Radiographic methods for evaluating osteoporotic vertebral fractures. Jt Bone Spine

INSERM, ERI12, Faculté de Médecine et de Pharmacie, 1 rue des Louvels 80037 Amiens, France
Joint, bone, spine: revue du rhumatisme (Impact Factor: 2.9). 03/2009; 76(3):241-7. DOI: 10.1016/j.jbspin.2008.07.017
Source: PubMed


Reproducible methods for the radiological assessment of osteoporotic vertebral fractures, defined based on accurate criteria, are needed in everyday practice and in therapeutic trials and epidemiological studies.
To describe and to evaluate methods for osteoporotic vertebral fracture assessment based on standard radiographs or dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) and to determine the role for each method in clinical practice, therapeutic trials, and epidemiological studies.
A review written by a rheumatologist based on his clinical experience and on a literature review was submitted to four experts. Studies in English or French published between 1975 and February 2008 were retrieved from Medline using the keywords vertebral fracture, osteoporosis, vertebral deformity, and vertebral fracture assessment.
One hundred forty-nine articles were selected and read in their full-text version. There was no consensus regarding the definition of osteoporotic vertebral fractures. The following methods were evaluated: visual assessment, Genant's semi-quantitative assessment, Jiang's algorithm-based qualitative method, morphometric radiography, and DXA of the spine. In everyday practice, Genant's semi-quantitative assessment on standard radiographs may provide useful information on the severity and prognosis of osteoporosis. DXA done for bone mineral density measurement may detect vertebral fractures in asymptomatic patients. Assessment of standard radiographs remains the reference standard for diagnosing vertebral fractures in patients with suggestive symptoms (e.g., pain in the thoracic or lumbar spine, height loss, or thoracic kyphosis). For therapeutic trials and epidemiological studies, Genant's semi-quantitative assessment used by a trained and experienced observer is the preferred method, based on its good reproducibility and ability to differentiate fractures from other deformities. However, thousands of radiographs may be needed, making routine interpretation by an expert impractical. A visual semi-quantitative method may be used to separate normal radiographs from radiographs showing possible or obvious fractures, which can then be read by an expert. Alternatively, radiomorphometric indices can be determined on digitized radiographs in combination with a semi-quantitative assessment, with discordant cases being reviewed by an expert. We do not recommend Jiang's method at present, as it is still undergoing validation.

