When Life-Sustaining Treatment Is Withdrawn and the Patient Doesn't Die

Department of Neonatology, Oslo University Hospital Ulleval, Oslo, Norway
PEDIATRICS (Impact Factor: 5.47). 10/2013; 132(5). DOI: 10.1542/peds.2013-0413
Source: PubMed


One of the most difficult decisions that doctors and parents must make is the decision to withdraw life-sustaining treatment. Doctors find it easier to withdraw treatments in situations where withdrawal will be rapidly fatal rather than in situations in which treatment withdrawal will lead to a prolonged dying process. Mechanical ventilation is usually such a treatment. Withdrawal of ventilation generally leads to the patient's rapid demise. Doctors may tell parents that death will occur quickly after a ventilator is withdrawn. But what happens when the doctors are wrong and a patient survives without life support? What should doctors do next? We present a case in which that happened and asked 3 experts to comment on the case. Stefan Kutzsche is a senior consultant in neonatology at Oslo University Hospital Ulleval in Norway. John Colin Partridge is a neonatologist and professor of pediatrics at University of California, San Francisco. Steven R. Leuthner is a neonatologist and professor of pediatrics and bioethics at the Medical College of Wisconsin. They each recommend slightly different approaches to this dilemma.

Download full-text


Available from: Stefan Kutzsche, Oct 02, 2015
59 Reads
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In clinical practice, and in the medical literature, severe congenital malformations such as trisomy 18, anencephaly, and renal agenesis are frequently referred to as ‘lethal’ or as ‘incompatible with life’. However, there is no agreement about a definition of lethal malformations, nor which conditions should be included in this category. Review of outcomes for malformations commonly designated ‘lethal’ reveals that prolonged survival is possible, even if rare. This article analyses the concept of lethal malformations and compares it to the problematic concept of ‘futility’. We recommend avoiding the term ‘lethal’ and suggest that counseling should focus on salient prognostic features instead. For conditions with a high chance of early death or profound impairment in survivors despite treatment, perinatal and neonatal palliative care would be ethical. However, active obstetric and neonatal management, if desired, may also sometimes be appropriate.
    Seminars in Fetal and Neonatal Medicine 09/1914; In Press-Corrected Proof(5). DOI:10.1016/j.siny.2014.08.007 · 3.03 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Über die Frage, wann und wie Sterbehilfe rechtlich zulässig und moralisch vertretbar sei, wird viel nachgedacht und debattiert. Passive Sterbehilfe gilt dabei meist als der am ehesten gangbare Weg. Doch er verläuft nicht immer so wie geplant.
    pädiatrie: Kinder- und Jugendmedizin hautnah 04/2014; 26(2):76-78. DOI:10.1007/s15014-014-0334-3
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Purpose of review: To review the role of pediatric palliative care (PPC) for children with metabolic and neurological diseases. Recent findings: There is a growing body of literature in PPC, though it remains limited for children with metabolic and neurological diseases. Evidence indicates the benefit of PPC. Utilization of PPC programmes can facilitate communication, ensure that families are better informed, improve certainty with decisions, enhance positive emotions, result in fewer invasive interventions at the end of life, and have an impact on location of death. Barriers to utilization of PPC include concern about taking away hope and uncertainty about prognosis. Challenging areas for children with metabolic and neurological diseases include the identification of distressing symptoms and prognostic uncertainty. This article aims to review literature relevant to this group of children, as well as provide a framework when considering specific palliative care needs. Summary: PPC for children with metabolic and neurological diseases can lessen a child's physical discomfort and enhance parental certainty with decision-making. These areas along with other needs throughout the illness trajectory and bereavement are being increasingly met by the growing availability of PPC programmes.
    Current Opinion in Supportive and Palliative Care 07/2014; 8(3). DOI:10.1097/SPC.0000000000000063 · 1.66 Impact Factor
Show more