Viruses 2012, 4, 3731-3753; doi:10.3390/v4123731
Neonatal Calf Infection with Respiratory Syncytial Virus:
Drawing Parallels to the Disease in Human Infants
Randy E. Sacco 1,*, Jodi L. McGill 1, Mitchell V. Palmer 2, John D. Lippolis 1,
Timothy A. Reinhardt 1 and Brian J. Nonnecke 1
1 Ruminant Diseases and Immunology Unit, National Animal Disease Center,
Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Ames, Iowa, 50010, USA;
E-Mails: Jodi.McGill@ars.usda.gov (J.L.M.); John.Lippolis@ars.usda.gov (J.D.L.);
Tim.Reinhardt@ars.usda.gov (T.A.R.); Brian.Nonnecke@ars.usda.gov (B.J.N.)
2 Infectious Bacterial Diseases Research Unit, National Animal Disease Center,
Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Ames, Iowa, 50010, USA;
* Author to whom correspondence should be addressed; E-Mail: Randy.Sacco@ars.usda.gov;
Tel.: +1-515-337-7354; Fax: +1-515-337-7149.
Received: 1 November 2012; in revised form: 29 November 2012 / Accepted: 7 December 2012 /
Published: 13 December 2012
Abstract: Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is the most common viral cause of childhood
acute lower respiratory tract infections. It is estimated that RSV infections result in more
than 100,000 deaths annually worldwide. Bovine RSV is a cause of enzootic pneumonia in
young dairy calves and summer pneumonia in nursing beef calves. Furthermore, bovine
RSV plays a significant role in bovine respiratory disease complex, the most prevalent
cause of morbidity and mortality among feedlot cattle. Infection of calves with bovine RSV
shares features in common with RSV infection in children, such as an age-dependent
susceptibility. In addition, comparable microscopic lesions consisting of bronchiolar
neutrophilic infiltrates, epithelial cell necrosis, and syncytial cell formation are observed.
Further, our studies have shown an upregulation of pro-inflammatory mediators in
RSV-infected calves, including IL-12p40 and CXCL8 (IL-8). This finding is consistent
with increased levels of IL-8 observed in children with RSV bronchiolitis. Since rodents
lack IL-8, neonatal calves can be useful for studies of IL-8 regulation in response to RSV
infection. We have recently found that vitamin D in milk replacer diets can be manipulated
to produce calves differing in circulating 25-hydroxyvitamin D3. The results to date
indicate that although the vitamin D intracrine pathway is activated during RSV infection,
Viruses 2012, 4
pro-inflammatory mediators frequently inhibited by the vitamin D intacrine pathway in
vitro are, in fact, upregulated or unaffected in lungs of infected calves.
This review will summarize available data that provide parallels between bovine RSV
infection in neonatal calves and human RSV in infants.
Keywords: Bovine respiratory syncytial virus; human respiratory syncytial virus;
innate immunity; adaptive immunity; vaccine
1. Importance of Human and Bovine Respiratory Syncytial Viruses
Human (hRSV) and bovine (bRSV) respiratory syncytial viruses are closely related viruses that are
among the leading causes of acute serious lower respiratory infection (ALRI) in young children and
calves, respectively. While estimated mortality rates in developing countries are low (<0.02%),
globally, it is estimated that new episodes of hRSV-associated disease in children younger than 5 years
of age exceed 33 million annually, with more than 100,000 resultant deaths . Severe hRSV
infections during the first three years of life are frequently followed by recurrent episodes of childhood
wheezing or asthma [2,3]. In addition, hRSV is increasingly seen as an important cause of morbidity
and mortality in elderly adults [4,5] and in immunocompromised patients .
BRSV is a cause of enzootic pneumonia in young dairy calves and summer pneumonia in nursing
beef calves. In fact, worldwide estimates suggest the frequency of bRSV infections in some dairy and
beef herds exceeds 50% . Furthermore, in combination with other viral and bacterial pathogens,
bRSV plays a significant role in shipping fever or bovine respiratory disease complex (BRDC), the
most prevalent cause of morbidity and mortality among feedlot cattle. Even in cases where animals do
not succumb to the disease, there can be long-term losses in performance. This includes reductions in
feed efficiency and rate of gain in the feedlot, as well as reproductive performance, milk production,
and longevity in the breeding herd. As a result, economic costs to the cattle industry from BRDC have
been estimated to approach $1 billion annually due to death losses, reduced performance, and costs of
vaccinations and treatment modalities.
2. Historical Perspectives on Respiratory Syncytial Viruses
In 1956, RSV was originally isolated as a causal agent of chimpanzee coryza . However, at the
time this virus was further linked with respiratory illness in a human working with the coryza agent
that had close contact with the chimpanzees. The next year, there was a reported isolation of a virus
from infants with respiratory illness that was indistinguishable from the chimpanzee coryza
agent [9,10]. The first study to propose an involvement of RSV in respiratory disease in cattle came
more than a decade later. Doggett et al.  found bovine sera that contained neutralizing antibody
against hRSV, suggesting a similar virus might exist in cattle. In the early 1970s, two reports from
respiratory disease outbreaks in Switzerland  and England  identified viruses isolated from
cattle that were closely related to hRSV. At the same time, Inaba et al.  reported the isolation of
Viruses 2012, 4
what appeared to be a new virus from cases of acute BRDC that was initially referred to as Nomi virus,
but which they subsequently identified as bRSV .
