Singaporean and Taiwanese pre-service teachers’ beliefs and their attitude towards ICT: A comparative study
ABSTRACT Teachers’ epistemological and pedagogical beliefs and their attitude about ICT are identified as the second-order barrier for the integration of ICTinto classrooms. In this paper, we report the findings obtained from our recent survey and conducted among,Singaporean and Taiwanese,pre-service teachers (N=108). The results indicate that the teachers’ epistemological beliefs were generally relativistic. They were also inclined to believe rather strongly the constructivist notion of teaching. The profile we obtained in this study seems to suggest that pre-service teachers from Singapore and Taiwan are holding beliefs that are congruent to the education reform efforts. However, the teachers’ attitude about ICT use does not seem to relate to their epistemological and pedagogical beliefs. The findings suggest that further effort needs to be taken in order to foster more productive use of ICT to support constructivism-oriented teaching. These results need to be verified with further study. Keywords:Epistemological beliefs , pedagogical beliefs, attitudes toward ICT
- SourceAvailable from: Chang Zhu
Article: How Innovative are Schools in Teaching and Learning? A Case Study in Beijing and Hong Kong Author: ZHU Chang Reference: from The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher (ISI/SSCI), DOI 10.1007/s40299-012-0006-4, issue Volume 22, Issue 2, Page 137-145, published by Springer URL: http://www.springerlink.com/openurl.asp?genre=article&id=doi:10.1007/s40299-012-0006-404/2013;
Article: How innovative are schools in teaching and learning? A case study in Beijing and Hong Kong Author: ZHU Chang Reference: The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher (ISI/SSCI), issue in press, DOI: 10.1007/s40299-012-0006-4, published by Springer URL: http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40299-012-0006-403/2012;
- [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: Available research is helpful to list a wide variety of factors influencing ICT adoption and integration in classroom teaching. But, existing studies hardly center on the combined impact of these variables. In addition, little research is available set up in the Chinese context. The latter is important given the rather limited extent ICT is currently being used in China and given the different cultural context in which the interplay between teacher beliefs and educational practices has yet been little documented. The present study centers on the complex interplay of a number of internal teacher variables to explain ICT classroom integration. These variables comprise "teachers' constructivist teaching beliefs", "teacher attitudes towards computers in education", "teachers' computer motivation", "teacher perception of ICT-related policy". A survey was set up, involving 820 Chinese primary school teachers. Path modeling was used to explore the direct and indirect effects of the teacher related variables on their level of classroom ICT integration. Firstly, two distinctive types of ICT use can be distinguished in this Chinese context: (a) Teacher supportive use of ICT that refers to the use of ICT for e.g., student administration, preparing worksheets, developing evaluation activities, keeping track of pupils' learning progress, (b) Classroom use of ICT to support and enhance the actual teaching and learning process. The results show that classroom use of ICT directly depends on teachers' computer motivation and the supportive use of ICT. Teachers' constructivist beliefs, their attitudes towards computers in education and perceptions about the ICT-related school policy influence ICT integration in an indirect way. The results demonstrate how a the complex interplay between teacher related variables and ICT integration in the classroom is partly in line with findings in non-Asian contexts. A number of differences can be explained by the particular Chinese context. In particular an indirect relationship was found between teachers' constructivist beliefs and their level of ICT integration. This is partly be explained by the Chinese educational tradition, based on the Confucian philosophy emphasizing "a group-based, teacher-dominated, and centrally organized pedagogical culture".
Singaporean and Taiwanese pre-service
teachers’ beliefs and their attitude towards
ICT: A comparative study
Ching Sing Chaia, Huang-Yao Hongb, Timothy Teoc
a,cNational Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
bDepartment of Education, National Chengchi University, Taiwan
Abstract: Teachers’ epistemological and pedagogical beliefs and their attitude about ICT are
identified as the second-order barrier for the integration of ICT into classrooms. In this paper,
we report the findings obtained from our recent survey and conducted among Singaporean
and Taiwanese pre-service teachers (N=108). The results indicate that the teachers’
epistemological beliefs were generally relativistic. They were also inclined to believe rather
strongly the constructivist notion of teaching. The profile we obtained in this study seems to
suggest that pre-service teachers from Singapore and Taiwan are holding beliefs that are
congruent to the education reform efforts. However, the teachers’ attitude about ICT use does
not seem to relate to their epistemological and pedagogical beliefs. The findings suggest that
further effort needs to be taken in order to foster more productive use of ICT to support
constructivism-oriented teaching. These results need to be verified with further study.
Keywords: Epistemological beliefs, pedagogical beliefs, attitudes toward ICT
The emergence of the knowledge-based economy has resulted in educational reforms in
many developed and developing countries across the world. In essence, these reforms aim to
develop active learners to work collaboratively with others to construct knowledge.
