The Two Faces of Market Support – How Deployment Policies Affect Technological Exploration and Exploitation in the Solar Photovoltaic Industry

ETH Zurich, Department of Management, Technology, and Economics, Weinbergstrasse 56/58, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland
Research Policy (Impact Factor: 2.85). 02/2013; 42(4):989-1003. DOI: 10.1016/j.respol.2013.01.002

ABSTRACT The recent years have seen a strong rise in policies aiming to increase the diffusion of clean energy technologies. While there is general agreement that such deployment policies have been very effective in bringing technologies to the market, it is less understood how these policies affect technological innovation. To shed more light on this important question, we conducted comparative case studies with a global sample of 9 firms producing solar photovoltaic (PV) modules, complemented by in-depth interviews with 16 leading PV industry experts. We propose that, on the one hand, policy-induced market growth serves as an important catalyst for innovative activity as it raises the absolute level of firm investments in technological exploration. On the other hand, however, deployment policies create an incentive for firms pursuing more mature technologies to shift their balance between exploitation and exploration toward exploitation. Firms focusing on less mature technologies cannot tap the potentials of exploitative learning to the same extent as those with more mature technologies. Therefore, stimulating strong market growth may raise the barrier to market entry for less mature technologies. We conclude that, when designing deployment policies, great care should be taken to avoid adverse effects on technological diversity and a premature lock-in into more established technologies.


Available from: Joern Hoppmann, Mar 15, 2014
1 Follower
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In this paper, we carry out a literature review of the studies investigating the factors that affect the performance and growth of clean technology start-up firms. The importance of clean-tech start-ups lies in their mission to protect the environment by facilitating the increased use of clean energy and environmentally friendly solutions. At the same time, the entrepreneurial nature of many of these firms enables introduction of radical innovations necessary for making breakthroughs in the industries of renewable energy and environmental technology that in turn are essential for the industry development. Given their significance, there are surprisingly few studies with the focus on the factors affecting the growth of clean-tech start-ups. Our search in leading management, entrepreneurship and energy journals has yielded a total of 13 articles, almost all of which focus on such external factors as policies. We argue that this gives us an incomplete picture of the factors enabling a clean-tech firm's development. As clean-tech firms are a subset of the population of new technology-based firms (NTBFs), we draw on the literature dealing with the factors that promote growth of NTBFs in order to build our framework for structuring the results. The analysis uncovers what future research areas can be pursued in order to gain a more balanced understanding of what enables the development of a clean-tech start-up. We suggest that in addition to the macro-studies of policies and regulations, future research needs to examine the individual and firm-specific factors, e.g. characteristics of the clean-tech entrepreneurs, teams, governance mechanisms and network structures. Furthermore, the existing focus on the environmental and innovative performance of clean-tech start-ups should be complemented by examining the alternative firm outcomes related to e.g. financial performance, social identity, alliance portfolio and internationalization.
    Energy Procedia 12/2014; 58. DOI:10.1016/j.egypro.2014.10.407
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Public demonstration projects are receiving increasing and often sceptical attention, especially when developing economies attempt to accelerate the emergence of new industries through government intervention. The aim of this paper is to ascertain whether these demonstration policies can promote industrial emergence, at least in China, and to explore the mechanisms of their influence. A survey with 1500 respondents was conducted to investigate China’s electric vehicle demonstration project, known as the ‘Ten Cities, One Thousand Vehicles’ programme. Structural-equation modelling was used to analyse the 437 valid questionnaires returned. The results show that this public demonstration project has improved product information, application and diffusion. In addition, the results validate the use of a model that illustrates the effects of demonstration policies on industrial innovation in terms of the policies’ testing and showing functions. The paper offers insight into the use of demonstration policies as a form of intervention to promote industrial emergence, and the results will be of interest to policy makers, industrialists and academics.
    Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice 03/2015; 15(2):1-23. DOI:10.1080/14479338.2015.1011051 · 0.38 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The rise of Chinese solar energy firms has taken many experts by surprise. German policy makers and researchers alike had suggested that the country's ambitious deployment policies would translate into a competitive advantage for the German solar photovoltaics industry. This paper argues that these expectations rested on an outdated model of the international diffusion of innovation. Building on the technological innovation system (TIS) framework and the related system functions approach, the paper thus proposes a new approach for capturing the global dynamics of innovation and industrial development in emerging technology fields. Focusing on a period of dynamic growth in the field of crystalline-based PV technologies, the paper highlights how a set of dynamic and mutual inter-dependencies between an industrialized country (i.e. Germany) and an emerging economy (i.e. China) have driven the development and diffusion of technology in the field.
    Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 01/2015; DOI:10.1016/j.eist.2014.12.002