A holistic view of happiness: Belief in the negative side of happiness is more prevalent in Japan than in the united states

PSYCHOLOGIA (Impact Factor: 0.09). 01/2011; 53(4):236-245. DOI: 10.2117/psysoc.2010.236

ABSTRACT Two studies tested the hypothesis that while Americans believe that happiness is an enduring positive state to be pursued by each individual, Japanese believe that it is a positive, but transitory interpersonal moment fraught with negative consequences such as others' envy and a reduced ability to attend to one's surroundings. Study 1 used a standard questionnaire method to show that people in Japanese cultural contexts have a more holistic concept of happiness than do people in European-American cultural contexts. Study 2 showed that this Japanese holistic view of happiness is associated with a holistic worldview rather than personal subjective well-being. This suggests that the holistic view of happiness is related to a dialectic thinking style prevalent in Japanese culture and unrelated to individual levels of subjective well-being. One Japanese woman was in a favorable situation. She was recently married, had a new job, and was living in a new and beautiful city. One day, however, she was injured. As a result, she was unable to walk for a month and had a difficult time completing the daily tasks many people take for granted, such as shopping and commuting to work. Such "lay theories" of happiness are quite prevalent in Japanese culture because people in that cultural context frequently believe that having too many positive outcomes is a sign of "negative things to come." In addition, they worry about negative consequences of feeling happiness, including the jealousy of others or a loss of motivation. For example, many Japanese think that if they feel happy, they will no longer put forth their greatest effort, thus diminishing their capacity for self-improvement. Notably, however, this kind of lay theory, called the holistic view of happiness, would be less likely to be accepted by European-American cultures than Japanese culture.

Download full-text


Available from: Yukiko Uchida, Sep 26, 2015
1 Follower
132 Reads
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The authors constructed the Analysis-Holism Scale (AHS) to measure analytic versus holistic thinking tendency. In Study 1, using exploratory and confirmatory factor analysis, a 24-item scale was developed. In Study 2, convergent and discriminant validities were tested. In Studies 3 and 4, the known-group difference validity was examined by comparing scores on the AHS of Americans and Koreans (Study 3) and of Korean students of Oriental medicine and Korean students of non-Oriental medicine majors (Study 4). Results of Studies 3 and 4 show that Koreans and Korean students of Oriental medicine scored higher on the AHS than did Americans and Korean students of non-Oriental medicine majors, respectively. Studies 5 and 6 tested predictive validity by examining associations of the AHS with performances on two cognitive tasks (categorization and causal reasoning). Data analysis shows that those with high scores on the AHS displayed the holistic pattern of performances on each task more than did those with low scores.
    Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 06/2007; 33(5):691-705. DOI:10.1177/0146167206298568 · 2.52 Impact Factor
  • Source
    The Journal of head trauma rehabilitation 11/2013; 28(6):489-91. DOI:10.1097/HTR.0000000000000004 · 2.92 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: An integrative explanation proposes that culture and gender interact to produce fundamentally different patterns of association between positive and negative emotions. People in independent-based cultures (e.g. the United States) experience emotions in oppositional (i.e. bipolar) ways, whereas people in interdependent-based cultures (e.g. China) experience emotions in dialectic ways. These patterns are stronger for women than men in both cultures. In support of the theory, Study 1 showed that positive and negative emotions are strongly correlated inversely for American women and weakly correlated inversely for American men, but strongly correlated positively for Chinese women and weakly correlated positively for Chinese men. In Study 2, findings for Koreans, although mixed, were closer to the results for Chinese.
    Cognition and Emotion 10/1999; 13(6):641-672. DOI:10.1080/026999399379023 · 2.52 Impact Factor