3. Age and Seasonal Affects
The most severe ALRI cases due to hRSV occur in infants and children less than 1 year of age,
especially those born premature or with underlying cardiopulmonary conditions [4,5]. In the USA, by
24 months of age, nearly all children have been infected at least once with hRSV, and approximately
half have experienced two infections . BRSV-associated disease is most pronounced in calves less
than 6 months of age, and infection can occur even in the presence of maternal antibodies. It has been
estimated that more than 70% of calves have seroconverted by the age of 12 months . As with
humans, re-infections in calves are common. Seasonal periodicity is seen with hRSV and bRSV, with
most common occurrences of infections in the fall and winter months .
4. RSV Viral Proteins
HRSV and bRSV belong to the family Paramixoviridae, subfamily Pneumoviridae, and genus
Pneumovirus. Pneumoviruses are single-stranded, negative-sense RNA viruses with a genome of
approximately 15.2 kb. The RSV viral RNA is transcribed into 10 major subgenomic mRNAs
encoding 11 proteins, due to the M2 gene encoding two proteins. Associated with the genomic RNA,
are nucleocapsid (N), phosphoprotein (P), large polymerase (L), and associated proteins,
transcriptional anti-termination factor M2-1 and RNA regulatory protein M2-2. There are 3
transmembrane surface glycoproteins, attachment (G), fusion (F), and small hydrophobic (SH).
A non-glycosylated matrix or membrane protein, M, is associated with the inner face of the envelope.
Finally, there are 2 non-structural proteins that accumulate in infected cells NS1, NS2.
HRSV has been classified into two subgroups, A and B, based on antigenic and genetic
differences [19,20]. BRSV isolates can be classified into subgroups based on reactivity of mAb to the
G protein , although these may represent variants of a single major antigenic group [21,22].
The F protein is a type I viral fusion protein synthesized as a precursor that is proteolytically cleaved
by furin into disulfide-linked fragments . Among the hRSV subgroups, the cellular attachment G
protein, a type II integral membrane protein, is more divergent than the F protein . Although
bRSV isolates possess antigenically heterogeneous G proteins, the nucleotide sequences are less
variable than for hRSV [21,25]. The F and G glycoproteins contain the predominant neutralization and
protective epitopes. For both hRSV and bRSV, the attachment protein is a major target of the host anti-
RSV antibody response  and specific regions of the protein may be under immune selection .
However, immunological pressures may differ between bRSV and hRSV as suggested by differences
in the variability of the central hydrophobic region of the G protein of these viruses .
5. Experimental Bovine RSV in Calves and Similarities to Lesions seen in Human Infants
We have used bRSV strain 375 for inoculation of neonates in our studies [29–31]. The inoculum
was prepared from virus stock re-isolated from the lung of an infected animal and passaged less than
4 times on bovine turbinate cells. Our bRSV aerosol challenge model  was adapted from that
Viruses 2012, 4
described by Woolums et al. . Briefly, the challenge inoculum is delivered by nebulization into a
mask covering the nostrils and mouth. The nebulization apparatus consists of a compressed air tank, a
jet nebulizer, and a mask (Trudell Medical International, London, Ontario, Canada) modified to fit
calves. Compressed air (25 lb/in2) is used to jet nebulize the challenge inoculum directly into a holding
reservoir. Upon installation, the nebulized inoculum is inhaled through a one-way valve into the mask
and directly into the nostrils. Each calf received a 5 ml challenge inoculum containing approximately
104 TCID50/ml of bRSV strain 375 during the nebulization period of 10–15 min.
At necropsy, performed on day 7 post infection, gross lesions typically consist of bilateral,
multifocal, firm, plum-red areas of consolidation that are of variable size and depressed compared to
the adjacent normal appearing lung (Figure 1). Lesions are most frequently observed in cranioventral
lung lobes. On cut surface, areas of consolidation are well delineated from adjacent normal lung. In
some cases, areas of consolidation surround and divide regions of pink, hyperinflated lung. Significant
microscopic lesions are apparent with representative photomicrographs shown (Figure 2).
Microscopically, interlobular septa are expanded by clear space interpreted to be edema (Figure 2A).
Alveolar septa are thickened due to infiltrates of macrophages, lymphocytes, and lesser numbers of
neutrophils (Figure 2B). Intralesional bronchioles are filled with neutrophils, sloughed epithelial cells,
and necrotic cellular debris (Figure 2C). Bronchiolar epithelial cell necrosis results in attenuation of
remaining epithelial cells, or complete loss of airway epithelium. In some bronchioles, epithelial cells
form multinucleated syncytial cells (Figure 2D). These lesions are similar to those described by others
following experimental bRSV challenge.
In the rare instances where histopathological evaluation is available from fatal hRSV cases, it was
noted that airway lumina contain cellular debris from leukocytes and sloughed epithelial cells, with
fibrin and a minor amount of mucin [33–35]. Submucosal edema and peribronchiolar infiltrates,
consisting predominately of mononuclear cells with minor numbers of neutrophils, further obstructed
the airways. With interstitial pneumonia, there was evidence of significant alveolar involvement
including edema and cellular infiltration, as well as epithelial cell attenuation or loss.
