Sulphate and ammonium in mist impair the frost hardening of red spruce seedlings

Institute of Terrestrial Ecology, Bush Estate, Penicuik EH 26 OQB, Midlothian, UK
New Phytologist (Impact Factor: 6.37). 04/2006; 118(1):119 - 126. DOI: 10.1111/j.1469-8137.1991.tb00572.x

ABSTRACT summaryTwo-year-old seedlings of red spruce [Picea rubens Sarg. syn. P. rubra (Du Roi) Link] were grown in open-top chambers supplied with charcoal-filtered air near Edinburgh, Scotland. Between May and November 1988, plants were exposed to mists containing NH4+, SO42− and NO3− ions at concentrations of 1.6 mol m−3 and H+ at 3.2 mol m−3, in pairwise combination and all together. The mists were applied twice weekly at a rate of 2 mm precipitation equivalent per application. Treatment with H2SO4 severely damaged the plants after 3 wk; the concentration for this treatment was therefore reduced from 1.6 mol m−3 to 0.5 mol m3, and new plants were substituted, in June 1988. Frost hardiness was assessed by freeze-testing detached shoots, then measuring rates of electrolyte leakage. No effects of the mist treatments were detected during the early stages of frost hardening, but on 31 October, shoots that had received sulphate and ammonium ions were less hardy than ‘control’ shoots treated with deionized water. The temperature which killed 20% of shoots was 14 °C higher, and the temperature which killed 56% of shoots was 7 °C higher than for ‘control’ shoots. Acidity per se had no effect on frost hardiness; nitrate ions had no effect and may have mitigated the effects of sulphate when applied together.The results confirm earlier data, and indicate that uptake of NH4+ and SO42− ions can disturb the frost-hardening process. There are important implications for pollution control strategies in the northeastern United States, if damaging interactions between frost hardiness of red spruce and pollutant deposition are linked to ammonium and sulphate rather than nitrate ions.

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Two-year-old red spruce (Picea rubens Sarg.) of Pittston provenance and 3-yr-old plants of Chatham provenance were exposed to acid mist in replicated open-top chambers supplied with charcoal-filtered air near Edinburgh, Scotland. Plants of Chatham provenance had already been exposed to acid mist throughout the previous growing season. The plants were exposed to mist, equivalent to 4 mm rainfall per week, containing an equimolar mixture of sulphuric acid and ammonium nitrate at pH 2.5 or pH 5.0 (1.6 or 0.01 mol m3) from May to November. This weekly dose was delivered at a low frequency (2 mm twice a week), or high frequency (1 mm on 4 consecutive days each week) to chambers fitted with ceilings to exclude rain. The low frequency dose was also applied to chambers without ceilings, to examine the effect of natural washing by rain. Frost hardiness, estimated by exposing detached shoots to controlled freezing and then measuring rates of electrolyte leakage, was determined during the misting period at the end of October and in December. Foliar nutrient concentrations were measured during the dormant period after treatment had ceased.At the end of October, plants which had received acid mist were less frost hardy than plants receiving mist at pH 5. The temperature causing 50% shoot death (LT50) increased by 6 °C for low frequency application, and by 10 °C at high frequency, relative to the plants receiving mist at pH 5. Exclusion of ambient rainfall had no detectable effect on the frost hardiness response to acid mist. In December, 3 wk after the cessation of misting, all plants were more frost hardy than in October. Significant effects of the acid mist treatment could no longer be detected. Differences in nutrient concentrations were small among treatments, although K+ concentrations in the low frequency treatment with acid mist with rain exclusion were 50 % below those in other treatments. Ca concentrations were 50% larger in the acid mist treatment with rain exclusion than without. The data suggested enhanced sulphate uptake resulting from increasing the frequency of exposure, but the increase was not significant.There was no clear relationship between the pattern of frost hardiness and nutrient concentrations except for S, which was 30% smaller in the control plants (pH 5) than in the high frequency pH 2.5 treatments.It is concluded that excluding rainfall, an experimental artifact introduced in evaluating effects of acid mist, does not influence the frost hardiness response of red spruce seedlings. The much greater effect of exposure to the same dose at double the frequency suggests that such experiments may underestimate effects in the field, if those trees are exposed to more frequent episodes of polluted cloud water than experimental plants.
    New Phytologist 08/1993; 124(4). · 6.37 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Approx. 50 papers (found from Scopus) published since 1990 were reviewed to determine whether or not nitrogen additions benefit frost hardiness in some plant species. The results varied according to species, timing of the effect, nitrogen source and plant tissue concentration. The key finding is that in 40% of reported cases nitrogen supply increased frost hardiness, while in 29% of cases nitrogen had no effect on frost hardiness. Together these findings comprise 69%, implying that in the majority of cases nitrogen additions are not deleterious but actually improve frost hardiness, especially in autumn.
    Environmental and Experimental Botany 10/2014; · 3.00 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Heather (Callunavulgaris) was grown in pots in a natural heathland soil and exposed in outdoor fumigation chambers (‘solardomes’) to 40 nl l−1 of both nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and sulphur dioxide (SO2) simultaneously. Plants exposed to NO2 and SO2 for 8 months over a growing season (February–November) showed increases in the growth of shoots (+37%) and the whole plant (+15%) and a raised ratio of root to shoot dry matter in comparison with control (charcoal-filtered air) plants. Fumigation raised the average foliar concentrations of nitrogen (+34%) and sulphur (+173%). The improvements in growth due to pollutant exposure were countered by reductions in tolerance to experimental acute frost. Cellular damage of heather shoots was assessed using measurements of electrolyte leakage from cut shoots following controlled over-night frosts. The rates of leakage were consistently increased in those plants that had been exposed to NO2 and SO2 for 5 months or more in comparison with non-fumigated controls. In some cases a greater leakage rate was recorded in fumigated plants than in controls even in the absence of freezing temperatures. The pollutants caused a similar reduction in frost tolerance whether exposure was given during the hardening period (August–January) or the de-hardening stage (November–April). These results support the hypothesis that low concentrations of air pollutants can reduce the tolerance of plants to freezing stress.
    Environmental and Experimental Botany 04/2000; 43(2):111–119. · 3.00 Impact Factor

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
Oct 14, 2014