Pedagogically, they demand a teaching practice that is learner-centred and
constructivist-oriented . The role of information technology (ICT) in this context of
teaching and learning is to function as a cognitive tool that enhances students’ thinking.
Although the general provision of ICT resources are getting better, changes in teaching
practices are less forth coming. Hu and colleagues  survey indicates that although
teachers are already using ICT for routine work, they do not engage learners to co-construct
knowledge constructively with ICT. Ertmer  reported a similar phenomenon in America
and attributed this to teachers’ pedagogical beliefs as a deeply rooted barrier. The aim of this
study is to explore pre-service teachers’ epistemological and pedagogical beliefs, and the
relationships between these beliefs and pre-service teachers’ attitude towards ICT use.
2. Literature Review
In this study, we study beliefs about knowledge and about knowing, beliefs about teaching,
and beliefs about learning, in relation to teachers’ attitude towards the use of computer.
These constructs are reviewed next with a focus towards studies on pre-service teachers.
8 6 5
Research on beliefs about knowledge and about knowing or personal epistemology
by educational researchers began in the late 60s . Generally, it was reported that college
students progressed from believing that knowledge is certain and is passed down from
authority to a more relativistic stance that emphasized knowledge to be uncertain and
constructed by individuals based on warrants. This general pattern of development was also
observed by later researchers who also rely on interview as the method for data collection
. Sutton, Cafarelli, Lund, Schurdell, and Bichsel  reported the epistemological
development of 32 student teachers near the end of their teacher education. More than half
of them were assessed to be at the higher end of epistemological development. White 
and Brownlee’s  study on student teachers further strengthened Sutton et al.’s findings. In
summary, these studies indicate that student teachers’ epistemological beliefs are
distributed across the developmental stages with more holding relativistic beliefs.
Pre-service teachers holding on to absolutists/dualistic epistemological beliefs are rare.
Schommer  proposed a model of five more or less independent dimensions of
epistemological beliefs, namely the “the structure, certainty, and source of knowledge, and
the control and speed of knowledge acquisition”. The last two dimensions reflect beliefs
about learning. To measure these dimensions, Schommer developed the Epistemological
Beliefs Questionnaire (EBQ). On the issue of students’ learning, myriad of studies have
documented that epistemological beliefs are associated with learning strategies, academic
achievements, interpretation of text and conceptual change . In general, sophisticated
epistemological beliefs are positively associated with learning and higher order thinking.
However, studies that explored the relationships between teachers’ epistemological beliefs,
pedagogical beliefs and teaching practice are generally lacking .
The relationship between teachers’ epistemological beliefs and their beliefs about
teaching and learning is complex. Beliefs about what teaching and learning can be broadly
classified under the knowledge transmission category or the knowledge construction
category . The former is characterized as teacher-centred, content-oriented didactic
teaching practice that emphasizes on passive reception of knowledge by students. As for the
later, it is usually characterized as student-centred, learning-oriented constructivist teaching
that encourages students to actively make sense of their experiences situated within the
social cultural contexts. Teachers with more sophisticated epistemological beliefs seem to
be more engaged than their peers, with regards to personal learning . However, the
relationship between pre-service teachers’ epistemological beliefs and their pedagogical
beliefs may be incongruent at times. Review of studies focusing on pre-service teachers’
beliefs indicates that these teachers are likely to perceived teaching as an unproblematic
process of knowledge transmission . Chan and Elliot  surveyed 385 Hong Kong
pre-service teachers and reported that most of the teachers were relativistic in their
epidemiological outlooks. However, they were not inclined towards constructivist teaching.
The pre-service teachers may view epistemological beliefs and their pedagogical beliefs as
two independent belief systems. Study of American student teachers, however, indicate that
teachers who see knowledge as evolving and learning as a process of constructing
understanding are also more receptive towards the idea of teaching as facilitating
knowledge and beliefs revision among students. Based on these reviews, it seems clear
that more cross-cultural studies are required .
Research that studied the relationships between teachers’ epistemological beliefs
and their perception of ICT generally suggests that teachers who hold constructivist belief
are more likely to engage their students to use computers and the Internet . However,
epistemological belief is just one factor among many other factors that influence teachers’
views of ICT. Zhao and his colleagues’  analyses indicate that successful integration of
ICT depends on the interrelationship between the school contexts, the teachers driving the
integration project and the technology involved. Specifically, when the technology chosen
8 6 6
for implementation is compatible with the teachers’ pedagogical beliefs, there is a higher
chance for integration to occur. Fox and Henri  investigation reveals that emphases
towards producing good examination results will inhibit teachers’ use of ICT.