Viruses 2012, 4
Figure 1. Lung from an RSV-infected calf at day 7 post-infection. Note multifocal to
coalescing areas of plum-red consolidation in cranial and ventral aspects of right cranial
and middle lobes. Consolidated areas surround and divide foci of pale pink hyperinflated
lung (arrow). Scattered multifocal areas of consolidation are also present in the ventral
third of the right caudal lobe (arrowheads). Original figure: .
Viruses 2012, 4
Figure 2. Histological lesions observed in lung of calves after experimental infection with
bovine RSV. Calves were challenged via aerosol with bovine RSV. On day 7
post-infection, samples of lung were collected for histological evaluation. A representative
image from a single calf is shown. (A) Moderate interstitial thickening and wide
interlobular septae due to edema. Original magnification, 4X. (B) Alveolar septae are
thickened due to cellular infiltrates found to be macrophages, lymphocytes and lesser
numbers of neutrophils when viewed at higher magnification. Original magnification, 20X.
(C) Bronchioles are filled with neutrophils, sloughed epithelial cells, and necrotic cell
debris. Original magnification, 20X. (D) There is partial to complete loss of bronchiolar
epithelial cells with attenuation of remaining cells. In some bronchioles, epithelial cells
form multinucleated syncytial cells (arrows). Original magnification, 40X. Figure adapted
6. Innate Immunity to RSV
Critical to the induction of the innate immune response are pattern recognition receptors (PRRs)
that recognize evolutionarily conserved pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs).
Recognition of viral PAMPs involves at least three distinct classes of PRRs, toll-like receptors (TLRs),
retinoic acid inducible gene-I (RIG-I)-like receptors (RLRs), and nucleotide-binding oligomerization
domain (NOD)-like receptors (NLRs). Involvement of several TLRs has been described for hRSV
infection, including TLR2, -3, -4, -7 and -8 [36,37]. Ligation of PRRs including TLR3, -7 and -8, and
RLRs activates interferon regulatory factors (IRFs). These IRFs, in particular IRF3 and 7, interact
Viruses 2012, 4
with other transcription factors to control expression of type I IFNs and related molecules. Inactive
IRFs reside in the cytoplasm in a latent form . Viral infection triggers phosphorylation of serine
and threonine residues and nuclear translocation of IRF3 and IRF7 where they associate with each
other and complex with other co-activators (e.g., CREB-binding protein) to form a transcriptional
complex that binds to promoter regions of type I IFN genes to activate transcription .
Virus-induced type I IFNs bind to the type I IFN receptor (IFNAR) activating Jak/STAT signaling
leading to the upregulation of IFN-stimulated target genes (ISGs). Among ISGs are a number of
antiviral mediators, including Mx, PKR, and 2-5 oligoadenylate synthetase.
Paramixoviruses are known to utilize different mechanisms to affect IFN signaling. hRSV and
bRSV have evolved strategies to inhibit the IFN-induced cellular response that are dependent upon
nonstructural (NS) proteins. As is characteristic of pneumoviruses, these viruses have two genes that
encode for NS proteins. It has been shown that NS1 and NS2 proteins cooperatively mediate resistance
of bRSV and hRSV to IFN-stimulated responses in a species-specific manner [40,41]. In fact, the
precise mechanism whereby type I IFN responses are altered, varies between these viruses. In the case
of bRSV, NS proteins block phosphorylation and activation of IRF3 . By comparison, hRSV NS1
and NS2 modulation of type I IFN responsiveness involves inhibition of Stat2 expression .
In addition to induction of IRFs, ligation of PRRs by viral PAMPs stimulates the release of
inflammatory mediators. It has been shown that RSV induces cytokine/chemokine production in
airway epithelial cells via signaling through TLR3 and RLRs, which have been linked to distinct
pathways controlling NF-B activation . In addition to respiratory epithelial cells, RSV infection
induces inflammatory cytokines in antigen-presenting cells, the kinetics of which differs between
cytokines. For example, we found peak induction of IL-1 and IL-12p40 mRNA in alveolar
macrophages occurs on day 3 post-infection in the neonatal bRSV model, whereas IL-6 mRNA was
higher at day 5 than day 3 of infection . Recently, we have shown a significant upregulation of the
innate chemokine IL-8 in lesioned lungs of bRSV-infected calves on day 7 post infection .
Importantly, our results fit well with data showing that IL-8 is elevated in the respiratory tract of
children with hRSV bronchiolitis. Rodents lack a bona fide homologue of IL-8, although mice have
what are considered to be functional homologues, CXCL1 (GRO/KC), CXCL2 (MIP-2) and CXCL5-6
(LIX), which belong to the same major cluster of chemokines. It is therefore evident that the neonatal
calf model can prove useful as an in vivo platform for future exploration into pathways that specifically
regulate innate immune responses during RSV infection.
