Constraints on core-collapse supernova progenitors from correlations with Halpha emission

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (Impact Factor: 5.23). 01/2008; 390:1527-1538. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13843.x
Source: arXiv

ABSTRACT We present observational constraints on the nature of the different core-collapse supernova (SN) types through an investigation of the association of their explosion sites with recent star formation (SF), as traced by Halpha + [NII] line emission. We discuss results on the analysed data of the positions of 168 core-collapse SNe with respect to the Halpha emission within their host galaxies. From our analysis we find that overall the type II progenitor population does not trace the underlying SF. Our results are consistent with a significant fraction of SNII arising from progenitor stars of less than 10Msolar. We find that the SNe of type Ib show a higher degree of association with HII regions than those of type II (without accurately tracing the emission), while the type Ic population accurately traces the Halpha emission. This implies that the main core-collapse SN types form a sequence of increasing progenitor mass, from the type II, to Ib and finally Ic. We find that the type IIn subclass display a similar degree of association with the line emission to the overall SNII population, implying that at least the majority of these SNe do not arise from the most massive stars. We also find that the small number of SN `impostors' within our sample do not trace the SF of their host galaxies, a result that would not be expected if these events arise from massive luminous blue variable star progenitors. Based on observations made with the Isaac Newton Telescope operated on the island of La Palma by the Isaac Newton Group in the Spanish Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos of the Institute de Astrofisica de Canarias, and on observations made with the Liverpool Telescope operated on the island of La Palma by Liverpool John Moores University in the Spanish Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos of the Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias with financial support from the UK Science and Technology Facilities Council. E-mail:


