On the origin of perennial water ice at the south pole of Mars: A precession-controlled mechanism

Laboratoire de Météorologie Dynamique, CNRS, UPMC, Paris, IPSL, France
Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres (Impact Factor: 3.44). 01/2007; 112:8-17. DOI: 10.1029/2007JE002902

ABSTRACT 1] The poles of Mars are known to have recorded recent (<10 7 years) climatic changes. While the south polar region appears to have preserved its million-year-old environment from major resurfacing events, except for the small portion containing the CO 2 residual cap, the discovery of residual water ice units in areas adjacent to the cap provides compelling evidence for recent glaciological activity. The mapping and characterization of these H 2 O-rich terrains by Observatoire pour la Minéralogie, l'Eau, les Glaces et l'Activité (OMEGA) on board Mars Express, which have supplemented earlier findings by Mars Odyssey and Mars Global Surveyor, have raised a number of questions related to their origin. We propose that these water ice deposits are the relics of Mars' orbit precession cycle and that they were laid down when perihelion was synchronized with northern summer, i.e., more than 10,000 years ago. We favor precession over other possible explanations because (1) as shown by our General Circulation Model (GCM) and previous studies, current climate is not conducive to the accumulation of water at the south pole due to an unfavorable volatile transport and insolation configuration, (2) the residual CO 2 ice cap, which is known to cold trap water molecules on its surface and which probably controls the current extent of the water ice units, is geologically younger, (3) our GCM shows that 21,500 years ago, when perihelion occurred during northern spring, water ice at the north pole was no longer stable and accumulated instead near the south pole with rates as high as 1 mm yr À1 . This could have led to the formation of a meters-thick circumpolar water ice mantle. As perihelion slowly shifted back to the current value, southern summer insolation intensified and the water ice layer became unstable. The layer recessed poleward until the residual CO 2 ice cover eventually formed on top of it and protected water ice from further sublimation. In this polar accumulation process, water ice clouds play a critical role since they regulate the exchange of water between hemispheres. The so-called ''Clancy effect,'' which sequesters water in the spring/summer hemisphere coinciding with aphelion due to cloud sedimentation, is demonstrated to be comparable in magnitude to the circulation bias forced by the north-to-south topographic dichotomy. However, we predict that the response of Mars' water cycle to the precession cycle should be asymmetric between hemispheres not only because of the topographic bias in circulation but also because of an asymmetry in the dust cycle. We predict that under a ''reversed perihelion'' climate, dust activity during northern summer is less pronounced than during southern summer in the opposite perihelion configuration (i.e., today's regime). When averaged over a precession cycle, this reduced potential for dust lifting will force a significantly colder summer in the north and, by virtue of the Clancy effect, will curtail the ability of the northern hemisphere to transfer volatiles to the south. This process may have helped create the observed morphological differences in the layered deposits between the poles and could help explain the large disparity in their resurfacing ages.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In this work the pathways and possibilities of H2O2 decomposiotion on Mars in microscopic liquid interfacial water was analyzed by kinetic calculations. Thermal and photochemical driven decomposition, just like processes catalyzed by various metal oxides are too slow relatively to the annual duration while such microscopic liquid layers exist on Mars today, to produce substantial decomposition.The most effective analyzed process is catalyzed by Fe ions, which could decompose H2O2 under Ph<4.5 with half life of 1–2 days. This process might be important during volcanically influenced periods when sulphur release produces acidic pH, and rotational axis tilt change driven climatic changes also influence the volatile circulation and spatial the occurrence just like the duration of thin liquid layer. Under current conditions, using the value of 200 K as the temperature in interfacial water (at the souther hemisphere), and applying Phoenix lander’s wet chemistry laboratory results, the pH is not favourable for Fe mobility and this kind of decomposition. Despite current conditions (especially pH) are unfavourable for H2O2 decomposition, microscopic scale interfacial liquid water still might support the process. By the reaction called heterogeneous catalysis, without acidic pH and mobile Fe, but with minerals surfaces containing Fe decomposition of H2O2 with half life of 20 days can happen. This duration is still longer but not several orders than the existence of springtime interfacial liquid water on