Influence of Surgeon Experience, Hospital Volume, and Specialty Designation on Outcomes in Pediatric Surgery A Systematic Review

JAMA pediatrics 03/2013; 167(5):1-8. DOI: 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2013.25
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT IMPORTANCE Analyses of volume-outcome relationships in adult surgery have found that hospital and physician characteristics affect patient outcomes, such as length of stay, hospital charges, complications, and mortality. Similar investigations in children's surgical specialties are fewer in number, and their conclusions are less clear. OBJECTIVE To review the evidence regarding surgeon or hospital experience and their influence on outcomes in children's surgery. EVIDENCE REVIEW A MEDLINE and EMBASE search was conducted for English-language studies published from January 1, 1980, through April 13, 2012. Titles and abstracts were screened in a standardized manner by 2 reviewers. Studies selected for inclusion had to use a measure of hospital or surgeon experience as a predictor variable and had to report postoperative outcomes as dependent response variables. Included studies were reviewed with regard to methodologic quality, and study results were extracted. FINDINGS Sixty-three studies were reviewed. Significant heterogeneity was detected in exposure definitions, outcome measures, and risk adjustment, with the greatest heterogeneity seen in appendectomy studies. Various exposure levels were examined: hospital level in 48 (68%) studies, surgeon level in 11 (17%), and both in 9 (14%). Nineteen percent of studies did not adjust for confounding, and 57% did not adjust for sample clustering. The most consistent methods and reproducible results were seen in the pediatric cardiac surgical literature. Forty-nine studies (78%) showed positive correlation between experience and most primary outcomes, but differences in outcomes and exposure definitions made comparisons between studies difficult. In general, hospital-level factors tended to correlate with outcomes for high-complexity procedures, whereas surgeon-level factors tended to correlate with outcomes for more common procedures. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE Data on experience-related outcomes in children's surgery are limited in number and vary widely in methodologic quality. Future studies should seek both to standardize definitions, making results more applicable, and to differentiate procedures affected by surgeon experience from those more affected by hospital resources and system-level variables.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background. There is an ongoing debate among pediatric surgeons regarding the need or lack thereof to centralize the surgical care of children to high-volume children's centers. Risk-adjusted comparisons of hospitals performing pediatric surgery are needed. Methods. Admissions from 2006 to 2010 from two national administrative databases were analyzed. Only nontrauma pediatric patients undergoing a noncardiac surgical procedure were included. Risk-adjustment was performed with a validated International Classification of Diseases, 9th Revision code-based tool. Hospitals were grouped into metropolitan regions using the first three digits of their zip code. Poorly performing outlier hospitals were defined by an odds ratio >1 and P value <.05 for mortality compared with the center with the greatest pediatric operative volume in that same region. Results. Information was obtained from 415,546 pediatric surgical admissions, and 173 hospitals in 55 regions were compared. A total of 18 poor performing hospitals (adjusted odds ratio, range 1.91-35.95) in 15 regions were identified. Mortality in poor performers ranged from 1.11% to 10.19% whereas that in the high-volume reference centers was 0.37-2.41%; A subset analysis in patients <1 year of age showed 37 poor performers in 46 regions. Median number of surgical admissions was 345 (interquartile range 152-907) for nonoutlier and 240 (interquartile range 135-566) for outlier centers (P = .30). Conclusion. The present analysis is a novel risk-adjusted assessment of the performance of hospitals delivering pediatric surgical care. By identifying the existence of multiple poor performing outlier hospitals, this study provides valuable data for discussion as health care delivery systems continue to debate optimal resource distribution and regionalization of the surgical care of children.
    Surgery 06/2014; 156(2). DOI:10.1016/j.surg.2014.04.003 · 3.37 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Very little is known about whether mortality following acute pancreatitis may be influenced by the following five factors: social deprivation, week day of admission, recruitment of junior doctors in August each year, European Working Time Directives (EWTDs) for junior doctors' working hours and hospital size. The aim of this study was to establish how mortality following acute pancreatitis may be influenced by these five factors in a large cohort study.
    BMC Gastroenterology 08/2014; 14(1):153. DOI:10.1186/1471-230X-14-153 · 2.11 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The distribution of surgical care of very low birth weight (VLBW) neonates among centers with varying specialized care remains unknown. This study quantifies operations performed on VLBW neonates nationally with respect to center type. VLBW neonates born 2009-2012 were assessed using a prospectively collected multi-center database encompassing 80% of all VLBW neonates in the United States. Surgical centers were categorized based on availability of pediatric surgery (PS) and anesthesia (PA). 48,711 major procedures (29,512 abdominal operations) were performed on 24,318 neonates. Of all patients, 20,892 (85.9%) underwent surgery at centers with PS and PA available on site. 1663 (6.8%) patients were treated at centers with neither specialty on site. Neonates requiring complex operations were more likely to receive surgery at centers with both PS and PA on staff than those requiring non-complex operations (95.6% vs 93.6%). This study confirms that most operations on VLBW neonates in the U.S. are performed at centers with pediatric surgeons and anesthesiologists on staff. Further research is necessary, however, to elucidate why a significant minority of this challenging population continues to be managed at centers without pediatric specialists. Copyright © 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
    Journal of Pediatric Surgery 12/2014; 49(12):1821-1824.e8. DOI:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2014.09.032 · 1.31 Impact Factor