Available from: Joseph Anderson, Apr 14, 2014
1 Follower
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: [Abridged] We use optical IFS of nearby SN host galaxies provided by the CALIFA Survey with the goal of finding correlations in the environmental parameters at the location of different SN types. We recover the sequence in association of different SN types to the star-forming regions by using several indicators of the ongoing and recent SF related to both the ionized gas and the stellar populations. While the total ongoing SF is on average the same for the three SN types, SNe Ibc/IIb tend to happen closer to star-forming regions and occur in higher SF density locations compared to SNe II and SNe~Ia, the latter showing the weakest correlation. SNe~Ia host galaxies have on average masses that are $\sim$0.3-0.8~dex higher than CC SNe hosts due to a larger fraction of old stellar populations in the SNe~Ia hosts. Using the recent SN~Ia delay-time distribution and the SFHs of the galaxies, we show that the SN~Ia hosts in our sample should presently produce a factor 2 more SNe~Ia than the CC~SN hosts. Since both types are in hosts with similar SF rate and hence similar CC~SN rate, this can explain the mass difference between the SN~Ia and CC~SN hosts, and reinforce the finding that at least part of SNe~Ia should originate from very old progenitors. Comparing the mean SFH of the eight least massive galaxies to that of the massive SF SN~Ia hosts we find that the low-mass galaxies formed their stars over more extended time than the massive SN~Ia hosts. We estimate that the low-mass galaxies should produce by a factor of 10 less SNe~Ia, and a factor of 3 less CC~SNe than the high-mass group. Therefore the ratio between the number of CC~SNe and SNe~Ia is expected to increase with decreasing the galaxy mass. CC~SNe tend to explode at positions with younger stellar populations than the galaxy average, but the galaxy properties at SNe~Ia locations are one average the same as the global ones.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We present constraints on supernovae type Ia (SNe~Ia) progenitors through an analysis of the environments found at the explosion sites of 102 events within star-forming host galaxies. H-alpha and GALEX near-UV images are used to trace on-going and recent star formation (SF), while broad band B, R, J, K imaging is also analysed. Using pixel statistics we find that SNe~Ia show the lowest degree of association with H-alpha emission of all supernova types. It is also found that they do not trace near-UV emission. As the latter traces SF on timescales less than 100 Myr, this rules out any extreme 'prompt' delay-times as the dominant progenitor channel of SNe~Ia. SNe~Ia best trace the B-band light distribution of their host galaxies. This implies that the population within star-forming galaxies is dominated by relatively young progenitors. Splitting SNe by their (B-V) colours at maximum light, 'redder' events show a higher degree of association to HII regions and are found more centrally within hosts. We discuss possible explanations of this result in terms of line of sight extinction and progenitor effects. No evidence for correlations between SN stretch and environment properties is observed.
    Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 12/2014; 448(1). DOI:10.1093/mnras/stu2712 · 5.23 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In the thesis we study close pairs of galaxies with the aim of understanding the influence of gravitational interaction on nuclear activity and star formation of paired galaxies. For this purpose we investigate dependencies of integral parameters of galaxies, their star formation and properties of nuclei on kinematic parameters of systems and their large-scale environment. The thesis has an introduction, three main chapters, a summary, lists of abbreviations and references, and three appendices. In the first chapter, the methods of selection of sample of pairs of galaxies and measurements of physical parameters of the First Byurakan Survey (Markarian) galaxies and their neighbors are presented, and the databases in appendices A and B are described, which contain parameters of neighbors of Markarian galaxies measured by us, and the parameters of pairs having Markarian galaxies, based on the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) data. The selection effects of sample of pairs are discussed, and the statistical comparison of Markarian galaxies and their neighbors is done. The results of statistical study of star formation and activity of nuclei in pairs having Markarian galaxies are presented, as well as the correlations between properties of galaxies in pairs and the physical mechanisms behind them. In the second chapter, the results of statistical study of the Second Byurakan Survey (SBS) galaxies and their neighbors, and star formation and activity of nuclei in those pairs are presented and discussed. In the third chapter, possibilities of using supernovae as indicators of star formation are discussed, the sample of supernovae in pairs of galaxies is presented, and study of star formation in pairs of interacting galaxies by means of that sample of supernovae is done. Also а conclusion about the nature of progenitors of different types of supernovae is made. The short summary of main results of the study concludes the thesis. The thesis has 158 pages. The main results are the following. 1. The linear distance between members of pairs of galaxies and the degree of their morphological disturbance reflect the strength of interaction better than the difference of line-of-sight velocities of pair members. The latter correlates with the density of large-scale environment of a pair and with morphologies of paired galaxies. 2. Close neighbors of Markarian galaxies mostly do not differ in their properties from that of Markarian galaxies. Close neighbors of SBS galaxies mostly do not differ in their properties from that of SBS galaxies. The SBS galaxies in pairs do not differ from isolated SBS galaxies in their properties. 3. The interactions between galaxies enhance their star formation, particularly, the mass normalized specific star formation rate in paired galaxies increases by an order of 0.5 averagely. This effect is revealed when studying both pairs with smaller differences of line-of–sight velocities and pairs with smaller linear separations between components. The effect is revealed for galaxies of any morphological type, in environments with almost any density, for both high- and low-mass galaxies. 4. The interaction with neighbors of the same or later morphological types enhances star formation. The interactions with neighbor galaxies of comparable masses increases star formation rate and activity of nuclei more effectively than interaction with less-massive neighbors. 5. The fraction of active nuclei among more disturbed and stronger interacting pairs is the highest. Galaxies with active nuclei usually are located in stronger interacting pairs and/or in pairs with later stages of interaction, in comparison with star-forming and passive galaxies. 6. Star formation rates and nuclear activity of paired galaxies are correlated. For a galaxy with a certain activity type of the nucleus, the probability of having a neighbor with the same type of activity is higher. 7. Due to the effect of interaction-enhanced star formation, the supernovae of type Ibc are located in pairs with smaller differences of line-of-sight velocities than supernovae Ia and II. The full thesis is available only in Armenian.
    05/2014, Degree: PhD, Supervisor: Artashes R. Petrosian