staged to increase in complexity and scope over time while affording multiple student evaluation opportunities. A hybrid delivery format was used, including Blackboard Learn e-technology, to support individual student assignments and small group collaboration, cloud technology for shared student document development, Excel budget manipulation, and face-to-face classroom interactions.Providing students with learning opportunities that integrate disparate data into meaningful constructs can be a challenge for faculty. The author discusses an unfolding case study that provided simulated learning opportunities related to administrative student competencies, staged to increase in complexity and scope over time while affording multiple student evaluation opportunities. A hybrid delivery format was used, including Blackboard Learn e-technology, to support individual student assignments and small group collaboration, cloud technology for shared student document development, Excel budget manipulation, and face-to-face classroom interactions.
Article
Introduction: Teaching From Within The Heart of a Teacher: Identity and Integrity in Teaching A Culture of Fear: Education and the Disconnected Life The Hidden Wholeness: Paradox in Teaching and Learning Knowing in Community: Joined by the Grace of Great Things Teaching in Community: A Subject-Centered Education Learning in Community: The Conversation of Colleagues Divided No More: Teaching from a Heart of Hope.
The courage to teach: Exploring the inner landscape of a teacher’s life
  • P J Palmer
  • Palmer P.J.
Educating nurses: A call for radical transformation
  • P Benner
  • M Sutphen
  • V Leonard
  • L Day
  • Benner P.