Page 1
Ghana
Studies
15/16
2012/2013
Page 2
Ghana Studies
Editors
Akosua Adomako Ampofo (University of Ghana), adomako@gmail.com
Stephan F. Miescher (University of California, Santa Barbara),
miescher@history.ucsb.edu
Editorial Board
Emmanuel Akyeampong (Harvard University)
Jean Allman (Washington University)
Gareth Austin (London School of Economics)
Lynne Brydon (University of Birmingham)
Francis Dodoo (University of Ghana and Penn State University)
Takyiwaa Manuh (University of Ghana)
T. C. McCaskie (SOAS, University of London)
Birgit Meyer (Free University, Amsterdam)
David Owusu-Ansah (James Madison University)
Mansah Prah (University of Cape Coast)
Richard Rathbone (Emeritus, SOAS, University of London)
Ray Silverman (University of Michigan)
Dzodzi Tsikata (University of Ghana)
Ivor Wilks (Emeritus, Northwestern University)
Larry Yarak (Texas A&M University)
Cover logo: “East-West” by George Kojo Arthur
(Published February 2014)
Ghana Studies is a membership benefit of the Ghana Studies Council. Otherwise all volumes are $22
each to individuals and $44 each to institutions.
Volumes 1-2, 4-14 are available from the
African Studies Program, 205 Ingraham Hall,
1155 Observatory Drive, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706
Tel: 608-262-2493, FAX: 608-265-5851, e-mail: publications@africa.wisc.edu
2014 by the Regents of the University of Wisconsin—Madison
ISSN 1536-5514
Page 3
Ghana
Studies
15/16
Health and Health Care
Guest Editors:
Sjaak van der Geest, Kristine
Krause & Kodjo A. Senah
2012/2013
Page 4
Page 5
SPECIAL ISSUE: HEALTH AND HEALTH CARE
CONTENTS
Editors’ Note
Introduction: Studying Health and Health Care in Ghana 7
Sjaak van der Geest and Kristine Krause
Articles on Health and Health Care
The Perception of Abnormality in Kasena and Nankani
Infants: Clarifying Infanticide in Northern Ghana
Albert K. Awedoba and Aaron R. Denham
Caring for the Seriously Sick in a Ghanaian Society:
Glimpses from the Past
Deborah Atobrah
“No Matter How the Child Is, She Is Hers”: Practical Kinship 103
in the Care of Mental Illness in Kintampo, Ghana
Ursula M. Read
HIV Disclosure in Ghana: The Underlying Gender
Dimension to Trust and Caregiving
Fidelia Ohemeng
Mobile Technology and HIV/AIDS in Ghana
Perpetual Crentsil
Dilemmas of Patient Expertise: People Living with HIV
as Peer Educators in a Ghanaian Hospital
Jonathan Mensah Dapaah and Eileen Moyer
1
Akosua Adomako Ampofo and Stephan F. Miescher
41
69
135
159
195
Page 6
Pharmaceutical Potentials: Praying over Medicines in 223
Pentecostal Healing
Kristine Krause
Humanitarian Claims and Expert Testimonies:
Contestations over Health Care for Ghanaian Migrants in the
United Kingdom
Benjamin N. Lawrance
Mission Medicine in a Decolonising Health Care System: 287
Agogo Hospital, Ghana, 1945-1980
Pascal Schmid
Documentaries on Women’s Health
Accra’s Women on Screen, 2001: A Documentary Pair 331
about Body, Risks, Tonics, and Health
R. Lane Clark, Nancy Rose Hunt, and
Takyiwaa Manuh
Other Articles
Managing the Pan-African Workplace: Discipline, 337
Ideology, and the Cultural Politics of the Ghanaian Bureau of
African Affairs
Jeffrey S. Ahlman
Staging Unity, Performing Subjectivities: Nkrumah, 373
Nation-Building, and the Ghana Dance Ensemble
Paul Schauert
Discourses of Love and Newspapers Advice Columns
in Ghana
Jo Ellen Fair
251
413
Page 7
Reviews
New Wine in Old Wineskins: The Conservative Tradition 467
in Ghana’s Historical Surveys
David Peterson del Mar
Christine Oppong, Delali M. Badasu, and
Kari Waerness, eds., Child Care in a Globalizing World:
Perspectives from Ghana
Cati Coe
Notes on Contributors
497
501
Page 8
Page 9
EDITORS’ NOTE
e are delighted to present the double issue Ghana
Studies 15/16 which will be our last as editors. More
than four years have passed since we assumed the
editorship, and it is time to pass the baton to a new set of editors:
Akosua Darkwah of the University of Ghana and Sean Hanretta of
Stanford University. They will continue the practice of an editorial
team that is based in Ghana and in the global North. We are
confident that their next issue will mark the beginning of another
fruitful transnational collaboration.
