Nutrients 2012, 4, 2047-2068; doi:10.3390/nu4122047
Space Flight Calcium: Implications for Astronaut Health,
Spacecraft Operations, and Earth
Scott M. Smith 1,*, Torin McCoy 1, Daniel Gazda 2, Jennifer L. L. Morgan 3, Martina Heer 4,5
and Sara R. Zwart 6
1 Human Health and Performance Directorate, NASA Lyndon B. Johnson Space Center, Houston,
TX 77058, USA; E-Mail: email@example.com
2 Wyle Science, Technology & Engineering Group, Houston, TX 77058, USA;
3 Oak Ridge Associated Universities/NASA Post-Doctoral Fellow, NASA Lyndon B. Johnson Space
Center, Houston, TX 77058, USA; E-Mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
4 Profil Institut für Stoffwechselforschung GmbH, Hellersbergstrasse 9, 41460 Neuss, Germany;
5 University of Bonn, 53115 Bonn, Germany
6 Division of Space Life Sciences, Universities Space Research Association, Houston, TX 77058,
USA; E-Mail: email@example.com
* Author to whom correspondence should be addressed; E-Mail: firstname.lastname@example.org;
Tel.: +1-(281)-483-7204; Fax: +1-(281)-483-2888.
Received: 11 October 2012; in revised form: 13 November 2012 / Accepted: 10 December 2012 /
Published: 18 December 2012
Abstract: The space flight environment is known to induce bone loss and, subsequently,
calcium loss. The longer the mission, generally the more bone and calcium are lost. This
review provides a history of bone and calcium studies related to space flight and highlights
issues related to calcium excretion that the space program must consider so that urine can
be recycled. It also discusses a novel technique using natural stable isotopes of calcium that
will be helpful in the future to determine calcium and bone balance during space flight.
Keywords: bed rest; bone; calcium; collagen crosslinks; dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry;
Nutrients 2012, 4
Bone and calcium metabolism have been a concern for space travelers, literally since before human
space flight was a reality. A little more than a half century after the first human space flight, we have
improved our understanding of the effects of space flight on calcium and bone, but we still have much
to learn. We review here the current state of knowledge and describe ongoing studies, including
application of the findings to space exploration and implications for the general population.
2. Bone Loss
Space flight-induced bone and calcium loss have been documented for decades, and have been the
subject of many reviews [1–5]. There have also been several evaluations of ground-based analogs,
including the most common, bed rest [6,7]. Bed rest is a viable model of space flight-induced bone
loss, producing metabolic changes and bone loss that are qualitatively similar to those brought on by
space flight but have a smaller magnitude. Bone loss in bed rest is about half of that observed in space
Documentation of negative calcium balance and increased calcium excretion during space flight
first came from Gemini and Apollo missions of the 1960s and early 1970s [10,11], but bed rest studies
documenting negative calcium balance go back even further, with initial documentation in the
1940s . Although urinary and fecal calcium excretion were shown clearly to increase on
short-duration space flights (1–2 weeks of flight), not until the longer Skylab missions were flown
(1973–1974) were actual changes in bone observed using densitometry [13,14].
In the 1990s the Russian space station Mir provided a platform for long-duration studies on changes
in bone during space flight. Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) scans on astronauts and
cosmonauts began to better characterize and quantify bone loss during space flight [2,15,16]. Although
considerable site-to-site variability exists, along with crewmember-to-crewmember variability, in
general, a 1.0%–1.5% loss of bone mineral density occurred per month of space flight . Bone
biochemistry studies in the 1990s also expanded significantly, largely fueled by the identification of
collagen crosslinks as markers that could be used to assess bone resorption, and development of
immunoassays to measure these crosslinks along with markers of bone formation. Novel techniques
are being developed to assess overall bone balance using stable isotopes of calcium. These techniques
will be beneficial because they are noninvasive (only a urine sample is needed), might be possible to
do during flight, and will give a picture of overall bone balance instead of resorption or formation
alone. These techniques will be discussed in detail below.
Early flight experiments with animals pointed to a decrease in bone formation as the metabolic key
to bone loss, whereas human studies (both space flight and bed rest) clearly pointed to an increase in
bone resorption, with bone formation being either unchanged or slightly decreased [17–22]. Further
research documented that the discrepancy between the animal and human data was not caused by a
problem with the animal model itself, but rather by an issue with the age of the animals used in those
early flight studies. In young rats, bone formation is suppressed during space flight. In mature rats,
bone resorption predominates and little change is seen in bone formation , as evidenced in
hindlimb-suspension studies. These differences in mechanism of bone metabolism must be considered
Nutrients 2012, 4
when interpreting results from space flight studies. Young animals are commonly used in research, and
provide an added benefit for space flight studies in that more animals may be flown in the limited
space available for animal research on these missions. Although any model has limitations, and these
need to be carefully accounted for, animal studies do provide the ability to do more extensive research
on mechanisms of bone loss.