In summary, the literature review highlighted the complex relationships between
teachers’ epistemological beliefs, pedagogical beliefs and their perception of ICT. In light
of the review above, this study investigates the following research questions:
1. How do the participants perceive the measured beliefs?
2. Are there significant differences between Singaporean and Taiwanese pre-service
teachers in terms of the measured beliefs?
3. How are pre-service teachers’ epistemological and pedagogical beliefs related to
their attitude towards use of ICT?
The participants for this study were pre-service teachers in teacher preparation courses.
Table 1 shows the background of the participants.
Table 1: Background information of the participants
Nation Age Qualification
Mean SD Undergraduate Postgraduate Male
Taiwan(TW, N=49) 24.0 2.47
Singapore(SG, N=50) 26.8 2.99
Overall 25.5 3.08
The questionnaire contained four parts. The first part of the questionnaire solicits
demographic data that could affect the teachers’ beliefs. The second part of the
questionnaire was an adapted version of Schommer’s EBQ used in Chan and Elliott’s 
study. This modified version covers four dimensions: Certainty of Knowledge (CK) and the
Authority/ Expert knowledge (AEK) as core dimensions of epistemological beliefs;
Innate/Fixed Ability (IA) and the Learning Effort/Process (LEP) as core dimensions related
to beliefs about learning. The third part of the survey measure teachers’ attitude towards the
use of computers . The fourth part of the survey examines the participants’ conceptions
about teaching and learning (traditional/ constructivist), developed by Chan and Elliot .
All items employed a 5-point Likert scale (5 = strongly agree, 1 = strongly disagree). A high
score indicates favorable respond towards the measured construct. Alpha reliabilities of the
measured dimensions range from .67 to .90. The overall reliability of the measured
constructs is satisfactory [10, 12, 20].
4. Results and Discussion
Table 2 below provides the statistical information required to answer the research questions.
Table 2: Mean, SD and t-test values for the measured constructs
Dimensions measured TW/SG N
Certainty of Knowledge
Innate Ability (IA)
Learning Effort/ Process
Mean SD t-test
8 6 7
Constructivist teaching (CT) TW
Traditional teaching (TT) 2.149*
Computer attitude (ATU) -.721
The results indicate that both Singaporean and Taiwanese pre-service teachers are
not inclined to believe in authority and expert as source of knowledge. They are also not
inclined to view knowledge as certain and unchanging. The epistemological beliefs that
these teachers hold are generally consistent with what we have reviewed earlier. In
particular, surveys of Hong Kong and Singapore pre-service teachers’ epistemological
beliefs using the same instrument documented comparable epistemological profile [10, 20].
Eighty five of the participants are degree holders and the remaining 23 undergraduate are in
their third years. The epistemological profile we obtained is therefore not surprising. These
teachers have the basic epistemological outlooks that are consistent with constructivist
teaching. Furthermore, the teachers have also expressed a lesser inclination towards the
beliefs of innate ability and they express a stronger inclination towards learning effort and
processes. These profiles should also support the constructivist-oriented reforms.
Both Singapore and Taiwan pre-service teachers are strongly inclined towards
constructivist teaching and less inclined towards traditional teaching. This should be a
logical stance given their epistemological profile. However, this may not always be the case
as Chan and Elliot’s  study testified. Based on the reported mean score, it seems that
Hong Kong pre-service teachers are neither inclined towards constructivist (M=1.86) nor
traditional teaching (M=2.63). Statistical differences are detected between the Taiwanese
and Singaporean teachers’ pedagogical beliefs. While the Taiwanese teachers express
stronger inclination towards constructivist teaching, they are also expressing stronger
inclination towards traditional teaching. One explanation is that the pre-service teachers
may view epistemological beliefs and their pedagogical beliefs as two independent belief
systems. Survey of Hong Kong pre-service teachers indicates that while the participants
held relativistic epistemology, they were not inclined towards constructivist teaching .
