The Relative Importance of Socioeconomic and Environmental Variables in Explaining Land Change in Bolivia, 2001–2010

Annals of the Association of American Geographers (Impact Factor: 2.09). 07/2012; 102(4):778-807. DOI: 10.1080/00045608.2012.678036

ABSTRACT This study assesses the relationship between trends in land change from 2001 to 2010 and socioeconomic and environmental variables in Bolivia at multiple spatial scales using a nonparametric, tree-based modeling approach. It also explores the theoretical dimensions surrounding the debate over the relative importance of socioeconomic and environmental variables in explaining land change. Results from the land change analysis show several hotspots of dynamic change. The majority of woody vegetation loss occurred in the eastern lowlands of Santa Cruz, Beni, and Pando and was attributable to the expansion of industrial agriculture. Gains in woody vegetation took place in the drylands of Santa Cruz and Beni savanna, and these changes were attributed to shifting patterns in precipitation and fire rather than human-induced change. Other hotspots of woody vegetation gain were attributed to abandonment of agriculture and herbaceous lands in the intermontane valleys of the southern Andes. Regression analyses showed that population and other demographic variables were poor predictors of land change. There is a clear relationship, however, between changes in woody and agriculture/herbaceous vegetation and environmental variables such as precipitation, temperature, and elevation. Municipalities with adequate precipitation and moderate temperature tended to show increases in agriculture and herbaceous vegetation and woody vegetation declines. Woody vegetation tended to increase in municipalities at higher elevations. This study also shows that explanations of only wealth or population as the main drivers of land change undervalue the role that natural features, like topography and precipitation, play in limiting or permitting certain land-use decisions.