Our journey as Ghana Studies editors has been exciting and
intellectually stimulating, although the workload at times stretched
us beyond what either of us had anticipated. When we were invited
to take on the editorship in 2009, the journal had not appeared for
several years. In 2010, our predecessors published their last issue,
GS 10 (2007), a wonderful special issue about Ghana@50; the
same year, we brought out our first issue, GS 11 (2008). The
double issue 12/13 (2009/2010) on Revisiting Modernization
followed in 2011, and then issue 14 (2011) in 2012. We are thrilled
to report that with the present double issue Ghana Studies is again
up to date. We trust that our successors, who are already hard at
work preparing issue 17, will continue publishing the journal in a
timely fashion. More good news needs to be shared: Ghana
Studies, in addition to its print edition, will appear online as part of
Project Muse starting in 2014. At the time of writing, we are still
looking for a suitable Internet place to house the back issues yet
remain confident that they will become accessible online as well.
In the course of our editorship we accumulated numerous debts,
including to our reviewers, our authors, and the production staff of
the African Studies Program at the University of Wisconsin,
W
Page 10
2
Madison. We are especially thankful to our reviewers for their
unflinching support of the journal—some of them turned around
articles we sent them in record time. Their names appear at the end
of this note, and we hasten to offer apologies to anyone whom we
may have omitted. We hope that the support of reviewers will
continue under the new editors, as rigorous peer review is at the
heart of this scholarly journal.
Ghana Studies 15/16 is an especially rich and diverse issue. It
contains a special issue on health and health care in Ghana,
skillfully edited by Sjaak van der Geest, Kristine Krause, and
Kodjo A. Senah. We are leaving it to two of the guest editors, van
der Geest and Krause, to situate their special issue within a larger
scholarly context and introduce their contributions. The nine
articles on health and health care are followed by R. Lane Clark,
Nancy Rose Hunt, and Takyiwaa Manuh’s piece that introduces
two film documentaries about women’s health and medical care:
“Excuse Me to Say”-- Notions of Body and Risk in Accra and
“Where Shall I Go?”-- Tonics, Clinics, and Miracles in Accra..
These two documentaries, directed by Clark and produced by Hunt
and Manuh, are accessible online through the Ghana Studies
website, YouTube, and Vimeo.1 The documentaries are the
culmination of a collaborative training project on women’s health
in Accra between the University of Ghana and the University of
Michigan. In these films, “health” not only refers to the curative
sense but also to social health, economic security, and activities
related to joy and well-being. While the first film focuses on
catering and seamstress apprentices who share their dreams and
aspirations about beauty, dating, marriage, and health concerns, the
1 See http://youtu.be/h3fcKq6wGGQ and http://youtu.be/j4P1CFNOJh0,
http://ghanastudies.com/ghana-studies-journal/, and http://vimeo.com/rlaneclark
Page 11
3
second film shows therapeutic options sought out by girls and
women, including hospitals, pharmacies, herbalists, spirit
mediums, and healing churches. Both films feature a complexity of
voices and spaces, in which women of different ages speak
candidly about their health options and challenges. The films
incorporate interviews with Ghanaian health experts whose work is
cited by other contributors. Thus, the documentaries complement
and extend the findings and scope of the special issue by adding a
compelling visual dimension.