In 2000, the first crews took up residence on the International Space Station (ISS), marking the
beginning of what many hope will be a permanent human presence off the planet. One of the novel
aspects of the ISS was the inclusion of resistance exercise equipment. Details of these efforts will be
described below, but although initial evaluations were disappointing , possibly because of altered
kinematics , recent evidence illustrates the potential of proper nutrition and exercise regimens to
prevent whole-body and regional loss of bone mineral density  during extended space flight.
3. Calcium Isotopes and Relevance for Bone Turnover
Analytical techniques to assess bone health, bone loss, and bone metabolism continue to evolve
with technology. Although densitometry techniques (such as DXA and quantitative computerized
tomography) provide valuable assessment of specific bones, these techniques detect only relatively
large changes in bone, and it takes several months for changes of this magnitude to occur. Studying
calcium requires either intensive balance studies or tracer kinetic studies. Bone biochemical markers
can provide more rapid assessments of changes in bone formation or resorption, but assessing the
relative association of these two factors has not been possible to date, and thus it is difficult to assess
net changes in bone calcium content.
A new technique to rapidly detect and quantitatively predict changes in bone mineral balance
(the ratio of bone formation to resorption) has recently been validated in a bed rest model .
Changes in bone mineral balance as a result of bed rest can be detected by measuring the ratios of
stable calcium isotopes in urine from individuals who have not received any stable isotope tracers .
This calcium isotope biomarker is based on natural, biologically induced variations. These variations
are a result of the 6 naturally occurring calcium isotopes (40Ca, 42Ca, 43Ca, 44Ca, 46Ca, and 48Ca)
reacting at different rates depending on their mass . In general, isotopic selectivity can occur in all
elements with multiple stable isotopes, and has been measured in light elements such as hydrogen,
oxygen, carbon, and nitrogen for many decades. These variations arise because the vibrational
frequencies of any chemical bonds are a function of the masses of the constituent nuclides. As a result,
more energy is required to break bonds formed from heavy isotopes than for the same bond with a
lighter isotope. In chemical reactions that do attain equilibrium (which are rare in biology), heavier
isotopes are preferentially concentrated in the strongest chemical bonding environments. In chemical
reactions that do not attain equilibrium (e.g., kinetic reactions), the bonds incorporating lighter
isotopes usually react more quickly than those incorporating heavier isotopes. Kinetic processes like
diffusion, evaporation, and precipitation, preferentially select lighter isotopes because they move faster
than heavy isotopes [30,31]. In soft tissue (e.g., blood, urine), variations in the calcium isotope
composition exist because bone formation depletes soft tissue of lighter calcium isotopes most likely
as a result of isotope selectivity during osteoblast-induced calcium precipitation. Bone resorption
releases that isotopically light calcium back into soft tissue. Therefore, when bone is being resorbed, as
Nutrients 2012, 4
is the case during bed rest, the urinary calcium isotope abundance shifts toward lighter values
(i.e., −δ44/42Ca; more 42Ca and less 44Ca relative to baseline). Applying this technique to a bed rest
study, it was shown that the calcium isotope ratio shifted in a direction consistent with bone loss after
just 7 days of bed rest, long before detectable changes in bone density occur. Consistent with this
interpretation, the calcium isotope variation accompanied changes observed in N-telopeptide, while
bone-specific alkaline phosphatase, a bone-formation biomarker, was unchanged (Figure 1) .
Figure 1. Variations in bone biochemical markers N-telopeptide (NTX, top panel) and
bone-specific alkaline phosphatase (BSAP, middle panel), along with calcium isotopes
(bottom panel), during and after bed rest (days 0 to 40). Percent changes were calculated as
the difference between the measured value at each time point and the average of the
pre-bed rest values (baseline, days to left of day 0) for that individual. All values are
mean ± SD. The calcium isotopes shift in a direction consistent with bone loss after just
7 days of bed rest and track the signal observed in NTX while BSAP remains unchanged.
Note: This figure is adapted with permission from , Copyright © 2012 National
Academy of Sciences. Data are from 12 subjects.
Nutrients 2012, 4
As the relationship between calcium isotopes and bone mineral balance is well established based on
the isotope selectivity principles described above and preliminary work measuring the offset between
soft tissue and bone [32,33], this relationship can be used to quantitatively translate the changes in the
calcium isotope ratio in urine to changes in bone mineral density using a simple model (Figure 2) .
