First metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis versus proximal phalanx hemiarthroplasty for hallux rigidus: Feasibility study for a randomised controlled trial

Trials (Impact Factor: 1.73). 03/2014; 15(1):79. DOI: 10.1186/1745-6215-15-79
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Background:
Osteoarthritis of the first metatarsophalangeal joint (hallux rigidus) leads to pain and poor function and mobility. Arthrodesis is the gold standard treatment for end-stage disease. Total joint arthroplasties have been attempted, but early loosening has been attributed to dorsally directed shear forces on the metatarsal component. Metallic proximal phalangeal hemiarthroplasty theoretically avoids this. Whilst early results are promising, no comparative trials exist comparing this to arthrodesis.

The primary objectives are to determine the range of outcome scores between the two treatment arms (to inform a power calculation). Outcome measures will include the MOXFQ, AOFAS-Hallux and EuroQol EQ-5D-5 L. Secondary objectives are to determine the accrual rate, dropout rate and trial acceptability to both patients and surgeons. These data will allow the development of a larger trial with longer follow-up.This is a prospective randomised controlled single-centre study comparing proximal phalanx hemiarthroplasty (AnaToemic, Arthrex Ltd., Sheffield, UK) with arthrodesis (15 patients in each arm). Randomisation will be performed using a 1:1 allocation ratio in blocks of six.Patients meeting the eligibility criteria will be recruited from three foot and ankle consultant surgeon's clinics (East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust). If agreeable, informed consent will be obtained before patients are randomised.The outcome measure scores will be completed pre-operatively and repeated at 6 weeks, 3 months and 12 months. A radiological review will be performed at 6 weeks and 12 months to determine rates of loosening (hemiarthroplasty) and union (arthrodesis). Data on length of stay, return to work, complications and re-operation rates will also be collected.The analysis will compare the change in outcome scores between treatment groups at all follow-up time points. Scores will be compared using a Student t-test, adjusting for scores at baseline.This study will be conducted in accordance with the current revision of the Declaration of Helsinki (1996) and the ICH-GCP Guideline (International Conference on Harmonisation, Good Clinical Practice, E6(R1), 1996). This study has been approved by the sponsor, the Trust Research & Development office. Ethical approval has been received from the National Research Ethics Service (North East: 12/NE/0385 for protocol version 5.3 dated 3 June 2013).

Trial registration:
Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN88273654.

Download full-text


Available from: Hiren Divecha, Mar 18, 2014
42 Reads
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Metallic proximal phalangeal hemiarthroplasty has been described for the surgical treatment of moderate to severe hallux rigidus. This long-term follow-up of an extended case series of 37 patients who underwent the index operation demonstrated a high rate (93%) of patient satisfaction, and significant improvement in Foot Function Index scores.
    Foot and Ankle Clinics of North America 01/2006; 10(4):713-28, ix-x. DOI:10.1016/j.fcl.2005.06.011 · 0.76 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: One hundred sixty-five feet were reconstructed with the single stem silicone implant, including patients with hallux regidus, hallux valgus due to degenerative and osteoarthritic joint changes, hallux valgus secondary to rheumatoid arthritis and patients with previous unsuccessful "bunion" procedures. Preoperative pain and intolerance to shoe wear were relieved in the great majority of patients. The amount of correction of the hallux valgus angle was directly related to the preoperative deformity. Infection occurred in 2 patients, and inflammatory reaction to the implant occurred in one patient. One hundred five feet were reconstructed with a flexible hinge implant; 94 of the feet had joints destroyed by rheumatoid arthritis. Dramatic improvement in the hallux valgus angle resulted in these feet which had relatively severe preoperative deformities. No implant fractures were recorded. The present survey of our cases, and experiences reported by others, encourage the use of these implants by surgeons who follow the suggested indications, surgical technique, and follow up care.
    Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 07/1979; · 2.77 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This article argues the practice of first metatarsal phalangeal joint (MPJ) implant arthroplasty. Intermediate and long-term studies raise concerns about implant failure and longevity. Other causes for concern are silicone-induced synovitis and lymphadenopathy. This article presents evidence against the practice of first metatarsal phalangeal implant arthroplasty. Intermediate and long-term studies raise concerns about implant failure and longevity. Furthermore, the lack of any significant long-term results and the documented metallic breakdown from two-piece metallic implants make their use in hallux rigidus questionable. Meanwhile, a comparative study shows the superiority of arthrodesis to implant arthroplasty. Also, alternatives to joint-destructive procedures are emerging. These include arthrodiastasis and the osteochondral autograft transfer procedure. This evidence proves that implant arthroplasty is not the best treatment for patients with hallux rigidus or other first-MPJ pathology.
    Clinics in Podiatric Medicine and Surgery 11/2006; 23(4):709-23, vi. DOI:10.1016/j.cpm.2006.08.001 · 0.56 Impact Factor
Show more