Download full-text


Available from: Jacques Fechtenbaum, Dec 02, 2014
1,080 Reads
  • Source
    • "A. Herrera et al. / Maturitas xxx (2015) xxx–xxx 7 reproducibility, this method has shown high reliability for the diagnosis (97.60%) when compared to morphometric studies [25], and it has been considered the most useful for studies like the present one [26]. Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) was ruled out for difficulties in the access to a DXA study in certain areas of our country; on the other hand, the images of the upper thoracic vertebrae were obtained with this method are hardly measurable. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of this work is to study the prevalence of osteoporotic vertebral fractures in Spanish women over 45 years of age, based on the selection of a nationwide sample. An observational, cross-sectional, multicenter study was conducted during 2006, in all of Spain's regions. The sample analyzed was of 5000 individuals, proportional to the female population over age 45 in Spain. A questionnaire was used to determine which factors are most often associated with vertebral fractures. Finally, we wonder whether the Prevalent Vertebral Fracture Index, proposed by Vogt, is useful to presume a possible osteoporotic vertebral fracture. Five hundred orthopedic surgeons, from various Spanish regions, were trained in different aspects of the study: inclusion and exclusion criteria, management of risk factors questionnaire, and implementation of the Vogt questionnaire. The number of fracture cases was 1549 (31.79%). 528 Women (34.08%) had a single vertebral fracture, and 1021 (65.92%) had multiple vertebral fractures. The following factors were statistically significant with vertebral fracture: age, late menarche, early menopause, diabetes mellitus, hyperparathyroidism, rheumatoid arthritis, height loss, daily physical activity, corticosteroid therapy, personal history of osteoporotic fracture and previous diagnosis of osteoporosis. The differences in Vogt score according to age and fracture were statistically significant. The conclusion of the study is that vertebral osteoporotic fracture in the female Spanish population is frequent. The high prevalence in the Spanish population older than 60 years is probably related to malnutrition in the period from 1936 to 1952.
    Maturitas 03/2015; [Epub ahead of prin](3). DOI:10.1016/j.maturitas.2014.12.004 · 2.94 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "The visual semiquantitative (VSQ) assessment on conventional spine radiograph proposed in 1993 by Genant and colleagues remains the most validated and used method in clinical practice [13]. However, some authors support a combined approach of VSQ and quantitative morphometric methods to overcome limits of single methods side by side [16] [17]. Great importance has been given to the incidental diagnosis of VFs, during imaging examinations for other clinical purposes. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of the present study was to evaluate the performance of sagittal MR localizer (MR-loc), in terms of diagnostic accuracy and intra- and inter-observer agreement in the detection of vertebral fractures (VFs). Three-hundred MR examinations of the thoracic and/or lumbar spine were randomly collected. A semi-quantitative approach was used and morphometric analysis was performed when a VF was suspected. MR-loc images were evaluated blindly by three radiologists in two different sessions. A full diagnostic sagittal T1-weighted fast spin echo MR sequence was used as standard of reference (RS). Degenerative arthritis was also scored on RS. Only vertebral bodies which were assessable by both MR-loc and RS were considered for the analysis. Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC), Cohen kappa statistic, and linear-by-linear association were used for statistical analysis. Kappa values were compared by means of the z distribution. A total of 2186 vertebrae were analyzed in 300 MRI exams (147 males, 153 females, 59.4±16.4 y.o.). Sixty-seven out of 2136 (3.1%) VFs were identified in 23/300 (7.7%) patients submitted to MRI. In the detection of VFs, sensitivity and specificity of MR-loc were both 100% (accuracy AUROC=1.000). Inter-observer agreement was excellent (k=0.938±0.013), while intra-observer agreement was perfect (k=1.000). The diagnostic performance was independent from degenerative arthritis, vertebral level, type and grade of VFs. MR-loc is a simple but accurate tool in the detection of VFs. It should be introduced for systematic evaluation in the detection of VFs in MR examinations performed in daily clinical practice.
    Bone 01/2014; 61. DOI:10.1016/j.bone.2014.01.013 · 3.97 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Several standardized approaches have been proposed to describe vertebral fractures.[3-6,15] There were various methods for evaluating OVFs based on simple radiography, including visual assessment of standard radiographs, Genant's semi-quantitative assessment, Jiang's qualitative methods, morphometric radiography and dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) measurement.[15] "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: On retrospective basis, we investigated the detection of osteoporotic vertebral fractures (OVFs) without radiologic collapse using a modified Yoshida's classification, which was designed by the authors. We observed 82 cases in 76 patients with confirmed OVFs without collapse at the thoracolumbar junction. The following factors were measured: age, gender, body mass index (BMI, kg/m(2)), bone mineral density (BMD, mg/cm(3)), type of a modified Yoshida's classification. The correct diagnosis rate for the presence and location of OVFs and the correct diagnosis rate according to the morphological type by a modified Yoshida's classification of the OVFs were analyzed. The mean BMI was 21.2; mean BMD, 44.1; and T-score, -4.4. As for the four subtypes of anterior cortical morphological change, there were 14 cases of the protruding type, 12 cases of the indented type, 5 cases of the disrupted type and 8 cases of the prow type. As for the three subtypes of endplate depression, there were 20 cases of upper endplate depression, 12 cases of lower endplate depression and 11 cases of endplate slippage type. According to the examiners, there was a significant difference between being informed before and after the modified Yoshida's classification. For the relationship of examiners and the type of fracture, there was a significant difference between being informed before and after the modified Yoshida's classification, particularly in the protruding type and the upper plate type. A modified Yoshida's classification can be helpful for the diagnosis of OVFs without radiologic collapse in a simple radiograph.
    11/2013; 20(2):89-94. DOI:10.11005/jbm.2013.20.2.89
Show more