Using this model it was estimated that subjects lost 0.25% ± 0.07% (1 SD) of their bone mass from
day 7 to day 30 of bed rest . This rate of loss extrapolates to a loss of 1.36% ± 0.38% of skeletal
mass over 119 days, which is equivalent, within error, to bone loss rates determined by DXA scans in
long-term (119-day) bed rest studies .
Figure 2. Schematic of model pools and fluxes used to quantify bone loss. Fdiet is the flux
of calcium absorbed from diet, Fbone and Fresorp are the bone formation and resorption
fluxes, and Furine and Fbile are the net excretion fluxes of calcium through urine and bile
respectively. 44/42Casoft and δ44/42Cabone are the Ca isotopic compositions of the soft tissue
and bone pools, δ44/42Cadiet and δ44/42Caurine are the isotopic compositions of the fluxes of
Ca absorbed from diet and excreted in urine, and ε44/42Cabone, ε44/42Caurine, and ε44/42Cabile are
the isotopic variations associated with forming bone, urine, and bile, respectively, from the
soft tissue pool. Note: This figure is adapted with permission from , Copyright © 2012
National Academy of Sciences.
A preliminary study examined the calcium isotope shift in bed rest subjects undergoing three
different treatments (untreated bed rest, the bisphosphonate alendronate, and intense resistance
exercise) [35,36]. In this study there were significant differences in isotope response: the control
group’s calcium isotope composition shifted in a direction consistent with bone resorption, while the
alendronate and resistance exercise groups’ calcium isotope composition shifted in a manner
suggesting maintained and slightly increased bone formation, respectively .
Given the rapid signal observed using calcium isotope measurements and the potential to
quantitatively assess bone loss, this technique is ideally suited for space flight studies in which changes
Nutrients 2012, 4
in bone formation and resorption are not only being altered by space flight itself but are being
manipulated by various countermeasures.
4. Dietary Calcium
When bone loss is considered, calcium intake is an obvious initial concern. Skylab crews
consumed an average of 894 ± 142 (SD) mg calcium/day  while participating in carefully
planned and executed metabolic balance studies over the entire course of their missions (28, 59, and
84 days) [14,37].
Based on reviews of available information, a decision was made requiring that the ISS food system
shall provide 1000–1200 mg calcium per day , similar to Earth-based recommendations. Proximate
analysis of the foods provided in the ―standard‖ menu revealed that calcium content of the ISS menu
averages 1020 ± 109 mg calcium/day .
Although the crews self-select meals while they are on board the ISS, dietary intake estimates using
a food frequency questionnaire designed for space flight documented actual intakes of calcium
during flight that were in the same range as in the ―standard‖ menu, 1068 ± 384 mg calcium/day in one
report , and 912 ± 229 and 1025 ± 309 mg calcium/day in another . Thus, intakes typically are
close to or meeting planned calcium intake during flight, which is similar to the Earth-based
5. Calcium Absorption, Metabolism, and Excretion
In space flight and bed rest models, changes in bone biochemistry occur rapidly after humans enter
the altered environment. This is hypothesized to be related to a loss of bone in response to unloading,
and the release of calcium from bone, which suppresses parathyroid hormone. This suppression of
parathyroid hormone in turn is associated with a drop in circulating 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D and a
decrease in calcium absorption.
In space flight studies, serum total and ionized calcium are tightly regulated, and do not manifest as
consistent measurable changes during flight [21,26,39,40]. Parathyroid hormone decreases during
flight , although because of the small numbers of subjects, this change is not always statistically
significant [18,22]. Circulating concentrations of the active form of vitamin D—1,25-dihydroxyvitamin
D—are decreased during flight (vitamin D stores will be addressed below). Calcium absorption has
been shown by calcium tracer kinetic studies to be decreased during flight [21,22,41]. This decreased
absorption has also been indirectly evidenced through increased fecal calcium during flight [10,14,37].
Urinary calcium excretion is also increased during flight (this will be addressed in greater detail below).
In bed rest, findings generally similar to those from space flight have been documented: unchanged
total circulating calcium [42–45], unchanged [44,45] or slightly increased ionized calcium ,
decreased parathyroid hormone [44–48] and 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D concentrations [42,45,46],
decreased calcium absorption , and increased urinary [42,43,45–49] and fecal calcium . As
mentioned earlier, although the biochemical and physiological changes in bed rest are similar to those
observed in space flight, the magnitudes of the changes are less in the ground-based analog. As with
any area of research, particularly research with human subjects, not all studies reveal the same effects
on all analytes. For example, some studies have shown increased serum calcium levels (within normal
Nutrients 2012, 4
limits) [46,47]. Not all studies have shown decreases in circulating parathyroid hormone concentrations
during bed rest; some have shown trends that were not statistically significant [47,49], others have
shown clearly unchanged concentrations [42,43]. Many factors are likely to lead to these
discrepancies, including study design and controls; subject age, gender, and pre-study fitness levels;
laboratory analytical methods; and inherent lab-to-lab variability. Despite these discrepancies, bed rest
remains the best analog of space flight with regard to bone and calcium metabolism.
