Methods of using household consumption and expenditures survey (HCES) data to estimate the potential nutritional impact of fortified staple foods.

Hubert Department of Global Health, Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, 1599 Clifton Road, N.E. - GHI Rm 6.431, Atlanta, GA 30322, USA.
Food and nutrition bulletin (Impact Factor: 1.5). 09/2012; 33(3 Suppl):S185-9.
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Micronutrient malnutrition, caused largely by inadequate dietary intake, is a global public health problem that adversely affects health, child growth and development, work capacity, and quality of life. Mass fortification of widely consumed edible products has the potential to increase micronutrient intakes and thus alleviate some nutritional deficiencies. Although individual-level data about food consumption patterns are ideal for informing the design of food fortification programs, they are often unavailable. Household Consumption and Expenditures Surveys (HCES) are nationally representative cross-sectional surveys conducted over a 12-month period every 2 to 5 years, primarily to characterize household expenditures.
We describe how expenditure data from HCES can serve as a proxy for household food consumption and thus aid in choosing which foods tofortify and in determining how much of a micronutrient to add to that food.
We describe methods of using HCES data to characterize apparent food consumption patterns among different strata within a population.
There are several limitations of using HCES data to describe apparent food consumption. HCES do not directly capture information about true food intake, but rather describe food expenditures. We assume that purchased foods are not shared with guests, wasted, fed to animals, gifted, or stockpiled for later use. We also assume that foods are allocated within each household based on energy needs.
Despite the limitations of using HCES data to estimate apparent food consumption, the dearth of individual-level data about food intake renders HCES data useful in designing food fortification programs.

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Knowledge of the amount and quality of food consumed by a population is essential in determining the adequacy of the food availability and supply. Since its founding the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) has developed methods for determining food availability and consumption that may be useful to other investigators. Based on FAO's 60 years of experience in conducting Household Consumption and Expenditures Surveys (HCES), to explain and demonstrate the advantages and use of the Adult Male Equivalent (AME) and Equivalent Nutrition Unit (ENU) concepts. The important factors related to the AME and ENU, such as energy requirements, size and composition of the food consumer unit, and attendance at meals, are explained through the examples of two hypothetical families: a family consisting of a father, a mother, a 12-year old daughter, and a 3-year old son plus an adult guest; and a family consisting of a single mother, a 10-year old son, and two daughters, 6 and 4 years of age. The reader is guided through the steps in calculating the AME and ENU. The various scenarios of the composition, size, and attendance at meals of the consumer unit show that the calculated food energy adequacy can range from +2% to -29%. Care and attention must be given to correctly attributing the consumers of the food intake measured or estimated. In addition, use of these concepts allows for a valid comparison of food consumption units of various sizes and compositions.
    Food and nutrition bulletin 09/2012; 33(3 Suppl):S157-62. · 1.50 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The potential impact of wheat flour fortification with iron and folic acid was assessed using data about food purchases from the nationally representative 2000 Guatemalan Living Standards Measurement Survey. Of 7265 households, 35% were indigenous and 57% rural; 11% were extremely poor, 35% were poor, and 54% were nonpoor. The percentage of households that purchased wheat flour, sweet bread, French rolls, and sliced bread in the previous 15 d was 10, 88, 59, and 11%, respectively. The median amount of fortified wheat flour equivalents in purchased foods was 50 g/d per adult equivalent; fortified wheat flour equivalents were 7, 25, and 110 g/d for the poverty groups, 16 g/d in indigenous households and 24 g/d in rural households. Wheat flour fortification contributed 2.3 mg/d of iron and 90 microg/d of folic acid per adult equivalent. Assuming 5% bioavailability, wheat flour fortification provided 2% of the recommended dietary allowance (RDA) and 6% of estimated average requirement (EAR) iron levels for women of reproductive age; values were 1, 3, and 12% of EAR levels for the poverty groups, respectively. Wheat flour fortification met 26% of folic acid RDA and 33% of EAR levels for women; values were 5, 16, and 71% of EAR levels for the poverty groups, respectively. In conclusion, the impact of fortification is likely to be substantial for folate status in nonpoor and urban women but limited in the case of iron status among all social groups. The poorest, rural, indigenous populations who suffer the highest burden of nutritional deficiencies likely benefit least from wheat flour fortification.
    Journal of Nutrition 05/2007; 137(4):1017-22. · 4.23 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Twenty-eight percent of Ugandan preschool children suffer from vitamin A deficiency. With vitamin A supplementation covering only a third of children under 5 years of age, fortification is essential to reduce their vitamin A deficiency-related disease burden. At present, the only widely consumed food in Uganda that is fortified with vitamin A is vegetable oil. To compare the feasibility, coverage, costs, and cost-effectiveness of fortifying vegetable oil and sugar with vitamin A in order to assess, from a public health policy perspective, whether sugar should also be fortified. The 2005/6 Uganda Household Budget Survey was used to analyze households' apparent consumption levels of sugar and vegetable oil and to model the additional intake of vitamin A, assuming the sugar and oil fortification levels are those set by the Uganda Bureau of Standards. The annual incremental private sector cost of vitamin fortification is US $555,668 for oil and US $2,644,765 for sugar. Assuming that oil and sugar fortification are both effective in reducing vitamin A deficiency by 30% among those who consume these foods, the estimated cost per disability-adjusted life year (DALY) averted is US $82 for sugar and US $18 for oil. Vitamin Afortification of vegetable oil is 4.6 times more cost-effective than vitamin A fortification of sugar. If sugar were to be fortified, the 17% of Ugandans who purchase sugar but do not purchase oil would become new beneficiaries of vitamin A fortification. This would increase the coverage of vitamin A-fortified foods by 31% and reduce the percentage of Ugandans without any coverage to 25%. Those most at risk for vitamin A deficiency-members of rural, poor households-would benefit disproportionately from the introduction of sugar fortification. Although the lack of information on the vitamin A deficiency status of consumers of oil and sugar precludes making definitive conclusions, the increased coverage and cost per DALY averted due to sugar fortification suggests-based on World Health Organization guidelines-that the Government of Uganda should pursue sugar fortification.
    Food and nutrition bulletin 06/2010; 31(2):193-205. · 1.50 Impact Factor


1 Download