Comparative assessment of the acute ankle injury by ultrasound and magnetic resonance

University of Zagreb, "Sestre Milosrdnice" University Hospital Center, Clinic of Traumatology, Radiology Department, Zagreb, Croatia.
Collegium antropologicum (Impact Factor: 0.61). 06/2012; 36(2):605-10.
Source: PubMed


We compared ultrasound (US) with magnetic resonance (MR) findings of muscle tendon and ligaments (mt&l) of 17 men and 13 women, 16-66 years old, who suffered from acute ankle injury without bone fracture visible on conventional radiographs. Joint effusion (JE), and injury of the Tibials anterior muscle tendon (TAmt), Calcaneofibular ligament (CFl), Long flexor of the great toe muscle tendon (LFGTmt), Short peroneus muscle tendon (SPmt), Long peroneus muscle tendon (LPmt), and Anterior talofibular ligament (ATFl) were assessed by the US, at seven days, and MR, at seventeenth day. Grading of ligament and muscle tendon injury as stretching (Grade 1), partially ruptured (Grade 2), and complete rupture (Grade 3); no lesion was considered to be Grade 0. Joint effusion and ATFl were the most common lesions whereas the TAmt lesion was the least frequent: JE approximately ATFl > SPmt approximately LPmt > LFGTmt approximately CFl approximately TAmt. Both US and MR were equally sensitive in detecting the presence (or absence) of the mt&l ankle injury, whereas US was less specific than MR in detecting G3 injury.

Download full-text


Available from: Petra Margetic, Feb 11, 2014
  • Source
    • "The results were considered to be negative (À) if there was no or a mild difference from the opposite side; however, the results were considered to be positive (+) if there was a pathologic instability consistent with an LLLA. A final validating direct sonography was conducted by an orthopaedic surgeon within 7 days of an injury using the methods described by Oae et al. [20] and Margetic et al. [17]. The operator performing this sonography was blinded for the results achieved with the three measurements (device of Hoffmann, arthrometer and clinical investigation) before. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background: Ankle sprain injuries, often due to lateral ligamentous injury, are the most common sports traumatology conditions. Correct diagnoses require an understanding of the assessment tools with a high degree of diagnostic accuracy. Obviously, there are still no clear consensuses or standard methods to differentiate between a ligament tear and an ankle sprain. In addition to clinical assessments, stress sonography, arthrometer and other methods are often performed simultaneously. These methods are often costly, however, and their accuracy is controversial. The aim of this study was to investigate three different measurement tools that can be used after a lateral ligament lesion of the ankle with injury of the anterior talofibular ligament to determine their diagnostic accuracy. Methods: Thirty patients were recruited for this study. The mean patient age was 35±14 years. There were 15 patients with a ligamentous rupture and 15 patients with an ankle sprain. We quantified two devices and one clinical assessment by which we calculated the sensitivity and specifity: Stress sonography according to Hoffmann, an arthrometer to investigate the 100N talar drawer and maximum manual testing and the clinical assessment of the anterior drawer test. A high resolution sonography was used as the gold standard. Results: The ultrasound-assisted gadgetry according to Hoffmann, with a 3mm cut-off value, displayed a sensitivity of 0.27 and a specificity of 0.87. Using a 3.95mm cut-off value, the arthrometer displayed a sensitivity of 0.8 and a specificity of 0.4. The clinical investigation sensitivities and specificities were 0.93 and 0.67, respectively. Conclusions: Different assessment methods for ankle rupture diagnoses are suggested in the literature; however, these methods lack reliable data to set investigation standards. Clinical examination under adequate analgesia seems to remains the most reliable tool to investigate ligamentous ankle lesions. Further clinical studies with higher case numbers are necessary, however, to evaluate these findings and to measure the reliability.
    Foot and Ankle Surgery 09/2014; 21(1). DOI:10.1016/j.fas.2014.09.006
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Sports injuries are still the most common reason for instability of the ankle. 20-40% of the acute ankle instabilities might pass on to chronic instabilities. The treatment of choice for acute instabilities is a conservative therapy (Level of Evidence (LoE) II) if there are no accompanying injuries and operative treatment is only needed in selected case (LoE II). A symptomatic chronic instability of the ankle presents a pre-osteoarthritis and long-term outcome appeared to be poor without appropriate treatment (LoE IV).
    Sport-Orthopädie - Sport-Traumatologie - Sports Orthopaedics and Traumatology 28(4):258–265. DOI:10.1016/j.orthtr.2012.10.007
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background Tendon repair involves a slow repair process, which results in inferior repair of tissue and failure to obtain full active range of motion. Microcurrent therapy (MCT) is a new therapy after arthroplasty. Stem cells with capacity of self-renewal are ideal for tissue engineering. Aim The present work aimed at investigating the effect of MCT and the possible role of endogenous stem cells in repair of induced tendon injury in albino rat. Materials and methods Twenty-four male albino rats were classified into: Control group, tenotomy group, 5 rats were sacrificed 2 weeks and 5 rats sacrificed 4 weeks following achillis tendon injury (Subgroups IIa and IIb respectively). MCT group of 10 rats subjected to tendon injury followed by MCT, 5 rats sacrificed 2 weeks and 5 rats sacrificed 4 weeks following MCT (Subgroups IIIa and IIIb respectively). Tendon sections were stained with H&E and CD44 and CD105 immunostains. A morphometric study was performed. Results Subgroup IIa demonstrated multiple areas of widely separated collagen fibers, infiltrating cells and multiple congested vessels. Subgroup IIb showed multiple areas of disorganized collagen bundles, less infiltrating cells and few congested vessels. MCT subgroup IIIa revealed some areas of parallel collagen bundles, some infiltrating cells and some dilated congested vessels. MCT subgroup IIIb showed multiple areas of parallel collagen bundles, few infiltrating cells and occasional congested vessels. CD44 +ve and CD105 +ve cells were seen among disorganized, parallel collagen fibers and inside blood vessels. A significant increase in the area of regenerated collagen bundles was recorded in MCT subgroup IIIb. The area% of CD44 +ve and CD105 +ve MSCs denoted a significant increase in MCT subgroup IIIa. Conclusion MCT activated endogenous bone marrow derived MSCs migration to the injured achillis tendon, which stimulated tendon repair following induced tenotomy.
    Egyptian Journal of Histology 06/2013; 36(2):400-408. DOI:10.1097/01.EHX.0000428367.71841.b8
Show more