Reflections on a proposed theory of reservation-dwelling American Indian alcohol use: comment on Spillane and Smith (2007).

American Indian and Alaska Native Programs, University of Colorado, Denver, Aurora, CO 80045 USA.
Psychological Bulletin (Impact Factor: 14.39). 04/2009; 135(2):339-43; discussion 344-6. DOI: 10.1037/a0014819
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT In their recent article, N. Spillane and G. Smith suggested that reservation-dwelling American Indians have higher rates of problem drinking than do either non-American Indians or those American Indians living in nonreservation settings. These authors further argued that problematic alcohol use patterns in reservation communities are due to the lack of contingencies between drinking and "standard life reinforcers" (SLRs), such as employment, housing, education, and health care. This comment presents evidence that these arguments were based on a partial review of the literature. Weaknesses in the application of SLR constructs to American Indian reservation communities are identified as is the need for culturally contextualized empirical evidence supporting this theory and its application. Cautionary notes are offered about the development of literature reviews, theoretical frameworks, and policy recommendations for American Indian communities.

Download full-text


Available from: Joseph E Trimble, Aug 02, 2015
1 Follower
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Using ethnographic findings from two community-based substance abuse programs for indigenous peoples in the United States and Canada, this article examines how greater attention to cultural context can help to inform the treatment of alcohol problems among Native North American women. Cultural context shapes not only therapeutic activities and interactions within substance abuse programs, but also how such programs develop within different communities. These findings add to the growing evidence that gender can powerfully shape how Native American clients engage spiritual resources and respond to conventional styles of psychotherapeutic talk, supporting emergent efforts to rethink “cultural competency” in mental health services for Native North Americans.
    Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly 09/2011; 29(4):379-402. DOI:10.1080/07347324.2011.608593
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: While injuries are a leading health concern for Aboriginal populations, injury rates and types vary substantially across bands. The uniqueness of Aboriginal communities highlights the importance of collecting community-level injury surveillance data to assist with identifying local injury patterns, setting priorities for action and evaluating programs. Secwepemc First Nations communities in British Columbia, Canada, implemented the Injury Surveillance Project using the Aboriginal Community-Centered Injury Surveillance System. This paper presents findings from a community-based participatory process evaluation of the Injury Surveillance Project. Qualitative data collection methods were informed by OCAP (Ownership, Control, Access, and Possession) principles and included focus groups, interviews and document review. Results focused on lessons learned through the planning, implementation and management of the Injury Surveillance Project identifying lessons related to: project leadership and staff, training, project funding, initial project outcomes, and community readiness. Key findings included the central importance of a community-based and paced approach guided by OCAP principles, the key role of leadership and project champions, and the strongly collaborative relationships between the project communities. Findings may assist with successful implementation of community-based health surveillance in other settings and with other health issues and illustrate another path to self-determination for Aboriginal communities. The evaluation methods represent an example of a collaborative community-driven approach guided by OCAP principles necessary for work with Aboriginal communities.
    Prevention Science 12/2011; 13(2):107-17. DOI:10.1007/s11121-011-0258-x · 2.63 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background Spillane and Smith (2007, Psychol Bull 133:395–418) postulated that high levels of problem drinking in some First Nation (FN) communities resulted in part from the perception that there is low access to alternative reinforcers (e.g., jobs, friendships, family relationships, and financial security), that many alternative reinforcers are less contingent on sobriety, and that others are available regardless of drinking status for reserve-dwelling FN members. Methods This study examined perceptions of access to alternative reinforcers and the extent to which access varied as a function of drinking in 211 FN members living on 1 reserve in Canada, 138 middle socioeconomic status Caucasians (MCCs), and 98 low socioeconomic status Caucasians (LCCs). ResultsThe FN group expected less access to employment, quality family and friend relationships, and financial security compared with the MCC group. After controlling for perceived access in general, gender, and age, the FN group reported that drinking would not cause a decrease in access to employment, family relationships, friendships, and finances as compared to the MCC group. The FN group did not differ from the LCC group in the degree to which they expected drinking to cost access to family relationships or finances, but the LCC group expected drinking to have less of an impact on access to jobs and friendships as compared to the FN group. Conclusions The results provide initial support for the Spillane and Smith theory of problem drinking among this 1 FN group. The results suggest that increasing access to these reinforcers may reduce problematic drinking in this FN group.
    Alcoholism Clinical and Experimental Research 01/2013; 37(s1). DOI:10.1111/j.1530-0277.2012.01864.x · 3.31 Impact Factor
Show more