6. Bone Loss Countermeasures
Along with the identification of space flight-induced bone loss, came a significant effort to find a
means to counteract this loss. Many countermeasures have been proposed and studied, including
physical, nutritional, and pharmacological measures. As with virtually all space flight research, ground
testing is required to document proof of concept before a countermeasure is implemented on a space
mission. Thus, numerous bed rest and related analog studies have been done in which bone
countermeasures were evaluated.
Physical countermeasures tested in bed rest studies have included exercise, vibration, and
centrifugation. Resistance exercise has shown the most promise in combating bone loss that results
from skeletal unloading. Heavy resistance exercise (such as weight-lifting) results in increased bone
formation but has little or no effect on resorption, while maintaining bone mineral density . When
heavy resistance exercise was combined with an aerobic type of exercise countermeasure (treadmill
exercise within a lower-body negative pressure device), the effect was similar, although a striking
dose-response relationship of the effect was observed . That is, when subjects performed resistance
exercise only every other day (3–4 days/week), the increase in bone formation was half of what it was
in subjects who performed resistance exercise 6 days per week.
Low-level vibration seemed promising as a bone loss countermeasure judging by a pilot study with
human subjects and animal model data. However, although in bed rest vibration had some beneficial
effects on bone marrow and vertebral disks [50–52], it did not protect bone mineral density as was
initially hoped . Although vibration of higher intensity or a combination of vibration and resistance
exercise produced more encouraging results with bone and muscle [48,54–58], some concerns have
been raised about potential risks of repetitive-motion injuries.
Space flight-induced bone loss is clearly related to a lack of the gravity found on Earth. Preliminary
studies have been conducted to evaluate the counteraction of bone loss by artificial gravity, produced
either by centrifugation [59,60] or by simply standing or walking for specified time periods during the
bed rest phase of bed rest studies. Although standing or walking for 2–4 h daily during bed rest
reduced hypercalciuria , an hour of centrifugation daily failed to have a positive effect on bone
health [44,62]. Many have proposed that subjects exercise during centrifugation, and although this has
proven beneficial for the muscle and cardiovascular systems , clear effects on bone have yet to
be documented. Artificial gravity should clearly, at some point, have an effect on bone health, but the
ability to provide this on spacecraft will be an engineering challenge.
Nutritional countermeasures also have the potential to mitigate bone loss. One potential nutritional
countermeasure is mitigation of low-level metabolic acidosis that can result from metabolism of
dietary components, including excess amounts of sulfur-containing amino acids and sodium chloride.
Nutrients 2012, 4
Decreasing the intake of sulfur-containing amino acids and decreasing the intake of sodium chloride
have been documented to mitigate bone loss in bed rest studies, and both of these nutritional
countermeasures are being tested on the ISS. In one study the impact of altering the ratio of animal
protein to potassium in the diet (not from supplements) is being examined, using animal protein as a
proxy for sulfur-containing amino acids and potassium as an estimate for organic base precursor salts
(carbonate, etc.) in the diet [64–67]. The literature contains many conflicting studies of the effects of
protein on bone, but bed rest (and space flight) provides a unique situation, in which generally healthy
individuals are placed in an environment that induces bone loss. The negative effect of protein on bone
seems to occur during bed rest (but not during an ambulatory control phase), and is more pronounced
with greater duration of bed rest [64–67]. Negative effects of protein on bone have also been found in
studies of individuals with inadequate intake of calcium, vitamin D, protein, or other nutrients, or
individuals with mobility challenges. However, in many studies of healthy, ambulatory, well-nourished
individuals, no effect (or at least no negative effect) of protein on bone was found . This is an area
where space flight studies might help to bridge gaps in the literature, in documenting that neither case
is ―right‖ or ―wrong,‖ but rather that the conditions of the experiments in essence provide different
models for the effect of protein on bone metabolism.
Most of the offered space food up to now is rather high in sodium, mainly sodium chloride, content.
This results in a high dietary sodium intake for residents on the ISS, whose average intake is more than
5000 mg of sodium per day, with individual intakes exceeding 12,000 mg/day [8,9,38,69,70]. In the
general population, high sodium chloride intake induces increased urinary calcium excretion [71–77]
and renal stone risk . Controlled studies in humans have shown that high sodium chloride intake
may lead to low-grade metabolic acidosis [79,80]. As the resorbing cells, osteoclasts, need an acidic
environment to be activated [81–83], the acidosis that results from high sodium chloride intake might
cause increased bone resorption as shown by bone resorption markers . This effect is exacerbated
when bone-resorbing mechanisms are already activated because of the immobilization in bed rest .
