Seeking for the rational basis of the median model: the optimal combination of multi-model ensemble results

Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics (Impact Factor: 4.88). 01/2007; DOI: 10.5194/acpd-7-5701-2007
Source: DOAJ

ABSTRACT In this paper we present an approach for the statistical analysis of multi-model ensemble results. The models considered here are operational long-range transport and dispersion models, also used for the real-time simulation of pollutant dispersion or the accidental release of radioactive nuclides. We first introduce the theoretical basis (with its roots sinking into the Bayes theorem) and then apply this approach to the analysis of model results obtained during the ETEX-1 exercise. We recover some interesting results, supporting the heuristic approach called "median model", originally introduced in Galmarini et al. (2004a, b). This approach also provides a way to systematically reduce (and quantify) model uncertainties, thus supporting the decision-making process and/or regulatory-purpose activities in a very effective manner.

  • Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology. 01/2009; 48(11).
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Five air quality models were applied over Portugal for July 2006 with an ensemble purpose. These models were used, with their own meteorology, parameterizations, boundary conditions and chemical mechanisms, but with the same emission data. The validation of the individual models and its ensemble for ozone (O3) and particulate matter was performed using monitoring data from 22 background stations over Portugal. After removing the bias from each model, different ensemble techniques were applied and compared. Besides the median, several weighted ensemble approaches were tested and intercompared: static (SLR) and dynamic (DLR) multiple linear regressions (using less-square optimization method) and the Bayesian Model Averaging (BMA) methodology. The goal of the comparison is to estimate to what extent the ensemble analysis is an improvement with respect to the single model results. The obtained results revealed that no one of the 4 tested ensembles clearly outperforms the others on the basis of statistical parameters and probabilistic analysis (reliability and resolution properties). Nevertheless, statistical results have shown that the application of the weights slightly improves ensemble performance when compared to those obtained from the median ensemble. The same statistical analysis together with the probabilistic measures demonstrates that the SLR and BMA methods are the best performers amongst the assessed methodologies.
    Environmental Modeling and Assessment 06/2012; 18(3). · 0.98 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In this study, an adaptive probabilistic algorithm was developed for the selection of the most plausible Kalman filter based time-varying statistical model by using Bayesian approach. The method was validated by a case study involving the prediction of the sample time series recorded in Macau between 2001 and 2005. Two types of statistical models, namely the time-varying autoregressive model of order p, abbreviated as the TVAR (p) model, and the timevarying autoregressive model with exogenous inputs, abbreviated as the TVAREX model, were adopted to predict the sample time series. By judging upon the model occurring plausibility conditional on the measured data, it was found that using a longer past history did not guarantee better prediction performance. On the contrary, inclusion of explanatory variables which reflect the mechanism of the physical problem can better capture the actual system.
    Procedia Engineering 01/2011; 14:2585-2592.

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
Jun 1, 2014