Gamma delta T cells have been suggested to play a role in innate immunity to RSV based on their
recognition of unprocessed and non-protein antigens independent of MHC restriction and their
localization in epithelial tissues at the host-environmental interface . In humans and mice, the
frequency of γδ T cells in circulation or within secondary lymphoid tissues is low, generally
representing less than 5-10% of the circulating peripheral lymphocyte population . However, in
ruminants, γδ T cells are significantly more abundant, representing up to 70% of the circulating
peripheral blood lymphocytes in very young animals [47,48]. Given their low frequency and the
difficulty in obtaining sufficient cell numbers, relatively few studies exist which have examined the
role of γδ T cells during hRSV infection. A study in patients hospitalized for hRSV bronchiolitis
revealed a significant reduction in the numbers of γδ T cells circulating in the blood compared to
control patients. Interestingly, this reduction was more pronounced in patients with severe disease .
Viruses 2012, 4
Aoyagi et al. recently demonstrated that γδ T cells isolated from the blood of hRSV-infected infants
produce less IFNγ and more IL-4 in response to mitogen stimulation than equivalent cells isolated
from rotavirus-infected infants , suggesting that γδ T cells may be susceptible to the Th2-skewing
often associated with hRSV infection (see section on Adaptive immunity to RSV). Data from mice
suggests that γδ T cells contribute to immunopathology at the site of infection, as depletion of γδ T
cells prior to challenge with hRSV results in reduced lung inflammation and disease severity .
However, γδ T cells may play a role in limiting viral replication in the lungs as their depletion also
resulted in an increase in peak viral titers .
Despite their abundance in circulation in the blood of ruminants, studies of γδ T cells in the bovine
during bRSV infection are also relatively scarce. A study by Taylor et al. reported that depletion of
WC1+ γδ T cells from neonatal gnotobiotic calves infected with bRSV had little effect on clinical signs
or viral clearance after 10 days of infection, but resulted in a significant increase in IgM and IgA in the
bronchiolar alveolar lavage . Similarly, γδ T cell depletion does not yield changes in macroscopic
or microscopic lesions in the lungs of bRSV-infected calves compared to non-depleted control
animals . The results of these studies are difficult to interpret however, as the experimental
numbers are very small and the infection failed to yield any clinical signs. Recent results from our
laboratory suggest that bovine γδ T cell subsets respond to in vitro and in vivo BRSV infection with
pro-inflammatory chemokine and cytokine production , suggesting γδ T cells may have a role in
recruiting effector cells to the site of infection. Together, there appears a potential role for γδ T cells in
altering lung pathology and viral clearance following both hRSV and bRSV infection, but much
remains to be examined including the potential innate role of γδ T cells in regulating early virus
recognition and lymphocyte recruitment.
7. Adaptive Immunity to RSV
The development of an adaptive immune response is required for the control and clearance of
established RSV infections. Following infection, humans and cattle mount virus-specific antibody and
T cell responses; however, these responses are weak and transient, as both species can be continuously
re-infected throughout life. Clearance of RSV infection is primarily mediated by CD4 and CD8 αβ T
cells. T cell responses are directed at epitopes within several RSV proteins including the N, M, NS2,
M2-1, F and G . The F and G proteins are the major HLA class II restricted targets in both humans
and cattle [55,56], with the F protein of hRSV being the most thoroughly studied and described to
contain multiple antigenic regions . To our knowledge, there are currently no specific BoLA class
II epitopes defined for bRSV in the bovine.
While important in anti-viral immunity, the RSV-specific CD4 T cell response is also thought to
contribute to disease pathogenesis and damaging immunopathology [58–60]. CD4 T cells, and the
cytokines they produce, are key in shaping the nature of the adaptive virus-specific immune response.
HRSV infection induces a mixed Th1 and Th2-type cytokine response . Production of IL-12 by
dendritic cells, and early IFNγ is required for the priming of an effective Th1 type cytokine response;
however, hRSV has been shown to interfere with dendritic cell cytokine production and their ability to
initiate the development of a Th1 response [56,62,63]. The ensuing Th2 polarized response leads to
increased disease severity and lung injury, and is thought to block the development of an effective
Viruses 2012, 4
CD8 T cell response during both primary and secondary challenge [56,64–66]. Much of our
understanding about the adaptive immune response to hRSV is derived from small rodent models;
however, evidence from humans, while limited, suggests a similar mechanism of disease pathogenesis.
Infants infected with hRSV exhibit Th2 polarization with increased IL-4 production in the lungs and
the establishment of eosinophilia [67,68]. Interestingly, eosinophilia was also apparent in the lungs of
infants that exhibited vaccine enhanced disease after receiving a formalin-inactivated hRSV vaccine
(see section on RSV Vaccines). However, cytokine balance and the resulting disease outcome likely
depends upon genetic background, as some infants have also been shown to contain significant
numbers IFNγ-producing cells in the lungs, and these increased levels did not correlate to disease
severity or outcome .
Like humans, calves infected with bRSV develop a mixed cytokine response, but favor the
development of a Th2-type immune response following infection. Studies of the cells and lymph fluid
from bRSV infected calves reveal enhanced IL-4 and IL-13 production in the serum and tissues as
early as day 4 post infection, and increased serum levels of virus-specific IgE, indicating the
establishment of a Th2-type response [70–72]. Calves also develop IFNγ producing cells and levels of
the cytokine increase in the serum, but, as with humans, neither cell numbers nor IFNγ levels correlate
with positive disease outcome . Evidence from humans has suggested that, due to the Th2 nature
of the anti-viral immune response, hRSV infection may predispose children to the development of
allergies and asthma later in life [74,75]. Interestingly, bRSV infection in calves has also been shown
to predispose to allergic sensitization [76,77]. Gershwin et al. demonstrated that exposure to the
model allergen ovalbumin during bRSV infection resulted in significantly increased levels of IL-4,
IL-13 and ovalbumin-specific IgE compared to uninfected control calves .