Bone formation, on the other hand, does not seem to be affected by acidosis, as shown by bone
formation markers . How much high sodium chloride intake affects bone turnover during space
flight is currently being examined on the ISS in controlled studies, by comparing bone turnover in
phases of low and high sodium intake. To what extent the increased amount of dietary sodium chloride
is responsible for the loss of bone mass in space flight is not known. However, taking into account the
extremely high sodium intake in the daily diet of astronauts [8,9,38,69], it is very likely that bone loss
can be decreased by lowering daily sodium chloride intake. As a consequence of that, and further
undesirable effects of high sodium chloride intake in space flight, NASA has made a tremendous effort
to decrease the salt content in the American space food products.
Omega-3 fatty acid intake has been shown to mitigate bone resorption in bed rest . This was
supported by cell culture studies in which eicosapentaenoic acid suppressed NFκB activation in
osteoclasts . Controlled studies in humans and animals also support a protective role of fish and
omega-3 fatty acids in bone health [86–90]. Controlled studies during space flight have not yet been
possible, but a somewhat crude negative association between fish intake and bone loss has been
Vitamin D is a concern for space travelers, in part because their dietary sources of vitamin D are
insufficient, and in part because they lack ultraviolet light exposure . Vitamin D stores decline
Nutrients 2012, 4
during flight if supplemental intake of this vitamin is inadequate [22,38]. Ground analog studies have
been conducted in Antarctica [91,92], where crews who stay during the winter also get little or
no ultraviolet light exposure. Recent studies have documented that supplementation with 800 IU
vitamin D/day will maintain vitamin D stores in astronauts on 6-month space missions . Although
vitamin D is likely not a countermeasure for space flight-induced bone loss, vitamin D deficiency will
surely exacerbate the problem.
Studies with other nutrients have also been attempted, with the aim of providing higher intake of
calcium  or vitamin K [93,94], but to date these have not provided enough convincing ground-based
data to warrant further investigation of calcium or vitamin K intake .
Pharmacologic studies focusing on bisphosphonates have been conducted in bed rest (and related
human and animal models) with several forms of these antiresorptive drugs [35,96–99]. Initial in-flight
testing with alendronate was conducted recently . Initial results seem promising, but concerns
over side effects arise with any pharmaceutical agent.
Exogenous testosterone is also often proposed as a potential countermeasure for bone and muscle
loss of space flight. This idea is based on data from a 1993 Space Shuttle flight, with 4 subjects and
one data point for each subject . It is noteworthy that these 4 subjects were also consuming about
half of their energy requirement in the days before data collection . Detailed analysis of data
from 15 crewmembers on long-duration flights to the ISS found no change in circulating testosterone
during flight in well-nourished crewmembers . Similar findings were also reported in bed rest
Combinations of countermeasures, including heavy resistance exercise and good nutritional intakes,
have recently been associated with maintenance of bone mineral density during space flight. ISS
crewmembers consuming an adequate diet (maintaining intake of energy and other nutrients, including
maintaining optimal vitamin D status) and exercising with an enhanced suite of exercise equipment,
including treadmill, cycle, and a high-load resistance exercise device were able to maintain their
whole-body and regional bone mineral density at preflight levels . This regimen led to an increase
in bone formation without suppressing the space flight-induced increase in bone resorption, and thus
questions and concerns remain about bone strength. Nonetheless, after more than a half century of
space travel and many proposed countermeasures that were unable to mitigate bone mineral density
loss, this is a significant step forward.
7. Urinary Calcium and Renal Stone Risk
One of the immediate concerns about increased urinary calcium during space flight is the increased
risk of renal stone formation. This increased risk has been documented during both short- and
long-duration space missions [103–105], as well as in bed rest [106–110]. Given that the occurrence of
a kidney stone on orbit would likely result in the medical evacuation of the affected crewmember
(and likely end the mission for all crewmembers, given the nature of spacecraft), the likelihood of a
kidney stone occurring has warranted a fair amount of attention. Many factors can increase or decrease
renal stone risk, but increased fluid intake is clearly the easiest, and a proven effective, means to
reduce this risk . Space-flight studies suggest that increased fluid intake is a viable
countermeasure after flight, when stone risk remains increased relative to preflight levels .
Nutrients 2012, 4
However, in some cases urine chemistry changes may indicate that additional in-flight
countermeasures are required . One such potential countermeasure is potassium citrate, which has
an alkalinizing effect on urine and thus will reduce stone-forming potential .