Two articles deal with two very different institutions founded
by Kwame Nkrumah. Jeffrey Ahlman revisits the Bureau of
African Affairs, one of the most controversial institutions of
Nkrumah’s Ghana. While most scholarship has looked at the
Bureau in relation to its Pan-African activities seeking to shape
governments across the continent, Ahlman examines the Bureau as
a workplace. He looks at the development of work regimes that
transformed contestations over pay, leave, and technological
innovations into debates about national security and ideological
discipline. Drawing on the Bureau’s neglected archive, he
reconstructs cases of talkative staff, perceived abuses of the
telephone, and gendered lack of discipline. These workplace
tensions triggered challenges to the Bureau’s operation, its Pan-
African and nation-building agenda. Such inter-office debates,
Ahlman argues, reflected anxieties about gender, generational, and
class tensions in postcolonial Ghana.
Paul Schauert’s contribution tracks the history of the Ghana
Dance Ensemble, established at the Institute of African Studies,
University of Ghana in 1962. This state-sponsored troupe became
instrumental in attempts of nation building and in promoting the
ideologies of African Personality and Pan-Africanism, even
beyond the duration of Nkrumah’s regime. Schauert explores how
Page 12
4
Ensemble members have interpreted, embodied, and expressed
nationalism through performance. He argues that while the ideals
of nationalism pushed individuals into an objectifying unitary
identity, drummers and dancers individually engaged with such
processes. By performing a variety of Ghanaian dances, they
embraced a national identity but still related this identification to
their own sense of self. Adopting a national identity did not mean
to abandon their own ethnic affiliation. Rather, national unity was
experienced subjectively as individuals created their own identity
through music and dance.
Jo Ellen Fair brings an interesting popular dimension to this
collection by providing us with perspectives on the dilemmas of
“modern love” as read from the letters to advice columns in
Ghanaian newspapers. Romance, sexual attraction, love proposals,
courtship, uncertainties, and heartbreaks are issues that concern
people of all ages and cultures. However, Fair shows the
particularly Ghanaian ways in which “tradition” and “modernity”
meet, and sometimes collide. She reveals the theories and
(oftentimes very skillful) methods of the columnists as they bring
popular, social, and moral discourses to bear on these exciting yet
sometimes troubling subjects. Fair’s work is a useful addition to
the large body of anthropological and sociological work on love,
marriage, and kinship in that she provides insights into discourses
of love in a contemporary setting where individuals are impacted
by global social media and want to be “modern” at the same time
that they seem to seek to maintain “traditional” ways of navigating
the relationship terrain.
The review essay by David Peterson del Mar examines
historical surveys of Ghana’s past published since independence,
particularly foregrounding Albert Adu Boahen’s influential work.
Historical surveys written since the 1990s, del Mar suggests, have
Page 13
5
become more conservative, since they merely present conventional
political narratives that ignore the insights of cultural and social
history. This conservatism, he argues, serves the needs of the
current nation state. The book review by Cati Coe reconnects to the
themes of the special issue by discussing an edited collection that
documents a childcare crisis in Ghana with a disturbing impact on
children’s health.
Finally, we are again grateful to Bethany Wilinski for seeing
Ghana Studies 15/16 through the production process. We wish you
happy reading of this splendid special issue on health and
healthcare, of the other articles, as well as enjoyment and
inspiration when watching the documentaries. While we are now
stepping back, handing over to Akosua and Sean, we are already
looking forward to receiving their first issue with new work about
Ghana, her people, and the worlds they have created.
