The integrated Sachs-Wolfe imprint of cosmic superstructures: a problem for ΛCDM

Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics (Impact Factor: 5.88). 06/2012; 2012(06):042-042. DOI: 10.1088/1475-7516/2012/06/042
Source: arXiv

ABSTRACT A crucial diagnostic of the ΛCDM cosmological model is the integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect of large-scale structure on the cosmic microwave background (CMB). The ISW imprint of superstructures of size ∼ 100 h−1Mpc at redshift z ∼ 0.5 has been detected with > 4σ significance, however it has been noted that the signal is much larger than expected. We revisit the calculation using linear theory predictions in ΛCDM cosmology for the number density of superstructures and their radial density profile, and take possible selection effects into account. While our expected signal is larger than previous estimates, it is still inconsistent by > 3σ with the observation. If the observed signal is indeed due to the ISW effect then huge, extremely underdense voids are far more common in the observed universe than predicted by ΛCDM.

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We measure the average cold spot on the cosmic microwave background(CMB) produced by voids selected in the SDSS DR7 spectroscopic redshift galaxy catalog, spanning redshifts from 0 to 0.4. Our detection has a significance of ~3sigma based on the variance of random samples, and has an average amplitude of ~3 muK as viewed through a compensated top-hat filter scaled to the radius of each void. This signal, if interpreted as the late-time Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect, serves as an evidence for the late-time acceleration of the Universe. The detection is achieved by applying the optimal filter size identified from N-body simulations. Two striking features are found by comparing ISW simulations with our detection, 1.) the void profiles traced by halos in our simulations are very similar to those in the data traced by galaxies. 2.) the same filter radius that gives the largest ISW signal in simulations also yields the largest detected signal in the observations. We model the expected ISW signal using voids from N-body simulations in LCDM, selected in the same way as in the observations. The detected signal, however, is many times larger than that from simulations, discrepant at the ~3sigma level. The large cosmic variance of large-scale modes in the gravitational potential can obscure an ISW measurement such as ours. However, we show how this cosmic variance can be effectively reduced by using a compensated top-hat filter for the detection. We test whether a few possible systematic effects could be producing the signal; we find no evidence that they do.
    The Astrophysical Journal 01/2013; · 6.28 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: I discuss how modern cosmology illustrates under-determination of theoretical hypotheses by data, in ways that are different from most philosophical discussions. I emphasise cosmology's concern with what data could in principle be collected by a single observer (Section 2); and I give a broadly sceptical discussion of cosmology's appeal to the cosmological principle as a way of breaking the under-determination (Section 3). I confine most of the discussion to the history of the observable universe from about one second after the Big Bang, as described by the mainstream cosmological model: in effect, what cosmologists in the early 1970s dubbed the ‘standard model’, as elaborated since then. But in the closing Section 4, I broach some questions about times earlier than one second.
    Studies In History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies In History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 01/2013; · 0.90 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Through a large ensemble of Gaussian realisations and a suite of large-volume N-body simulations, we show that in a standard LCDM scenario, supervoids and superclusters in the redshift range $z\in[0.4,0.7]$ should leave a {\em small} signature on the ISW effect of the order $\sim 2 \mu$K. We perform aperture photometry on WMAP data, centred on such superstructures identified from SDSS LRGs, and find amplitudes at the level of 8 -- 11$ \mu$K -- thus confirming the earlier work of Granett et al 2008. If we focus on apertures of the size $\sim3.6\degr$, then our realisations indicate that LCDM is discrepant at the level of $\sim4 \sigma$. If we combine all aperture scales considered, ranging from 1\degr--20\degr, then the discrepancy becomes $\sim2\sigma$, and it further lowers to $\sim 0.6 \sigma$ if only 30 superstructures are considered in the analysis (being compatible with no ISW signatures at $1.3\sigma$ in this case). Full-sky ISW maps generated from our N-body simulations show that this discrepancy cannot be alleviated by appealing to Rees-Sciama mechanisms, since their impact on the scales probed by our filters is negligible. We perform a series of tests on the WMAP data for systematics. We check for foreground contaminants and show that the signal does not display the correct dependence on the aperture size expected for a residual foreground tracing the density field. The signal also proves robust against rotation tests of the CMB maps, and seems to be spatially associated to the angular positions of the supervoids and superclusters. We explore whether the signal can be explained by the presence of primordial non-Gaussianities of the local type. We show that for models with $\FNL=\pm100$, whilst there is a change in the pattern of temperature anisotropies, all amplitude shifts are well below $<1\mu$K.
    Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 12/2012; · 5.23 Impact Factor

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
May 16, 2014