8. Urinary Calcium and Spacecraft Water Reclamation
Renal stone risk and bone loss are well known to be medical concerns for space flight, and recently
urinary calcium precipitation became a concern for operation of the ISS Program for an entirely
different reason. In this section, we will walk through the process undertaken by NASA’s Nutritional
Biochemistry Laboratory and Water and Food Analytical Laboratory to make recommendations to the
ISS Program related to urinary calcium concentration and fluid intake, and we will provide the
in-flight urine data that were used to make these decisions.
In late 2008 NASA deployed the Urine Processor Assembly (UPA), a system designed to reclaim
water from urine. Reclaiming water from urine is a significant step toward closing the life-support loop
on the ISS and significantly reduces the resupply requirement for this critical resource.
The UPA works on the principle of reduced-pressure distillation. Preserved urine is collected in a
metal bellows tank that feeds a fixed-volume recirculation loop. As water is removed from the
preserved urine, additional urine flows from the bellows tank to maintain the volume in the
recirculation loop. The loop also contains a brine tank that is emptied at the end of each concentration
cycle. The amount of water recovered during each concentration cycle is calculated as a percentage of
the total amount of urine added to the recirculation loop. The initial goal for the UPA was to recover
85% of the water in urine. This corresponds to 232 L of water for a 41-L brine tank and 119 L of water
for a 21-L brine tank. The brine that is collected during each concentration cycle is discarded in the
non-reusable resupply vehicles that deliver cargo to the ISS.
After initial deployment and checkout of the UPA, and several months of normal operations, a hard
failure occurred in the system. This failure was later determined to be the result of precipitation in the
distillation assembly and recirculation loop. Several brine samples and hardware components were
returned as part of the failure investigation, and after extensive ground analyses the precipitate was
identified as calcium sulfate. The primary source of the sulfate was sulfuric acid, which is one
component of the preservative added to urine when it is collected in the waste hygiene compartment
(toilet). The preservative is added to inhibit biological activity and prevent ammonia formation while
the urine is stored before it is processed. The sulfate combined with the calcium in urine to form the
precipitate, which coated the surface of the distillation assembly (Figure 3).
An extensive review of urinary calcium excretion during space flight was conducted after the
failure occurred, because preflight testing of the UPA had shown no evidence of precipitation.
Evaluation of existing in-flight urinary calcium data shed new light on the cause of the UPA failure
and, by extension, the risk of renal stone formation during space flight. Data were initially evaluated in
2010 and then the updated data set was reanalyzed in 2012. By then, the data set had expanded to
include samples from 10 additional subjects (2–5 in-flight samples for each subject). The intent of
revisiting the data was to determine if the findings of the initial assessment were still valid. We report
both data sets here and elaborate on the impact of the assessments on water reclamation on the ISS and
on evaluation of renal stone risk.
Nutrients 2012, 4
Figure 3. Photograph of calcium sulfate precipitates formed inside the Urine Processor
Assembly (UPA) distillation assembly on the International Space Station (ISS), and
scanning electron micrograph (inset) of precipitates formed during UPA ground tests.
Photo and micrograph courtesy of the NASA Marshall Space Flight Center Environmental
Control and Life Support (ECLS) Project.
Water recovery in the UPA is limited by the concentration of calcium in the urine, and not the total
amount of calcium excreted per day. For this reason, total urine volume was a key variable in the
assessments. Figure 4 shows urinary calcium excretion, urine volume, and urinary calcium
concentration data before and during flight, separated by year of collection. Independent of time,
urinary calcium excretion is increased during flight (as noted above), and urine volume is decreased.
This combination of effects results in higher urinary calcium concentrations during space flight. The
red lines in the right panel reflect the calculated values above which precipitation would be expected
when recovering 85% of the water. As shown in Figure 4, given the number of data points above the
lines in 2009, the initial precipitation event that occurred on orbit should have been expected.
Figure 4. Urinary calcium excretion (left), urine volume (middle), and urinary calcium
concentration (right) before and during flight, by year of collection on the ISS. Each
symbol represents a 24-h urine collection; 23 crewmembers may have each provided up to
five 24-h collections during flight, and at least 4 before flight. Within data sets, the
horizontal lines represent the mean ± 1 SD. The green dashed line in the right panel
represents a calcium concentration of 28.3 mg/dL, the expected calcium precipitation point
for UPA water recovery at 70%, and the red dashed line represents calcium concentrations
of 14.2 mg/dL, the expected calcium precipitation point for UPA water recovery at 85%. A
subset of these data, in a different form, have been published, along with details of urine
collection procedures .