Cytotoxic CD8 T cells play a critical role in the control and clearance of RSV infection. Infection of
human infants results in a significant influx of activated CD8 T cells into the airways , and calves
infected with bRSV exhibit increased CD8 T cell infiltration in the lungs, trachea and
nasopharynx . Depletion of CD8 T cells from mice  or bRSV infected calves  results in
more severe disease and increased and sustained viral shedding compared to non-depleted control
animals. In humans, the hRSV-specific HLA class I response is primarily targeted against the M2, F
and N proteins [80–82]. Bovine CD8 T cells target the M2, F, N and G proteins of bRSV [83,84].
Interestingly, while G-specific CD8 T cells are readily detectable in cattle, they have not been
demonstrated in humans . It has been reported that the strong Th2 skewing that occurs during RSV
infection acts to inhibit the development of an efficient CD8 T cell response and prevent the
establishment of long-lived memory . Anecdotally, this is evidenced by the recurring infections
that occur commonly in both humans and calves [16,18]. In the mouse model, hRSV-specific CTLs
appear impaired in both cytokine secretion and cytotoxicity [56,86,87], while calves infected with
bRSV exhibit a similar phenotype, displaying limited bRSV-specific cytotoxicity during primary
infections and impaired memory responses following challenge or vaccination [88,89].
Humoral immunity plays an important role in defending the host from RSV infection. While not
fully effective, maternal antibodies may provide some level of protection from severe RSV infection in
both humans [90–92] and calves ; however, their presence has also been described to suppress the
development of antibody and T cell responses during acute infection [94,95]. Although humans
initiate responses to several proteins of hRSV, only antibodies that are reactive to the major surface
Viruses 2012, 4
glycoproteins F and G appear to be important for protection [96,97]. The F protein is highly conserved
and the majority of the F specific response is cross-reactive, making it more important for protection
across hRSV strains . The G protein is more divergent, thus few antibodies cross-react between
virus strains [98,99]. Further, the G-specific response is particularly inefficient and it has been
proposed that this may be due to the secreted form of the G protein acting as a decoy for the host’s
humoral response [100,101].
Like humans, calves mount antibody responses to several bRSV antigens, but the primary targets
for protective humoral responses are the F, G and NP proteins . bRSV-specific IgM and IgA can
be detected in the nasal secretions and serum of bRSV infected calves as early as 8 days post
infection . BRSV-specific IgG2, the antibody isotype associated with a Th1 response, is not
detected in the serum until 1-3 months post infection. As evidence of the cytokine skewing that occurs
during RSV infection of calves, virus-specific IgG1, the isotype associated with a Th2 phenotype, is
detectable in the serum starting at 13 days post infection . In a separate study, virus-specific IgE,
another antibody associated with Th2 skewing and airway hyperresponsiveness, was detectable in the
serum concurrent with the development of clinical signs [71,72].
In humans, both neutralizing IgG and IgA are thought to have a role in protection from RSV. IgA is
important in local immunity, particularly in the upper airways and nasopharynx, while serum IgG
plays a significant role in protection of the lower airways. Adults who have been repeatedly infected
with hRSV develop sustained high levels of IgA in nasal secretions which has been shown to prevent
virus replication in the upper airways, regardless of serum Ig levels . Further underlining the
importance of both antibody types, passive immunization studies in rodents have shown that
administration of neutralizing IgG provides complete protection from hRSV replication in the lungs,
but not in nasal secretions [103–105]. However, the IgA response is often transient and neutralizing
IgM and serum IgG are likely more important for long-term protection . To date, the only licensed
therapy available for hRSV infection in humans is the passive transfer of the virus-specific monoclonal
antiserum, Palivizumab, which recognizes a conserved epitope in the F protein of hRSV. As proof of
the importance of neutralizing antibodies in the immune response to hRSV, the antiserum is effective
as a prophylactic and known to reduce disease severity in hRSV-infected infants [106–108].
8. RSV Vaccines
In the 1960s, a formalin-inactivated hRSV vaccine was prepared and tested in infants and children.
The Bernett strain of hRSV was initially propagated in human embryonic kidney cells and passaged in
vervet monkey kidney cells. The infected cells were inactivated with formalin and concentrated by
ultracentrifugation and alum precipitation. This preparation was known as lot 100. Lot 100 was
administered as two or three intramuscular doses separated by 1 to 3 months to infants and children
between 2 months and 7 years of age. Lot 100 not only failed to protect against hRSV disease, but also
induced an exaggerated clinical response to hRSV infection in infants who were hRSV näive before
vaccination [109–111]. Many vaccinates were hospitalized with LRI; in one study, the hospitalization
rate of vaccinates approached 80% compared to 5% in controls . Tragically, two infants who
received lot 100 died following hRSV infection, one at 14 months of age and the second at 16 months
of age . HRSV was readily isolated from the lower respiratory tracts of these infants, whose
Viruses 2012, 4
lungs also contained eosinophilic infiltrates. The disastrous results of those clinical trials are still felt
five decades later. To date there is no approved vaccine.
