Influence of abutment material on stability of peri-implant tissues: A systematic review

Vilnius Implantology Center, Kalvariju str. 121-2, LT-08221, Vilnius, Lithuania.
The International journal of oral & maxillofacial implants (Impact Factor: 1.45). 05/2008; 23(3):449-56.
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT The aim of this systematic review was to evaluate available evidence for a difference in the stability of peri-implant tissues between titanium abutments versus gold alloy, zirconium oxide, or aluminum oxide abutments.
Studies were identified by examining several electronic databases and major dental implant, prosthetic, and periodontal journals. To be selected for the preliminary article pool, the article must have been written in the English language and published from 1980 to March 2007. Articles were sorted based on the nature of the study. In vitro studies and literature reviews were excluded. The included articles were clinical, human histology, and animal studies. Case reports, case series, uncontrolled clinical trials, and clinical studies with teeth treated as a control were excluded from the final review.
The initial article pool included 40 articles of which 9 met the inclusion criteria: 3 animal studies, 2 human histological studies, and 4 randomized clinical trials. Soft tissue recession was not accurately measured in the included clinical studies. Assessment of peri-implant tissues around zirconium oxide and titanium abutments was described only in animal and human histologic studies. Due to differences in study types, timing of follow-ups, and outcome variables, meta-analysis could not be performed.
Included studies revealed that titanium abutments did not maintain a higher bone level in comparison to gold alloy, aluminum oxide, or zirconium oxide abutments. However, there is a lack of information about the clinical performance of zirconium oxide and gold alloy abutments as compared to titanium abutments.

Download full-text


Available from: Tomas Linkevicius, Jan 12, 2014
29 Reads
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: A desirable feature of an implant surface which penetrates epithelium would be that the surface impedes epithelial downgrowth. Previous experiments have shown that the micromachined, horizontally oriented grooves on the percutaneous implant surface can impede epithelial downgrowth (Chehroudi et al., J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 22, 459 (1988) and 23, 1067 (1989)). However, little is known of the effect of varying groove parameters such as depth, spacing, and orientation on epithelial downgrowth and attachment of epithelial (E)-cells and fibroblasts (F) to percutaneous implants in vivo. Grooves were produced with a 30-micron pitch and depths of 22 microns, 10 microns, or 3 microns. In addition, 10-microns- and 3-microns-deep grooves were made with pitches of 39 microns and 7 microns, respectively. Implants with grooves oriented either horizontally or vertically to the long axis of the implant as well as smooth control surfaces were coated with 50 nm of titanium and placed in the parietal area of rats for a period of 7 days. Close attachment of E-cells was found on the smooth, 10-microns- and 3-microns-deep, horizontally or vertically aligned grooved surfaces; in contrast, E-cells bridged over the 22-microns-deep, horizontally oriented grooves. F formed a capsule on the smooth surface as well as the 10-microns- and 3-microns-deep horizontally oriented grooves, but F inserted obliquely into the 22-microns-deep, horizontally aligned grooved surface. Histomorphometric measurements indicated that the epithelial downgrowth was greatest on the vertically oriented grooved and smooth surfaces and was shortest on the 22-microns-deep and 10-microns-deep horizontally aligned grooved surfaces. These differences indicate that epithelial downgrowth was accelerated on the vertically oriented grooved surfaces and inhibited on the horizontally oriented grooved surfaces. Moreover, the mechanism of inhibition of the epithelial downgrowth may differ among these surfaces. E-cells bridged over the 22-microns-deep grooves and their migration appeared to be inhibited by the F that inserted into the implant surface. In the shallower horizontal grooves, however, epithelial downgrowth was probably inhibited by contact guidance because there was no evidence of F inserting obliquely into the implant surface.
    Journal of Biomedical Materials Research 09/1990; 24(9):1203-19. DOI:10.1002/jbm.820240906
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical performance of customized ceramic single-implant abutments in combination with two different techniques for fabricating crowns. Twenty consecutive patients were provided with 24 single-implant restorations with customized ceramic abutments. The restorations were either cemented to the abutment (n = 13) or fabricated with the veneering material fused directly onto the ceramic abutment (n = 11). The patients were evaluated at 6 and 12 months with radiographs and clinical parameters for complications and soft tissue response. All implants and restorations were still in function after 1 year. Few clinical problems were reported during the follow-up period. The interproximal soft tissue recovered to near normal size. The mean marginal bone loss was similar for both groups, reaching an average of 0.3 mm (SD 0.71) after 1 year in function. The short-term results indicate that customized ceramic abutments are successful and have comparable function, regardless of fabrication method.
    The International journal of prosthodontics 11/2003; 16(6):626-30. · 1.46 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: 16 consecutive totally edentulous patients were provided with 95 osseointegrated titanium fixtures in 7 upper and 9 lower jaws. Facultatively removable bridges were later connected to abutments, attached to the fixtures. The marginal soft and hard tissue reactions were investigated at a baseline examination and after 6, 12, 21, 30 and 39 months by standardized clinical and radiographical methods. At the last examination, microbiological samples and gingival biopsies were also analysed. The % ratios of abutments without plaque, 70-75%, and without any gingivitis, 80-85%, were almost constant throughout the study. The mean probing depth was 2.9 mm at the final examination. About 75% of all probing depths were 3 mm or less and none exceeded 5 mm. The bridge-gingiva distances increased during the investigation. Attached gingiva surrounded 65% of the buccal and lingual abutment surfaces. Only 0.9 mm marginal bone was lost as a mean during the first year and not more than 0.05 mm annually for the next 2 years. After 6 months, no significant changes in marginal bone levels occurred. The perifixtural bone gradually became more radiopaque, especially marginally in upper jaws, indicating a successive load-related remodelling. The microbiotia comprised coccoid cells and non-motile rods to 93% in 32 samples. Healthy tissues were present in 35% of the 14 soft tissue biopsies. In a further 29%, only a slight inflammation was observed. No constant correlations could be established for any of the investigation parameters used. It is concluded that the marginal soft tissue reactions were mild and not significant for a progressive periodontitis. Mobility tests of separate fixtures combined with quantitative and qualitative standardized radiological examinations of the surrounding bone appear to provide a truer comprehension of longitudinal events at osseointegrated implants than conventional clinical soft tissue observations. The prognosis for the osseointegrated implants appears excellent, especially with regard to the microbiotia, the small marginal bone height changes, and the radiological indications of remodelling in the perifixtural bone.
    International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 03/1986; 15(1):39-52. DOI:10.1016/S0300-9785(86)80010-2 · 1.57 Impact Factor
Show more