The Freshman 15: A Critical Time for Obesity Intervention or Media Myth?

Social Science Quarterly (Impact Factor: 0.99). 01/1997; 92(5). DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-6237.2011.00823.x


We test whether the phrase “Freshman 15” accurately describes weight change among first-year college students. We also analyze freshmen's weight change during and after college.
This is the first investigation of the “Freshman 15” to use a nationally representative random sample, the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth (NLSY97). The data are analyzed using descriptive statistics, regression analysis, simulations, and longitudinal analysis.
Freshmen gain between 2.5 to 3.5 pounds, on average, over the course of their first year of college. Compared to same-age noncollege attendees, the typical freshman gains only an additional half-pound. Instead of a spike in weight during the freshman year, college-educated individuals exhibit moderate but steady weight gain during and after college.
Anti-obesity efforts directed specifically at college freshmen will likely have little impact on obesity prevalence among young adults.

Download full-text


Available from: Jay L. Zagorsky, Dec 03, 2014
444 Reads
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Abstract Purpose . To identify impact of an online nutrition and physical activity program for college students. Design . Randomized, controlled trial using online questionnaires and on-site physical and fitness assessments with measurement intervals of 0 (baseline), 3 (postintervention), and 15 months (follow-up). Setting . Online intervention delivered to college students; a centralized Web site was used for recruitment, data collection, data management, and intervention delivery. Subjects . College students (18-24 years old, n = 1689), from eight universities (Michigan State University, South Dakota State University, Syracuse University, The Pennsylvania State University, Tuskegee University, University of Rhode Island, University of Maine, and University of Wisconsin). Intervention . A 10-lesson curriculum focusing on healthful eating and physical activity, stressing nondieting principles such as size acceptance and eating competence (software developer: Rainstorm, Inc, Orono, Maine). Measures . Measurements included anthropometrics, cardiorespiratory fitness, fruit/vegetable (FV) intake, eating competence, physical activity, and psychosocial stress. Analysis . Repeated measures analysis of variance for outcome variables. Results . Most subjects were white, undergraduate females (63%), with 25% either overweight or obese. Treatment group completion rate for the curriculum was 84%. Over 15 months, the treatment group had significantly higher FV intake (+.5 cups/d) and physical activity participation (+270 metabolic equivalent minutes per week) than controls. For both groups, anthropometric values and stress increased, and fitness levels decreased. Gender differences were present for most variables. First-year males and females gained more weight than participants in other school years. Conclusion . A 10-week online nutrition and physical activity intervention to encourage competence in making healthful food and eating decisions had a positive, lasting effect on FV intake and maintained baseline levels of physical activity in a population that otherwise experiences significant declines in these healthful behaviors.
    American journal of health promotion: AJHP 11/2012; 27(2):e47-58. DOI:10.4278/ajhp.110606-QUAN-239 · 2.37 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: E ating disorder (ED) symptoms are prevalent among college students. Recent surveys estimate that 13.5% of women and 3.6% of men screen positive for EDs and 20% of college students report a history of an ED. 1,2 Disordered eating behaviors and unhealthy weight regulation methods appear to have increased in this population over the last decade and affect an even greater number of students. 3 Subclinical symptoms are associated with significant distress and impairment, and persist over time. 1 Of great concern are the large numbers of students with EDs who do not seek treatment, an estimated 80 to 90% of individuals who screen positive for an ED. 1, 4 College presents a unique opportunity to prevent, identify, and treat EDs given the multiple channels through which students can be reached, including health services, residential education, academic affairs, social networks, and extracurricular activities. This paper provides a summary of the current status of EDs on college campuses, including identification, prevention, and evidence-based treatment. We also highlight key challenges and important areas for further outreach and research. How do EDs in College Students Present? ED Screening Transitions are times when problem behaviors may become exacerbated. The transition to college is a major life event that occurs in the context of significant neurological change. For many students, college also marks a change in their eating environment, comparison of eating habits with peers, and possible concern about the "Freshmen 15" weight gain myth. 5 It is unsurprising then, that the peak age of onset for BN, BED and EDNOS is 16-20 years, around the time that young people leave home and go to college. 6 EDs are often associated with other problems such as major depression, panic disorder, generalized anxiety, suicidal ideation, self-injury, binge drinking, cigarette smoking, and marijuana use, making early detection and intervention among this population of even greater public health importance. 1 Fortunately, there is a growing literature on ED screening instruments with good predictive validity that can identify ED risk factors, and preventive interventions to reduce ED risk and onset have been developed. Screening can be conducted on a mandatory basis for incoming students as part of entrance medical forms, "strongly encouraged" (i.e., recommended but not required) in the same way that many universities promote alcohol education programs for new students, or advertised as one of several resources available to students through health promotion and/or counseling center services. 7-9 We favor an online format for screens as this permits greater anonymity and confidentiality, easier access, and the provision of immediate feedback to the student with recommendations for appropriate resources. Wide-spread screening also promotes a greater reach among the student body and reduces the potential to overlook problematic behaviors among students.
    Harvard health policy review 01/2012; 13(2):28-38.
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper discusses the critical period of adolescence and its potential role in the development and persistence of obesity. The adolescent years are characteristic of changes in body composition (location and quantity of body fat), physical fitness and decreased insulin sensitivity during puberty. This period of growth and maturation is also marked with behavioural changes in diet, physical activity, sedentary behaviour and psychological health. Physical activity and sport participation decline during adolescence especially in teenage girls, while sedentary behaviour, risk for depression and body esteem issues increase during the teenage years. These physiological and behavioural changes during adolescence warrant the attention of health practitioners to prevent the onset and continuation of obesity throughout the lifespan.
    Pediatric Obesity 03/2012; 7(4):261-73. DOI:10.1111/j.2047-6310.2011.00046.x · 4.57 Impact Factor
Show more