Akosua Adomako Ampofo
University of Ghana, Legon
Stephan F. Miescher
University of California,
Santa Barbara
Ghana Studies Reviewers, 2009-2013
Kojo Opoku Aidoo (University of Ghana
Ama de-Graft Aikins (University of Ghana)
Emmanuel Akyeampong (Harvard University)
Jean Allman (Washington University)
Richard Asante (University of Ghana)
Gareth Austin (London School of Economics)
Albert Awedoba (University of Ghana)
Joseph Atsu Ayee (University of Ghana and University of Witwatersrand)
Peter J. Bloom (University of California, Santa Barbara)
Walter Bruchhausen (University of Bonn)
Lynne Brydon (University of Birmingham)
Marian Burchardt (University of Leipzig)
Page 14
6
Gracia Clark (Indiana University)
Cati Coe (Rutgers University)
Akosua Darkwah (University of Ghana)
Girish Daswani (University of Toronto)
Mirjam de Bruijn (University of Leiden)
Aaron Denham (Macquarie University)
Philippe Denis (University of Kwazulu-Natal)
Hansjörg Dilger (Free University of Berlin)
Wilhelmina Donkoh (Kwame Nkrumah University of Science &
Technology)
Susan Drucker-Brown (University of Cambridge)
James Dzisah (Nipissing University)
Kevin Fridy (University of Tampa)
Rudolf Gaudio (SUNY, Purchase College)
Kristine Krause (Max Planck Institute, Göttingen)
Dennis Laumann (University of Memphis)
Carola Lentz (Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz)
Takyiwaa Manuh (University of Ghana)
T. C. McCaskie (University of Birmingham)
Wyatt McGaffey (Haverford College)
Timothy Mechlinski (Lewis & Clark College, Portland)
Birgit Meyer (Free University, Amsterdam)
Mary Ann Mhina (Freelance Development Practitioner)
Adam Mohr (University of Pennsylvania)
Paul Nugent (University of Edinburgh)
David Owusu-Ansah (James Madison University)
John Parker (SOAS, University of London)
Deborah Pellow (University of Syracuse)
Howard Phillips (University of Cape Town)
Mansah Prah (University of Cape Coast)
Ursula Read (University College, London)
Kodjo A. Senah (University of Ghana)
Raymond Silvermann (University of Michigan)
Arne Steinforth (Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster)
Eric Tenkorang (Memorial University of Newfoundland)
Gerrie ter Haar (Erasmus University Rotterdam)
Sjaak van der Geest (University of Amsterdam)
Susan Whyte (University of Copenhagen)
Larry Yarak (Texas A&M University)
Page 15
Ghana Studies v.15/16 (2012/2013): 7-39
INTRODUCTION: STUDYING HEALTH AND
HEALTH CARE IN GHANA
Sjaak van der Geest, University of Amsterdam &
Kristine Krause, Max Planck Institute, Göttingen1
This introduction delineates and discusses the field of social,
cultural, and historical studies of health and health care in
Ghana. Health and health care are viewed as significant
nexuses of social and cultural processes. This overview of
studies, mainly from Anglophone medical anthropology,
focuses on developments around “traditional” medicine and
various themes relating to biomedicine, including hospital
ethnography, pharmaceuticals, health insurance, reproductive
technology, and HIV/AIDS, while the final topic is about
concepts and quality of care. The contributions to this special
issue are briefly presented and linked to the above mentioned
themes.
Keywords: Traditional medicine, medical pluralism, biomedicine,
hospital ethnography, pharmaceuticals,
reproductive technology, HIV/AIDS, care, Ghana.
llness and health are major concerns in life. During illness
people experience and express their most inner-felt ideas
and concerns regarding belonging, belief, trust, kinship,
economy, reciprocity, and identity. Sickness reveals what and
who really counts, the value of kinship, where economic
priorities lie, and what religion means. If illness and health are
at the centre of culture and society, it is not surprising that the
domains of ill health and wellness, fortune and misfortune,
provide some of the most important tools and metaphors that
people use to order their existence, attach meaning to it, and
communicate with others. The sick body becomes the “topos”
of social vulnerability; the body afflicted by chronic illness or
AIDS represents the inveterate ailments of society, the ageing
health insurance,
1 We thank Edward Nanbigne and Kodjo Senah for helping us with the
literature search and Zoe Goldstein for final editing.
I