There are multiple vaccines currently marketed for bRSV (killed and modified-live) that are
generally provided as part of multivalent products. As with humans, similar vaccine-enhanced disease
has been reported from two cases of natural bRSV infections in calves [112,113]. In the former case,
an outbreak of respiratory tract disease among 5- to 7-mo old calves on a beef-fattening farm in the
Netherlands started two days after administration of a modified-live bRSV vaccine . The disease
was severe among vaccinates, but absent in non-vaccinated calves 8 mo of age or older. In the latter
case, 30% of 8-mo old Belgian Blue calves vaccinated with a beta-propiolactone inactivated bRSV
vaccine died during a naturally occurring bRSV outbreak. Interestingly, no deaths were recorded
among younger calves not vaccinated . Experimentally, vaccine-enhanced disease has been
reproduced in some studies of calves
preparations [114,115], but not in others [116,117]. Where bRSV vaccine-enhanced disease has been
observed, there is a bias toward a Th2-like response characterized by increases in serum IgE [114,118]
and eosinophils in lavage fluid .
Given the significant disease burden associated with hRSV and bRSV infections, there is a
profound interest in developing new and more efficacious vaccines for both species. RSV vaccine
development in both cattle and humans has been the topic of several recent and excellent
reviews [55,101,119]. As such, we will only briefly describe some of the approaches currently being
pursued in the field.
RSV and its target populations pose several obstacles with respect to vaccine development,
particularly the need to vaccinate populations with immature immune systems, to induce a response in
the face of maternal antibodies, and to induce an appropriate, robust and long-lasting immune
response. To address these challenges, a variety of new hRSV vaccines have recently been tested in
animal models and, in some cases, clinical trials. The primary focus of these new platforms is to
induce a more robust response using actual replicating agents, as opposed to the use of inactivated
virus, and to induce Th1-type CD4 T cell response through the use of known CD4 T cell targeted
proteins or Th1 activating adjuvants. Amongst these new candidates are synthetic and subunit vaccines
that target whole or fragments of the F, N, G and M proteins, singly or in combination. Other examples
include the use of live attenuated hRSV, such as strains lacking nonessential genes such as the NS1,
NS2, SH, G or M2-2 genes and/or cold-passaged temperature-sensitive mutants [55,119]. One such
temperature-sensitive mutant, which lacks the SH gene and contains a mutation in the L gene, proved
promising in early phase I trials but lacked efficacy during phase II clinical trials in seronegative
infants [120,121]. The stability of the mutant has recently been improved and shown success in trials
using seronegative chimpanzees . The use of nanoparticles, virosomes and virus-like particles, as
well as vector-based approaches using DNA, virus or bacterial-based vectors that express hRSV
proteins have all proven promising [55,119]. One of the vectors that has shown potential is a chimeric
bovine/human parainfluenza virus type 3-based vaccine that has been engineered to express the hRSV
F protein . This vaccine has proven safe in phase I clinical trials and is currently being tested in a
large international clinical trial in infants [123,124].
Although there is widespread use of bRSV vaccines in calves, their efficacy is controversial and
there is a definite need for improved technologies. Researchers are currently studying many of the
vaccinated with formalin-inactivated bRSV
Viruses 2012, 4
same approaches as described for hRSV, including the use of subunit based vaccines and live
attenuated bRSV . One promising example reported by Valarcher et al. reported the success of
two bRSV strains, one devoid of NS1 and the other lacking NS2 . Calves vaccinated with either
deletion mutant exhibited a robust virus-specific antibody and CD4 T cell response and were protected
against virus challenge . Interestingly, the NS2 mutant was more effective than its counterpart.
Also being extensively pursued against bRSV is the use of new adjuvants coupled with inactivated
bRSV or subunit vaccines. Amongst those showing promise is the use of CpG containing
oligodeoxynucleotides (CpG-ODN) ,
(ISCOMS) [127,128]—both of which induce a robust Th1 skewing. ISCOMS are multimers composed
of cholesterol, phospholipids, proteins and Quillaja saponins. Recent studies by Hagglund et al. have
described the ability BRSV-ISCOMs to successfully induce bRSV-specific cellular and humoral
responses and protect from virulent bRSV challenge in neonatal calves aged 3-8 weeks.
Interestingly, this protection was robust despite the presence of significant levels of maternally derived
and immunostimulating complexes
9. Potential Role of Vitamin D as an Immunomodulator During RSV Infection
Recent evidence has suggested a role for vitamin D in hematopoietic cell differentiation and
immune function [129,130]. It is known that the nuclear vitamin D receptor (VDR) and the enzymes
responsible for activation (CYP27B1; 1-hydroxylase) and degradation (CYP24A1; 24-hydroxylase)
of vitamin D are expressed in subsets of immune cells. Moreover, several aspects of immune
regulation are modified by the actions of vitamin D [129,131–134]. Based on these data and
epidemiological evidence suggesting a connection between inadequate vitamin D levels and
respiratory tract infections [135–137], there has been an examination of the ability of vitamin D to
modulate the response to in vitro respiratory infections. In the case of hRSV, it was shown that
treatment of cultured respiratory epithelial cells with 1,25(OH)2D3 decreases viral induction
of pro-inflammatory gene expression . In spite of the reduction of antiviral IFN-, there was no
concomitant increase in hRSV replication, suggesting that providing adequate vitamin D could reduce
inflammation while maintaining antiviral activity.
