Assessing Habits of Mind

Teachers College Record (Impact Factor: 0.79). 02/2014; 116(2):1-33.


Educational researchers and policymakers have often lamented the failure of teachers to implement what they consider to be technically sound assessment procedures. Through a case study of New York City’s Central Park East Secondary School (CPESS), in the years when it served as a model for progressive American school reform, Duckor and Perlstein demonstrate the usefulness of an alternative to reliance of the technical characteristics of standardized tests for constructing and judging assessments: teachers’ self-conscious and reasoned articulation of their approaches to learning and assessment. They conclude that when teachers are given opportunities for genuine, shared reflection on teaching and learning and classroom practices are tied to this understanding, fidelity to what they call the logic of assessment offers a more promising framework for the improvement of schooling than current forms of high-stakes, standardized accountability. Thus, instead of expecting teachers to rely on data from standardized assessments or replicate features of standardized testing in their own assessment practices, researchers, policymakers and teacher educators should promote fidelity to the broader logic of assessment.

Download full-text


Available from: Brent Duckor, Mar 13, 2014
306 Reads
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In this article, we describe the principles that guided the creation and implementation of a system of embedded assessments—the so-called BEAR (Berkeley Evaluation and Assessment Research) Assessment System. The assessment system was devel-oped in the context of a specific curriculum in issues-oriented science for the middle grades but is designed generically to address the implementation of those principles. The assessment system builds on methodological advances in alternative assessment techniques and attempts to address salient issues in the integration of alternative as-sessment into the classroom teaching and learning context. The 4 principles are de-scribed, and we discuss how the application of these principles generates the compo-nent parts of the system and determines how the component parts work together. The use of teacher moderation to integrate the parts of the system in school and classroom is also discussed. In recent years, "alternative assessment" has been a major topic of interest, de-bate, and experimentation in the nationwide efforts at educational reform. Initial hopes that alternative, authentic, or performance assessments of student achieve-ment would drive (or at least facilitate) changes in what and how students are taught have been tempered by the realities of implementation. Efforts to intro-duce alternative assessments into large-scale, high-stakes state and district test-ing programs have met with mixed results due to high costs, logistical barriers, and political ramifications (e.g., Gipps, 1995; Rothman, 1995). For example, the demise of the California Learning Assessment System was due principally to the complications, technical, political, and financial, of using performance assess-ments for large-scale assessment. Efforts to introduce alternative assessments APPLIED MEASUREMENT IN EDUCATION, 13(2), 181–208 Copyright © 2000 Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
    Applied Measurement in Education 04/2000; 13(2). DOI:10.1207/S15324818AME1302_4 · 0.37 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In the wake of the federal No Child Left Behind legislation, standardized tests have become increasingly high-stakes. Yet English language learners (ELLs) typically score far below native English speakers, creating pressure to “teach to the test.” This article shares findings from an intensive year long study in 10 New York City high schools, detailing how high-stakes tests become defacto language policy in schools. Most schools and individual educators have increased the amount of English instruction ELLs receive; however, some have instead increased native language instruction as a test preparation strategy. Curriculum and instruction focuses on test content and strategies, and English as a second language classes have become more like English language arts classes for native English speakers. In bilingual classes, tests are found to promote monolingual instruction with test translations guiding decisions about language allocation.
    Bilingual Research Journal 07/2006; 30(2):521-546. DOI:10.1080/15235882.2006.10162888
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Although a great deal of debate surrounds the level and allocation of resources to public schools, very little research addresses how schools might organize teaching resources more effectively at the school level. This article describes case studies of five high-performing public schools that have organized professional resources in innovative ways. The study sought to detail alternative ways of deploying instructional resources in order to provide concrete alternatives to traditional organization of teachers and to quantify objectively the ways in which these schools use resources differently depending on their instructional goals and strategies. Although the schools studied looked very different from one another, they shared six principles of resource allocation that are outlined in this article. The article develops a framework for examining the use of resources and a methodology that may be used to measure the extent to which schools use their resources in focused ways to support teaching and learning.
    Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 03/1998; 20(1). DOI:10.2307/1164288 · 1.38 Impact Factor
Show more