In terms of the attitude toward the use of computers, both Singaporean and
Taiwanese teachers express moderately positive attitude. The absolute mean score is not
high, indicating that there may be some barriers that they are aware of. This could be an
important area for further research. The result for the Singaporean teachers is comparable to
another recent research . To understand the relationships of the measured constructs, we
ran additional correlation tests. It was found that there were no significant correlations
between Attitude towards Computer Use (ATU) and all types of teachers’ epistemological
beliefs (Pearson’s correlation efficiencies ranging from -.12 to .26) expect for a significant
negative correlation between ATU and AEK for the Singaporean group. It indicates a
negative attitude towards use of ICT corresponding with the epistemological beliefs in
expert knowledge. In addition, it was also found that there were no significant correlations
between Attitude towards Computer Use (ATU) and Constructive Teaching (CT) (r = .11, p
> .05, for the Taiwan group; and r = .23, p > .05, for the Singapore group). The findings
suggest that additional effort to help both Taiwanese and Singaporean teachers learn to use
ICT to support more constructive teaching is necessary. Furthermore, in terms of
relationships between Attitude towards Computer Use (ATU) and Traditional Teaching, a
significant correlation (r = .30, p < .05) is found for the Taiwan group, but not found for the
Singapore group (r = .01, p > .05). The findings suggest that Taiwanese pre-service teachers
are more likely than Singapore pre-service teachers to embrace an attitude towards use of
8 6 8
ICT in support of traditional teaching. As mentioned in the literature review, how
epistemological beliefs and pedagogical beliefs are related to the teachers’ attitude towards
computers is a less researched area; therefore, these results need to be verified with further
 Jimoyiannis, A. & Komis, V. (2007). Examining teachers’ beliefs about ICT in education: Implications
of a teacher preparation programme. Teacher Development, 112), 149-173.
 Hu, C., Wong, A., Cheah, H. M., Wong, P., & D’Rozario, V. (2004). Effectiveness of NIE’s IT teacher
training programme: Have we prepared them enough? (ACRFcademic Research Fund Report 18/01).
Nanyang Technological University: Singapore.
 Ertmer, P. A. (2005). Teacher pedagogical beliefs: The final frontier in our quest for technology
integration? Educational Technology, Reaserch and Development, 53(4), 25-39.
 Perry, W. G. (1970). Forms of intellectual and ethical development in the college years: A scheme. New
York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
 Hofer, B. K., & Pintrich, P.R. (1997). The development of epistemological theories: Beliefs about
knowledge and knowing and their relation to learning. Review of Educational Research, 67(1), 88-140.
 Sutton, R. E., Cafarelli, A., Lund, R., Schurdall, D. & Bichsel, S. (1996). A developmental constructivist
approach to pre-service teachers’ ways of knowing. Teaching and Teacher Education, 12(4), 413-427.
 White, B.C. (2000). Pre-service teachers’ epistemology viewed through perspectives on problematic
classroom situations. Journal of Education for Teaching, 26(3), 279-305.
 Brownlee, J. (2001). Knowing and learning in teacher education: a theoretical framework of core and
peripheral epistemological beliefs. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education and Development, 4(1),
 Schommer, M. (1990). Effects of beliefs about the nature of knowledge on comprehension. Journal of
Educational Psychology, 82(3), 498-504.
 Chan, K. W., & Elliot, R.G. (2004). Relational analysis of personal epistemology and conceptions about
teaching and learning. Teaching and Teacher Education, 20, 817-831.
 Entwistle, N., Skinner, D., Entwistle, D., & Orr, S. (2000). Conceptions and beliefs about “good
teaching”: An integration of contrasting research areas. Higher Education Research & Development,
 Ravindran, B., Greene, B. A., & DeBacker, T. K. (2005). Predicting pre-service teachers’ cognitive
engagement with goals and epistemological beliefs. The Journal of Educational Research, 98 (4),
 Richardson, V. (2003). Pre-service teachers’ beliefs. In J. Raths, & A. C. McAninch. (Eds.). Teacher
beliefs and classroom performance: The impact of teacher education. (pp. 1-22). Greenwich,
Connecticut: Information Age Publishing.
 Sinatra, G. M., & Kardash, C. (2004). Teacher candidates’ epistemological beliefs, dispositions, and
views on teaching as persuasion. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 29(4), 483-498.
 Hofer, B. (2008). Personal epistemology and culture. In M. S. Khine (ed.). Knowing, knowledge and
beliefs: Epistemological studies across diverse cultures (pp. 3-24). Netherland: Springer.
 Becker, H. J. & Ravitz, J. (1999). The influence of computer and internet use on teachers’ pedagogical
practices and perceptions. Journal of Research on Computing in Education, 31(4), 356-384.
 Zhao, Y., Pugh, K., Sheldon, S. & Byers, J. L. (2002). Conditions for classroom technology innovations.
Teacher College Record, 104(3), 482-515.
 Fox, R., & Henri, J. (2005). Understanding Teacher Mindsets: IT and Change in Hong Kong Schools.
Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 8 (2), 161-169.
 Teo, T., Lee, C. B., & Chai, C. S. (2008). Understanding pre-service teachers' computer attitudes:
applying and extending the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM). Journal of Computer Assisted
Learning, 24, 128-143.
 Chai, C. S., & Khine, M. S. (2008). Assessing the epistemological and pedagogical beliefs among
pre-service teachers in Singapore. In M. S. Khine (Ed.) Knowing, knowledge and beliefs:
Epistemological studies across diverse cultures (pp. 287-299). Netherlands: Springer.
8 6 9