We examined the influence of vitamin D status on the response to bRSV experimental challenge in
calves . Calves with high or low circulating 25(OH)D3 levels were challenged with RSV and
subsequently, lung tissue samples examined at day 7 post infection. We showed, for the first time in
vivo, that bRSV infection induced expression of the VDR and associated hydroxylase enzymes in the
lung. Importantly, gene expression levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines were not suppressed in the
presence of this induced vitamin D regulatory network, but rather specific pro-inflammatory cytokines
were elevated in the high vitamin D group compared to the low vitamin D group of calves.
Further examination of the potential effects of vitamin D status on bRSV disease resolution would
require longer-term studies with immunologically sufficient and deficient vitamin D levels.
Thus, preliminary bRSV challenge studies have been conducted with groups of calves with circulating
levels considered sufficient (40–60 ng/ml) or deficient (<20 ng/ml) in 25(OH)D3. To date, we have not
observed an alteration in the clinical course of bRSV as a result of providing differing levels of vitamin
Viruses 2012, 4
In recent years, we have made significant progress in our knowledge of both bRSV and hRSV and
the way each interacts with its respective host. To date, the disease process and lesions, as well as
many aspects of the innate and adaptive immune response described during bRSV infection in the
bovine parallel those described in human patients. See Table 1 for a summary of common features
between bRSV and hRSV infection. From these data, we suggest that cattle serve as an excellent
model for studying hRSV infection in humans. The field is currently pursuing several new approaches
and vaccine platforms in both species that hold great promise for the future. Despite this, however,
considerable challenges await with respect to our understanding of the RSV-specific immune response
and the development of effective vaccine strategies.
Table 1. Features common to hRSV in infants and bRSV in calves.
More prevalent in
children <2 yrs old
More common in fall
More prevalent in calves
<6 mo old
More common in fall
Th2 cytokine bias Th2 cytokine bias [67,68,70–72]
Observed with formalin-
Observed with formalin-
The authors wish to thank Nancy Eischen, Emma Frimml-Morgan, Darrel Hoy, Tracy Porter, and
Theresa Waters for their excellent technical assistance. Further, we thank our outstanding animal
caretaker staff for the care of the calves. Finally, we thank Tyler C. Thacker for providing specific
primer sequences for the work described herein.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Viruses 2012, 4
1. Nair, H.; Nokes, D.J.; Gessner, B.D.; Dherani, M.; Madhi, S.A.; Singleton, R.J.; O'Brien, K.L.;
Roca, A.; Wright, P.F.; Bruce, N.; et al. Global burden of acute lower respiratory infections due
to respiratory syncytial virus in young children: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet
2010, 375, 1545–1555.
2. Silvestri, M.; Sabatini, F.; Defilippi, A.C.; Rossi, G.A. The wheezy infant -- immunological and
molecular considerations. Paediatr. Respir. Rev. 2004, 5 Suppl A, S81–87.
3. Stein, R.T.; Sherrill, D.; Morgan, W.J.; Holberg, C.J.; Halonen, M.; Taussig, L.M.; Wright, A.L.;
Martinez, F.D. Respiratory syncytial virus in early life and risk of wheeze and allergy by age 13
years. Lancet 1999, 354, 541–545.
4. Falsey, A.R.; Hennessey, P.A.; Formica, M.A.; Cox, C.; Walsh, E.E. Respiratory syncytial virus
infection in elderly and high-risk adults. N. Engl. J. Med. 2005, 352, 1749–1759.
5. Falsey, A.R.; Walsh, E.E. Respiratory syncytial virus infection in adults. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 2000,
6. Raboni, S.M.; Nogueira, M.B.; Tsuchiya, L.R.; Takahashi, G.A.; Pereira, L.A.; Pasquini, R.;
Siqueira, M.M. Respiratory tract viral infections in bone marrow transplant patients.
Transplantation 2003, 76, 142–146.
7. Gershwin, L.J. Bovine respiratory syncytial virus infection: immunopathogenic mechanisms. Anim.
Health Res. Rev. 2007, 8, 207–213.
8. Blount, R.E., Jr.; Morris, J.A.; Savage, R.E. Recovery of cytopathogenic agent from chimpanzees
with coryza. Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol. Med. 1956, 92, 544–549.
9. Chanock, R.; Finberg, L. Recovery from infants with respiratory illness of a virus related to
chimpanzee coryza agent (CCA). II. Epidemiologic aspects of infection in infants and young
children. Am. J. Hyg. 1957, 66, 291–300.
10. Chanock, R.; Roizman, B.; Myers, R. Recovery from infants with respiratory illness of a virus
related to chimpanzee coryza agent (CCA). I. Isolation, properties and characterization. Am. J.
Hyg. 1957, 66, 281–290.
11. Doggett, J.E.; Taylor-Robinson, D.; Gallop, R.G. A study of an inhibitor in bovine serum active
against respiratory syncytial virus. Arch. Gesamte Virusforsch 1968, 23, 126–137.
