Exploring patterns and mechanisms of interspecific and intraspecific variation in body elemental composition of desert consumers

Center for Advanced Studies in Ecology and Biodiversity and Depto de Ecología, Pontificia Univ. Católica de Chile, Santiago. Chile
Oikos (Impact Factor: 3.44). 02/2011; 120(8):1247 - 1255. DOI: 10.1111/j.1600-0706.2010.19151.x


Key processes such as trophic interactions and nutrient cycling are often influenced by the element content of organisms. Previous analyses have led to some preliminary understanding of the relative importance of evolutionary and ecological factors determining animal stoichiometry. However, to date, the patterns and underlying mechanisms of consumer stoichiometry at interspecific and intraspecific levels within natural ecosystems remain poorly investigated. Here, we examine the association between phylogeny, trophic level, body size, and ontogeny and the elemental composition of 22 arthropod as well as two lizard species from the coastal zone of the Atacama Desert in Chile. We found that, in general, whole-body P content was more variable than body N content both among and within species. Body P content showed a significant phylogenetic signal; however, phylogeny explained only 4% of the variation in body P content across arthropod species. We also found a significant association between trophic level and the element content of arthropods, with carnivores having 15% greater N and 70% greater P contents than herbivores. Elemental scaling relationships across species were only significant for body P content, and even the P content scaling relationship was not significant after controlling for phylogeny. P content did decrease significantly with body size within most arthropod species, which may reflect the size dependence of RNA content in invertebrates. In contrast, larger lizards had higher P contents and lower N:P ratios than smaller lizards, which may be explained by size-associated differences in bone and scale investments. Our results suggests that structural differences in material allocation, trophic level and phylogeny can all contribute to variation in the stoichiometry of desert consumers, and they indicate that the elemental composition of animals can be useful information for identifying broad-scale linkages between nutrient cycling and trophic interactions in terrestrial food webs.


Available from: Angélica L. González
  • Source
    • "This regulation is thought to dampen intraspecific OS variability in animals (Karimi and Folt 2006). However, recent studies have shown that OS can still vary dramatically within species due to intraspecific variability in trait distributions (Pilati and Vanni 2007; Gonzalez et al. 2011), or to variability in abiotic factors such as temperature, nutrients, and light (Dickman et al. 2008; Hamback et al. 2009; Small and Pringle 2010). Environmental factors influence animal OS either by acting directly on organismal traits (Hamback et al. 2009), or by altering the availability of elements for consumers by altering elemental content of their resources (Schade et al. 2003; Small and Pringle 2010). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Interspecific differences in organismal stoichiometry (OS) have been documented in a wide range of animal taxa and are of significant interest for understanding evolutionary patterns in OS. In contrast, intraspecific variation in animal OS has generally been treated as analytical noise or random variation, even though available data suggest intraspecific variability in OS is widespread. Here, we assess how intraspecific variation in OS affects inferences about interspecific OS differences using two co-occurring Neotropical fishes: Poecilia reticulata and Rivulus hartii. A wide range of OS has been observed within both species and has been attributed to environmental differences among stream systems. We assess the contributions of species identity, stream system, and the interactions between stream and species to variability in N:P, C:P, and C:N. Because predation pressure can impact the foraging ecology and life-history traits of fishes, we compare predictors of OS between communities that include predators, and communities where predators are absent. We find that species identity is the strongest predictor of N:P, while stream or the interaction of stream and species contribute more to the overall variation in C:P and C:N. Interspecific differences in N:P, C:P, and C:N are therefore not consistent among streams. The relative contribution of stream or species to OS qualitatively changes between the two predation communities, but these differences do not have appreciable effects in interspecific patterns. We conclude that although species identity is a significant predictor of OS, intraspecific OS is sometimes sufficient to overwhelm or obfuscate interspecific differences in OS.
    Ecology and Evolution 05/2014; 4(9). DOI:10.1002/ece3.981 · 2.32 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "The Growth Rate Hypothesis predicts that organisms with the highest P concentrations in their bodies would grow faster in P-rich environments and would be sensitive to P limitation (Sterner & Elser, 2002). Predators have been reported to generally be the most N-rich trophic group (Gonzáles et al., 2011), and N limitation may drive them to search for N-rich food, frequently even resulting in intraguild predation (Denno & Fagan, 2003). Theory predicts that primary producers have a wide range of variation in elemental composition, whereas consumers keep their elemental composition relatively constant and have relatively strict stoichiometric homoeostasis (Sterner & Elser, 2002). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: 1. Ponto-Caspian peracaridans, and mysids and amphipods in particular, are among the most successful aquatic invaders. However, species differ in the trophic-status range of ecosystems they can invade while establishment rates and impacts can vary substantially between habitats. There is limited knowledge of the environmental factors and species characteristics that drive such variation in invasion success. 2. Here we test how trophic level and body stoichiometry vary among peracaridan species and in relation to body size. The amphipod Pontogammarus robustoides and the mysids Limnomysis benedeni and Paramysis lacustris were investigated in ecosystems differing considerably in productivity and nutrient supply, namely an N-limited eutrophic lagoon and P-limited mesotrophic lakes. 3. As revealed by stable isotope (15N/14N) analysis, herbivory was inferred to be the main feeding mode of L. benedeni. In contrast, the mysid P. lacustris and the amphipod P. robustoides displayed a higher propensity for predatory feeding at larger body sizes, a pattern that was more pronounced in the eutrophic lagoon than in the mesotrophic lakes. 4. Their mean stoichiometric composition (P. robustoides C:N:P 108:20:1, L. benedeni 92:21:1 and P. lacustris 93:22:1) demonstrates that these peracaridans are rich in nutrients, especially nitrogen. They all exhibited the same ontogenetic pattern of reduced stoichiometric regulation during juvenile stages and stricter homoeostasis at older stages. 5. The higher P content in juveniles of all peracaridan species from the lagoon indicates higher potential somatic and population growth rates than those in the mesotrophic lakes. Such a difference may explain the substantially faster rates of invader establishment observed in the lagoon in comparison with lakes of low trophy. 6. Due to differences in ontogenetic and habitat-induced variation, the study species differed significantly in stoichiometric variability, which was lowest in L. benedeni and highest in P. robustoides. The ranges of species-specific variation in stoichiometric ratios corresponded to the trophic (by chlorophyll a) and nutrient stoichiometry (N:P) ranges of lentic waters successfully invaded by these species in Lithuania. 7. Stoichiometric plasticity, which should be associated with flexibility of feeding strategy, may enhance the potential of peracaridan species to successfully invade habitats with differing trophy and nutrient supply. The optimal feeding strategy should be omnivory with a propensity for predatory feeding, which can be adjusted with respect to ontogenetic nutrient demands and resource availability. Invading species may have a stronger effect on the local biota in ecosystems with high P levels, which promote growth, and N limitation that should favour predation.
    Freshwater Biology 05/2013; 58(5):1052-1068. DOI:10.1111/fwb.12108 · 2.74 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "data downloadable from Weiser et al. (2011); polar nematofauna from the Taylor Valley, Antarctica, as in Courtright et al. (2001: their Table III) and Barrett et al. (2006: their Table IV); temperate nematofauna downloadable from Mulder and Elser (2009) and Mulder and Vonk (2011). Macroarthropods from the coastal zone of the Atacama Desert, Chile, were described in González et al. (2011) "

Show more