Nutrients 2012, 4
After the initial data review and analysis in 2010, a decision was made to reduce the water recovery
rate to 65%, which significantly reduced the amount of water recovered during each concentration
cycle. Eventually, the recovery rate was increased to 70%, but that was still much lower than the
initially targeted 85%. When the data were reevaluated in 2012, the expanded data set indicated that
the average of all combined urinary calcium concentrations had dropped by 8% relative to the average
of data available in 2010. This was largely due to the fact that the average urinary calcium
concentrations for the 10 additional subjects were 18% lower than those for the first 13 subjects
(Figure 4). When daily urinary calcium excretion and total urine volumes were examined, this
difference in calcium concentration was found to be almost entirely the result of increased urine
volumes (Figure 4).
Data from in-flight food frequency questionnaires (FFQs) allowed us to compare fluid intake over
time; the average fluid intake increased from 1904 ± 414 mL/day in crews that launched in 2006–2007
to 2284 ± 184 mL/day in crews that launched in 2010. This increased fluid intake was consistent with
the observed higher urine volumes and may be attributed to a number of factors, including education
of the crews on the importance of fluid intake. The need for adequate fluid intake was emphasized in
preflight briefings with crews after the initial precipitation event. The UPA served as a perfect analog
for the human kidney to illustrate the potential for formation of precipitates (renal stones). Another
contributing factor could be launching and installation of the U.S. Potable Water Dispenser in early
2009. This provided a second dispensing point for potable water on the ISS and simplified access to
water. Importantly, the chance that the more recent crews simply happened to habitually drink more
water cannot be ignored. Regardless of the cause, in evaluating these data, it was determined that
consumption of fluid at >32 mL/kg body weight was associated with urinary calcium concentrations
that would allow recovery of water at 75% with minimal risk of precipitation (Figure 5) and also
reduce the risk of renal stone formation.
Figure 5. In-flight fluid intake and associated in-flight urinary calcium concentration of
crewmembers on the ISS. Each symbol represents a 24-h urine collection; individual
crewmembers may have provided up to five 24-h collections during flight, and at least
4 before flight. Dashed horizontal lines reflect urinary calcium concentrations above which
calcium precipitation would be expected for UPA water recoveries at 70% and 75%.
Nutrients 2012, 4
For the 23 crewmembers included in the data set, 32 mL/kg body weight equals an average of
2.5 L/day of fluid, the amount of water that the water recovery system on the ISS is designed to
provide for crewmembers. Thus, this level of water consumption would not be considered
extraordinary or even atypical. The fluid intake requirement for ISS crewmembers is 1.0–1.5 mL/kcal,
but not less than 2000 mL/day .
From an ISS Program point of view, it would be ideal if one could predict in-flight urinary calcium
concentrations on the basis of preflight data. This would allow personalized consultations with
individual crewmembers to minimize their health risks during flight and tailor water recovery to
reduce precipitation risks for a given crew complement. To this end, the available data were evaluated
from two perspectives: using 24-h pools (Figure 6, left panel), and using single-void urinary calcium
concentration data (Figure 6, right panel) to determine whether a predictable relationship existed
between preflight and in-flight urinary calcium concentrations. These data suggest that although
variability is substantial, there does seem to be a relationship.
Figure 6. Relationships between preflight and in-flight urinary calcium concentrations.
Left panel: Each symbol represents a 24-h urine collection, and on the x axis individual
crewmember preflight data were averaged, with individual in-flight data points shown on
the graph. Right panel: Each point reflects the average of all individual urine voids, and the
error bars reflect one standard deviation of the data before flight (horizontal) or during
flight (vertical). The green dashed lines represent calcium concentrations of 28.3 mg/dL,
the expected calcium precipitation point for UPA water recovery at 70%, and the red
dashed lines represent calcium concentrations of 14.2 mg/dL, the expected calcium
precipitation point for UPA water recovery at 85%.
In the attempt to understand the nature of urinary calcium and operational aspects of this system,
many facets were examined. Data were evaluated to determine if urinary calcium concentrations
changed over the course of a mission, but no significant relationship was observed. That is, urinary
calcium concentration was essentially the same earlier and later in the 6-month mission. Single-void
data were also evaluated to assess whether excluding the first morning void from water recovery
would eliminate higher average calcium concentrations in urine, but again, somewhat surprisingly, this
was found not to be the case (Figure 7). This was true for subjects participating in a study in which
Nutrients 2012, 4
70 mg of alendronate was administered once weekly during flight, and also was true for those not
taking alendronate (Figure 7).
Figure 7. Creatinine (left panel) and calcium (right panel) concentration in single-void
(SV) urine samples, by time of day when samples were collected. Some ISS crewmembers
were participating in an experiment on bisphosphonate (alendronate) use as a bone loss
countermeasure. These data are shown with filled symbols, but did not have a significant
effect on calcium concentration.