12. Paccaud, M.F.; Jacquier, C. A respiratory syncytial virus of bovine origin. Arch. Gesamte
Virusforsch 1970, 30, 327–342.
13. Jacobs, J.W.; Edington, N. Isolation of respiratory syncytial virus from cattle in Britain. Vet. Rec.
1971, 88, 694.
14. Inaba, Y.; Tanaka, Y.; Sato, K.; Ito, H.; Omori, T. Nomi virus, a virus isolated from an apparently
new epizootic respiratory disease of cattle. Jpn. J. Microbiol. 1970, 14, 246–248.
15. Inaba, Y.; Tanaka, Y.; Omori, T.; Matumoto, M. Isolation of bovine respiratory syncytial virus.
Jpn J. Exp. Med. 1970, 40, 473–474.
16. Glezen, W.P.; Taber, L.H.; Frank, A.L.; Kasel, J.A. Risk of primary infection and reinfection with
respiratory syncytial virus. Am. J. Dis. Child. 1986, 140, 543–546.
17. Valarcher, J.F.; Schelcher, F.; Bourhy, H. Evolution of bovine respiratory syncytial virus. J. Virol.
2000, 74, 10714–10728.
Viruses 2012, 4 Download full-text
18. Van der Poel, W.H.; Brand, A.; Kramps, J.A.; Van Oirschot, J.T. Respiratory syncytial virus
infections in human beings and in cattle. J. Infect. 1994, 29, 215–228.
19. Anderson, L.J.; Hierholzer, J.C.; Tsou, C.; Hendry, R.M.; Fernie, B.F.; Stone, Y.; McIntosh, K.
Antigenic characterization of respiratory syncytial virus strains with monoclonal antibodies. J.
Infect. Dis. 1985, 151, 626–633.
20. Cristina, J.; Lopez, J.A.; Albo, C.; Garcia-Barreno, B.; Garcia, J.; Melero, J.A.; Portela, A.
Analysis of genetic variability in human respiratory syncytial virus by the RNase A mismatch
cleavage method: subtype divergence and heterogeneity. Virology 1990, 174, 126–134.
21. Furze, J.M.; Roberts, S.R.; Wertz, G.W.; Taylor, G. Antigenically distinct G glycoproteins of
BRSV strains share a high degree of genetic homogeneity. Virology 1997, 231, 48–58.
22. Deplanche, M.; Lemaire, M.; Mirandette, C.; Bonnet, M.; Schelcher, F.; Meyer, G. In vivo
evidence for quasispecies distributions in the bovine respiratory syncytial virus genome. J. Gen.
Virol. 2007, 88, 1260–1265.
23. McLellan, J.S.; Yang, Y.; Graham, B.S.; Kwong, P.D. Structure of respiratory syncytial virus
fusion glycoprotein in the postfusion conformation reveals preservation of neutralizing epitopes.
J. Virol. 2011, 85, 7788–7796.
24. Johnson, P.R.; Spriggs, M.K.; Olmsted, R.A.; Collins, P.L. The G glycoprotein of human
respiratory syncytial viruses of subgroups A and B: extensive sequence divergence between
antigenically related proteins. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 1987, 84, 5625–5629.
25. Valarcher, J.F.; Schelcher, F.; Bourhy, H. Evolution of bovine respiratory syncytial virus. J. Virol.
2000, 74, 10714–10728.
26. Garcia, O.; Martin, M.; Dopazo, J.; Arbiza, J.; Frabasile, S.; Russi, J.; Hortal, M.; Perez-Brena, P.;
Martinez, I.; Garcia-Barreno, B.; et al. Evolutionary pattern of human respiratory syncytial virus
(subgroup A): cocirculating lineages and correlation of genetic and antigenic changes in the G
glycoprotein. J. Virol. 1994, 68, 5448–5459.
27. Woelk, C.H.; Holmes, E.C. Variable immune-driven natural selection in the attachment (G)
glycoprotein of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV). J. Mol. Evol. 2001, 52, 182–192.
28. Prozzi, D.; Walravens, K.; Langedijk, J.P.; Daus, F.; Kramps, J.A.; Letesson, J.J. Antigenic and
molecular analyses of the variability of bovine respiratory syncytial virus G glycoprotein. J. Gen.
Virol. 1997, 78 ( Pt 2), 359–366.
29. Fach, S.J.; Meyerholz, D.K.; Gallup, J.M.; Ackermann, M.R.; Lehmkuhl, H.D.; Sacco, R.E.
Neonatal ovine pulmonary dendritic cells support bovine respiratory syncytial virus replication
with enhanced interleukin (IL)-4 And IL-10 gene transcripts. Viral. Immunol. 2007, 20, 119–130.
30. Meyerholz, D.K.; Grubor, B.; Fach, S.J.; Sacco, R.E.; Lehmkuhl, H.D.; Gallup, J.M.; Ackermann,
M.R. Reduced clearance of respiratory syncytial virus infection in a preterm lamb model.
Microbes. Infect. 2004, 6, 1312–1319.
31. Sacco, R.E.; Nonnecke, B.J.; Palmer, M.V.; Waters, W.R.; Lippolis, J.D.; Reinhardt, T.A.
Differential expression of cytokines in response to respiratory syncytial virus infection of calves
with high or low circulating 25-hydroxyvitamin D3. PLoS One 2012, 7, e33074.