Mars today. This estimation is relevant for activation energy controlled reaction rates. The other main parameter that may influence the reaction rate is the diffusion speed. Although the available tests and theoretical calculations do not provide firm values for the diffusion speed in such a “2 dimensional” environment, using relevant estimations this parameter in the interfacial liquid layer is smaller than in bulk water. But the 20 days duration mentioned above is still relevant, as the activation energy driven reaction rate is the main limiting factor in the decomposition and not the diffusion speed. The duration of dozen(s) days is still longer but not with orders of magnitude than the expected duration for the existence of springtime interfacial liquid water on Mars today. The results suggest such decomposition may happen today, however because of our limited knowledge on chemical processes in thin interfacial liquid layers, this possibility waits for confirmation – and also points to the importance of making laboratory tests to validate the possible process. While some tests were already realized for diffusion in an almost 2 domensional liquid, the same is not true for activation energy, where only the value from the “normal” measurements were applied yet. Even if H2O2 decomposition is too slow today, the analysis of such process is important, as under volcanic influence more effective decomposition might take place in thin intrerfacial liquids close to the climate of today if released sulphur produces pH<4.5. Large quantity and widespread occurrence of bulk liquid phase is not expected in the Amazonian period, but interfacial liquid water probably appeared regularly, and its locations, especially during volcanically active periods might make certain sites than others more interesting for astrobiology with the lower concentration of oxidizing H2O2.
    Planetary and Space Science 11/2014; DOI:10.1016/j.pss.2014.07.017 · 1.63 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Global Climate Models (GCMs) have been successfully employed to explain the origin of many glacial deposits on Mars. However, the Latitude Dependent Mantle (LDM), a dust-ice mantling deposit that is thought to represent a recent “Ice Age”, remains poorly explained by GCMs. We reexamine this question by considering the effect of radiatively active water-ice clouds (RACs) and cloud microphysics. We find that when obliquity is set to 35°, as often occurred in the past 2 million years, warming of the atmosphere and polar caps by clouds modifies the water cycle and leads to the formation of a several centimeter-thick ice mantle poleward of 30° in each hemisphere during winter. This mantle can be preserved over the summer if increased atmospheric dust content obscures the surface and provides dust nuclei to low-altitude clouds. We outline a scenario for its deposition and preservation that compares favorably with the characteristics of the LDM.
    07/2014; 41(14). DOI:10.1002/2014GL059861
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The spectral signature of water ice was observed on Martian south polar cap in 2004 by the Observatoire pour l'Mineralogie, l'Eau les Glaces et l'Activite (OMEGA) (Bibring et al., 2004). Three years later, the OMEGA instrument was used to discover water ice deposited during southern summer on the polar cap (Langevin et al., 2007). However, temporal and spatial variations of these water ice signatures have remained unexplored, and the origins of these water deposits remains an important scientific question. To investigate this question, we have used observations from the Compact Reconnaissance Imaging Spectrometer for Mars (CRISM) instrument on the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) spacecraft of the southern cap during austral summer over four Martian years to search for variations in the amount of water ice. We report below that for each year we have observed the cap, the magnitude of the H2O ice signature on the southern cap has risen steadily throughout summer, particularly on the west end of the cap. The spatial extent of deposition is in disagreement with the current best simulations of deposition of water ice on the south polar cap (Montmessin et al., 2007). This increase in water ice signatures is most likely caused by deposition of atmospheric H2O ice and a set of unusual conditions makes the quantification of this transport flux using CRISM close to ideal. We calculate a 'minimum apparent' amount of deposition corresponding to a thin H2O ice layer of 0.2mm (with 70 percent porosity). This amount of H2O ice deposition is 0.6-6 percent of the total Martian atmospheric water budget. We compare our 'minimal apparent' quantification with previous estimates. This deposition process may also have implications for the formation and stability of the southern CO2 ice cap, and therefore play a significant role in the climate budget of modern day Mars.
    Earth and Planetary Science Letters 07/2014; 406. DOI:10.1016/j.epsl.2014.08.039 · 4.72 Impact Factor

Full-text (3 Sources)

Available from
May 23, 2014