Preliminary study of ballistic impact on an industrial tank: Projectile velocity decay

Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries (Impact Factor: 1.15). 01/2008; 21(6):627-634. DOI: 10.1016/j.jlp.2008.06.006

ABSTRACT Since the events of September 11, 2001, the possibility of an intentional act targeting the chemical process industry has become realistic. It is, therefore, a great concern to be able to predict the immediate consequences of such an act. This study is intended to improve our knowledge about the sequence of events that occurs when a high-speed bullet (>1000 m s−1) penetrates a vessel filled with toxic liquid. We find that, prior to liquid ejection, several well-defined phases occur, including the phenomenon known as the “hydraulic ram.” This paper focuses on projectile–target interactions and explains how the decay of projectile velocity is related to the initial conditions of the target.

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We present the plan for an extended expert-system “front end” or design advisor for implementing systems (DAIS) for use in conjunction with a commercial digital control system environment, e.g., the Elsag Bailey INFI 90 System. The objective of DAIS is to make it substantially easier for applications engineers to make effective use of the broad spectrum of capabilities of this and similar hardware and software systems for industrial controls implementation. This concept is of quite general applicability for industrial controls environments. The extensions are primarily focused on handling multi-input/multi-output (MIMO) systems. This should greatly enhance the value of DAIS in modern process control applications
    Proceedings of the American Control Conference, San Diego, CA; 06/1999
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: High speed underwater systems involve many modelling and simulation difficulties related to shocks, expansion waves and evaporation fronts. Modern propulsion systems like underwater missiles also involve extra difficulties related to non-condensable high speed gas flows. Such flows involve many continuous and discontinuous waves or fronts and the difficulty is to model and compute correctly jump conditions across them, particularly in unsteady regime and in multi-dimensions. To this end a new theory has been built that considers the various transformation fronts as ‘diffuse interfaces’. Inside these diffuse interfaces relaxation effects are solved in order to reproduce the correct jump conditions. For example, an interface separating a compressible non-condensable gas and compressible water is solved as a multiphase mixture where stiff mechanical relaxation effects are solved in order to match the jump conditions of equal pressure and equal normal velocities. When an interface separates a metastable liquid and its vapor, the situation becomes more complex as jump conditions involve pressure, velocity, temperature and entropy jumps. However, the same type of multiphase mixture can be considered in the diffuse interface and stiff velocity, pressure, temperature and Gibbs free energy relaxation are used to reproduce the dynamics of such fronts and corresponding jump conditions. A general model, based on multiphase flow theory is thus built. It involves mixture energy and mixture momentum equations together with mass and volume fraction equations for each phase or constituent. For example, in high velocity flows around underwater missiles, three phases (or constituents) have to be considered: liquid, vapor and propulsion gas products. It results in a flow model with 8 partial differential equations. The model is strictly hyperbolic and involves waves speeds that vary under the degree of metastability. When none of the phase is metastable, the non-monotonic sound speed is recovered. When phase transition occurs, the sound speed decreases and phase transition fronts become expansion waves of the equilibrium system. The model is built on the basis of asymptotic analysis of a hyperbolic total non-equilibrium multiphase flow model, in the limit of stiff mechanical relaxation. Closure relations regarding heat and mass transfer are built under the examination of entropy production. The mixture equation of state (EOS) is based on energy conservation and mechanical equilibrium of the mixture. Pure phases EOS are used in the mixture EOS instead of cubic one in order to prevent loss of hyperbolicity in the spinodal zone of the phase diagram. The corresponding model is able to deal with metastable states without using Van der Waals representation.The model’s predictions are validated in multi-dimensions against experiments of high velocity projectile impact onto a liquid tank. Simulations are compared to experiments and reveal excellent quantitative agreement regarding shock and cavitation pocket dynamics as well as projectile deceleration versus time. Then model’s capabilities are illustrated for flow computations around underwater missiles.
    International Journal of Multiphase Flow. 01/2009;
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We have studied the sequence of events that occurs when a high-speed projectile (from 960 ms(-1) to 1480 ms(-1)) penetrates a vessel filled with toxic liquid. We find that prior to liquid ejection several well-defined phases occur, including the phenomenon known as the "hydraulic ram." Then a catastrophic tank failure leads to liquid ejection and fragmentation. This paper focuses on this phenomenon and explains how it can be related to the initial conditions of the target.
    Journal of hazardous materials 08/2009; 172(2-3):587-94. · 4.14 Impact Factor