Results from the expanded data set and documented efforts to educate crews on the importance of
adequate fluid intake led the ISS Program in 2012 to make the decision to increase water recovery by
the UPA from 70% to 74%–75%. This decision required the periodic reevaluation of urinary calcium
concentrations to assess whether or not the trend for increased fluid intake and urine output is being
maintained. Increasing the water recovery percentage in the UPA will reclaim an additional 60–80 L of
water per year. When one considers the cost of launching 60–80 kg of water, the 4%–5% increase in
water recovery yields a significant cost savings. An additional benefit of increasing the water recovery
rate in the UPA is the reduction in crew time associated with changing the brine tank. Crew time is
arguably the most valuable resource on the ISS, and running the UPA at 74%–75% recovery is
estimated to save 6–8 h of crew time each year.
Many health risks are associated with alterations in bone and calcium metabolism during space
flight, extending from short-term risk of renal stone formation to long-term bone loss. Understanding
calcium metabolism during space flight, and developing methods to counteract and detect bone loss,
will be critical for exploration beyond low Earth orbit. As briefly reviewed here, these studies and
findings will have multiple applications to space travel (including impacts on non-human spacecraft
systems), and will have implications for the medical and scientific communities here on Earth as well.
Nutrients 2012, 4
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Sibonga, J.D.; Cavanagh, P.R.; Lang, T.F.; LeBlanc, A.D.; Schneider, V.S.; Shackelford, L.C.;
Smith, S.M.; Vico, L. Adaptation of the skeletal system during long-duration spaceflight. Clin.
Rev. Bone Miner. Metab. 2008, 5, 249–261.
LeBlanc, A.; Schneider, V.; Shackelford, L.; West, S.; Oganov, V.; Bakulin, A.; Voronin, L.
Bone mineral and lean tissue loss after long duration space flight. J. Musculoskelet. Neuronal
Interact. 2000, 1, 157–160.
Alexandre, C.; Vico, L. Pathophysiology of bone loss in disuse osteoporosis. Joint Bone Spine
2011, 78, 572–576.
Whedon, G.D.; Rambaut, P.C. Effects of long-duration spaceflight on calcium metabolism:
Review of human studies from Skylab to the present. Acta Astronaut. 2006, 58, 59–81.
Heer, M.; Kamps, N.; Biener, C.; Korr, C.; Boerger, A.; Zittermann, A.; Stehle, P.; Drummer, C.
Calcium metabolism in microgravity. Eur. J. Med. Res. 1999, 4, 357–360.
LeBlanc, A.D.; Spector, E.R.; Evans, H.J.; Sibonga, J.D. Skeletal responses to space flight and
the bed rest analog: A review. J. Musculoskelet. Neuronal Interact. 2007, 7, 33–47.
Pavy-Le Traon, A.; Heer, M.; Narici, M.V.; Rittweger, J.; Vernikos, J. From space to Earth:
Advances in human physiology from 20 years of bed rest studies (1986–2006). Eur. J. Appl.
Physiol. 2007, 101, 143–194.
Smith, S.M.; Zwart, S.R.; Kloeris, V.; Heer, M. Nutritional Biochemistry of Space Flight; Nova
Science Publishers: New York, NY, USA, 2009.
Smith, S.M.; Zwart, S.R. Nutritional biochemistry of spaceflight. Adv. Clin. Chem. 2008, 46,
10. Lutwak, L.; Whedon, G.D.; Lachance, P.A.; Reid, J.M.; Lipscomb, H.S. Mineral, electrolyte and
nitrogen balance studies of the Gemini-VII fourteen-day orbital space flight. J. Clin. Endocrinol.
Metab. 1969, 29, 1140–1156.
11. Rambaut, P.C.; Leach, C.S.; Johnson, P.C. Calcium and phosphorus change of the Apollo
17 crew members. Nutr. Metab. 1975, 18, 62–69.
12. Deitrick, J.E.; Whedon, G.D.; Shorr, E. Effects of immobilization upon various metabolic and
physiologic functions of normal men. Am. J. Med. 1948, 4, 3–36.
13. Whedon, G.; Lutwak, L.; Rambaut, P.; Whittle, M.; Leach, C.; Reid, J.; Smith, M. Effect of
weightlessness on mineral metabolism; metabolic studies on Skylab orbital flights. Calcif. Tissue
Res. 1976, 21, 423–430.
14. Whedon, G.D.; Lutwak, L.; Rambaut, P.C.; Whittle, M.W.; Smith, M.C.; Reid, J.; Leach, C.;
Stadler, C.R.; Sanford, D.D. Mineral and Nitrogen Metabolic Studies, Experiment M071.
In Biomedical Results from Skylab (NASA Sp-377); Johnston, R.S., Dietlein, L.F., Eds.; National
Aeronautics and Space Administration: Washington, DC, USA, 1977; pp. 164–174.