Cultural competency in medical education: demographic differences associated with medical student communication styles and clinical clerkship feedback.

Washington University School of Medicine, 4444 Forest Park, Ste 6700, St Louis, MO 63108, USA.
Journal of the National Medical Association (Impact Factor: 0.91). 02/2009; 101(2):116-26.
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT We tested the significance of associations among students' demographics, communication styles, and feedback received during clerkships.
US medical students who completed at least one required clinical clerkship were invited between April and July 2006 to complete an anonymous, online survey inquiring about demographics, communication styles (assertiveness and reticence), feedback (positive and negative), and clerkship grades. The effects of self-identified race/ethnicity, gender, and generation (immigrant, first- or second-generation American) and their 2-way interactions on assertiveness, reticence, total positive and total negative feedback comments were tested using factorial analysis of covariance, controlling for age, clerkship grades, and mother's and father's education; pairwise comparisons used simple contrasts. Two-sided P values < .05 were considered significant.
Medical students from 105 schools responded (N = 2395: 55% women; 57% white). Men reported more assertiveness than women (P = .001). Reticence (P < .001) and total positive comments (P = .006) differed by race/ethnicity; in pairwise contrasts, black, East Asian, and Native American/ Alaskan students reported greater reticence than white students (P < .001), and white students reported receiving more positive comments than black, and South and East Asian students. Race/ethnicity-by-generation (P = .022) and gender-by-generation (P = .025) interaction effects were observed for total negative comments; white first-generation Americans reported receiving the fewest and male immigrants reported receiving the most negative comments.
Demographic differences in students' communication styles and feedback they received highlight a need for cultural competency training to improve medical student-teacher interactions, analogous to training currently advocated to improve physician-patient interactions.

Download full-text


Available from: Dorothy A Andriole, Jun 13, 2015
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Cultural competency is gaining recognition as an essential strategy by which to address health care disparities. A closer examination of medical school curriculums was undertaken to determine how the need for cultural competency and humility (CCH) training in medical education is being addressed. A MEDLINE review of published literature regarding CCH training in medical education was performed. Additionally, key informant interviews with influential faculty members from prominent medical institutions were completed. Many academic medical institutions recognize the need for CCH and have successfully integrated it into the first 2 years of their curriculums. However, there seems to be a uniform deficit in CCH training in the third and fourth years of their education. Recognizing the need for CCH training during the third and fourth years of medical education, we explored the issues inherent to the integration of CCH training in clinical education. Using surgery as a model, we established a set of recommendations to assist clerkship directors and curriculum committees in their efforts to ensure CCH training in the last 2 years of medical education.
    Journal of Surgical Education 05/2011; 68(3):222-30. DOI:10.1016/j.jsurg.2011.01.002 · 1.39 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: To identify which patient characteristics are associated with silence towards the healthcare system after experiences of abusive or ethically wrongful transgressive behaviour by healthcare staff. Cross-sectional questionnaire study using the Transgressions of Ethical Principles in Health Care Questionnaire. A women's clinic in the south of Sweden. Selection criteria were: consecutive female patients coming for an outpatient appointment, ≥18-year-old, with the ability to speak and understand the Swedish language, and a known address. Questionnaires were answered by 534 women (60%) who had visited the clinic, of which 293 were included in the present study sample. How many times the respondent remained silent towards the healthcare system relative to the number of times the respondent spoke up. Associations were found between patients' silence towards the healthcare system and young age as well as lower self-rated knowledge of patient rights. Both variables showed independent effects on patients' silence in a multivariate model. No associations were found with social status, country of birth, health or other abuse. The results offer opportunities for designing interventions to stimulate patients to speak up and open up the clinical climate, for which the responsibility lies in the hands of staff; but more research is needed.
    BMJ Open 10/2012; 2(6). DOI:10.1136/bmjopen-2012-001562 · 2.06 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background and Purpose. In 2003, The University of Utah initiated the Cultural Competency and Mutual Respect (CCMR) educational program for the Interdisciplinary Health Sciences Students (IHSS), professionals in medicine (MED), pharmacy (PHARM), nursing (NSG), physical therapy (PT), and others. This 3-year study assessed the pre/post learning outcomes of the CCMR program through Campinha-Bacote’s Inventory for Assessing the Process of Cultural Competence- Revised (IAPCC-R©).1-4 Subjects. A total of 2,124 IHSS students, participating in CCMR learning modules, completed the Inventory for Assessing the Process of Cultural Competence-Revised (IAPCC-R©), with 114 PT and MED subjects as controls. Methods. This study was approved by The University of Utah Health Sciences Center Institutional Review Board. Verbal and written permission was received for use of the IAPCC-R©. Following informed consent procedures, IAPCC-R© pre/post data was collected each semester from fall 2003 through spring 2006. Paired and nonpaired analyses were performed, comparing Cultural Competence (CC) scores and constructs, P < .05, for each discipline, along with demographics. Results. Study outcomes resulted in 1,974 usable, completed inventories, with overall IAPCC-R© pre/post scores demonstrating gains in progression towards cultural competence. In year 2, the curriculum was adjusted based upon student feedback and facilitator input; however, overall CC was not necessarily further enhanced. In terms of CC—Asian, Hispanic, and Other demographic IHSS subject categories outpaced Caucasians. Discussion. Overall CC was improved for all disciplines. In terms of the 5 constructs of CC, results indicated that PT, MED, PHARM, and NSG disciplines attained significant scores for the cultural constructs of “attitudes,” “knowledge,” and “skills” but not “encounters” and “desires.” Although posttest scores indicated marked progressions, approaching CC, IHSS did not yet demonstrate Cultural Proficiency. The constructs of cultural “desires” and “encounters” warrant further curricular enhancement and examination for progression towards attainment of Cultural Proficiency. Conclusion. Results of this 3-year investigation indicate that the IHSS are becoming more Culturally Aware as a result of CCMR program participation and are significantly progressing towards Cultural Competence. However, overall, these interdisciplinary health science student subjects have not achieved the level of Cultural Proficiency. Ongoing support is needed to assist facilitators in teaching matters of Cultural Competence, in a way that is sensitive to the core values, beliefs, and attitudes of health care professionals. Further investigation, in both academic and clinical education, is warranted to examine culturally competent practice opportunities within interprofessional health care interactions and to reduce health care disparities and medical errors for the patients/clients served.