Download full-text


Available from: Matthew Clark, Feb 13, 2014
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: China has witnessed rapid economic growth in recent decades, but it increasingly faces the challenges of water shortage and arable land depletion. This article develops a space–time panel filter model (STPFM) to measure the dragging effects of the arable land and available water resources on economic growth in China at both the national and regional levels. Unlike traditional panel models, the STPFM allows us to explicitly account for spatial cross-regional dependence in the data. This is particularly important for two interrelated reasons. First, the aggregated output and its resource factors as well as physical capital and human capital have been shown to be spatially correlated and cross-regionally dependent. Second, STPFM can potentially mitigate the bias of variable omissions by taking into account spatial dependence and diffusion. The results show that the aggregate drag of arable land and available water resources reduces annual economic growth rate by about 1.3 percentage points in China as a whole, and significant differences exist in both disaggregate and aggregate drags over the provinces and regions. Our experiment confirms that the STPFM is an effective technique to quantify joint spatial and temporal dragging effects of natural resources on economic growth.
    Annals of the Association of American Geographers 11/2013; 103(6). DOI:10.1080/00045608.2013.784108 · 2.09 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Forest cover change directly affects biodiversity, the global carbon budget, and ecosystem function. Within Latin American and the Caribbean region (LAC), many studies have documented extensive deforestation, but there are also many local studies reporting forest recovery. These contrasting dynamics have been largely attributed to demographic and socio-economic change. For example, local population change due to migration can stimulate forest recovery, while the increasing global demand for food can drive agriculture expansion. However, as no analysis has simultaneously evaluated deforestation and reforestation from the municipal to continental scale, we lack a comprehensive assessment of the spatial distribution of these processes. We overcame this limitation by producing wall-to-wall, annual maps of change in woody vegetation and other land-cover classes between 2001 and 2010 for each of the 16,050 municipalities in LAC, and we used nonparametric Random Forest regression analyses to determine which environmental or population variables best explained the variation in woody vegetation change. Woody vegetation change was dominated by deforestation (−541,835 km2), particularly in the moist forest, dry forest, and savannas/shrublands biomes in South America. Extensive areas also recovered woody vegetation (+362,430 km2), particularly in regions too dry or too steep for modern agriculture. Deforestation in moist forests tended to occur in lowland areas with low population density, but woody cover change was not related to municipality-scale population change. These results emphasize the importance of quantitating deforestation and reforestation at multiple spatial scales and linking these changes with global drivers such as the global demand for food. Resumen Los cambios en la cobertura de bosque tienen efectos directos sobre la biodiversidad, el ciclo global del carbono, y el funcionamiento de los ecosistemas. Muchos estudios en la región de América Latina y el Caribe han documentado extensa deforestación; sin embargo, existen estudios locales que reportan recuperación del bosque. Ambas dinámicas, deforestación y reforestación, han sido relacionadas con cambios demográficos y socioeconómicos. Por ejemplo, dinámicas poblacionales, como la migración rural urbana, pueden estimular la recuperación del bosque, mientras que el aumento en la demanda mundial de alimentos puede promover la expansión agrícola. Dado a que ningún estudio ha evaluado conjuntamente los procesos de deforestación y reforestación a escala municipal o regional, no existe un análisis sobre de la distribución espacial de estos procesos. Hemos superado esta limitación al producir, simultáneamente, mapas del cambio en las coberturas de vegetación leñosa y usos del suelo entre 2001 y 2010 para cada uno de los 16,050 municipios de América Latina. Se utilizó el análisis no paramétrico de regresión “Random Forest” para determinar cuáles de las variables demográficas o medioambientales explican la variación del cambio en vegetación leñosa. Los cambios más significativos en la cobertura de vegetación leñosa fueron causados por procesos de deforestación (−541,835 km2), particularmente en los biomas de bosque húmedo, bosque seco, y en las sabanas o matorrales de América del Sur. Igualmente, se registró un aumento en la cobertura de vegetación leñosa (362,430 km2), especialmente en zonas áridas o empinados poco favorables para la agricultura industrial. La deforestación en los bosques húmedos tiende a ocurrir en zonas de baja elevación y de poca densidad poblacional, sin embargo, los cambios en vegetación leñosa no estuvieron relacionados con cambios en población a nivel de municipio. Estos resultados enfatizan la importancia de cuantificar la deforestación y la reforestación a múltiples escalas espaciales y de vincular estos cambios con acontecimientos globales, como el incremento mundial en la demanda de alimentos.
    Biotropica 03/2013; 45(2). DOI:10.1111/j.1744-7429.2012.00908.x · 2.08 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Although over 40 years of satellite imagery has greatly helped in documenting the location and extent of human impact, especially deforestation, our ability to confidently detect current patterns of land change at broad spatial scales needs improvement. To address this challenge, we have developed a cost-effective mapping procedure based on 250-m MODIS imagery that produces annual land-use/land-cover (LULC) maps for Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC). This procedure uses annual spectral statistics, collection of references samples with a Web-based tool, and tree-based Random Forests classifiers stratified by biome map regions to produce wall-to-wall, annual LULC maps for 2001 to 2010 that cover all of LAC. Across 26 map regions, overall pixel-level accuracy averaged 80.2 ± 8.1% for eight basic LULC classes, and 84.6 ± 6.5% for a five-class scheme. Municipality-scale area change between 2001 and 2010 in the three dominant classes (woody vegetation, mixed woody/plantation, and agriculture/herbaceous vegetation) was then estimated using regression models fit to 10 years of data, thus minimizing the impact of inter-annual class variation on change statistics. Closed-canopy forest area and change between 2001 and 2009 were well correlated with high-resolution maps of the Brazilian Legal Amazon (PRODES project). Our LAC-wide analysis of significant change revealed the recent extent and magnitude of deforestation hotspots, such as in the Amazon moist forests and the dry forests of Argentina, Paraguay and Bolivia. Our data also revealed biome-specific clusters of municipalities with increasing woody vegetation due to forest recovery, reforestation, or woody encroachment. Taken as a whole, our MODIS-based mapping and trend modeling methodology can provide reliable land change data, not just for the tropics or for forest cover, but for all biomes and municipalities in LAC and including multiple LULC classes. Because this information can be produced quickly on an annual time scale, with internally-consistent data sources, it is a very useful tool for resource managers, policy makers, scientists and conservationists interested in tracking recent land change across broad-scale, political and environmental gradients.
    Remote Sensing of Environment 11/2012; 126:84–103. DOI:10.1016/j.rse.2012.08.013 · 4.77 Impact Factor