Uncertainty and multiple objective calibration in regional water balance modelling: case study in 320 Austrian catchments

Institute of Hydraulic Engineering and Water Resources Management, Vienna University of Technology, Wien, Vienna, Austria
Hydrological Processes (Impact Factor: 2.7). 02/2007; 21(4):435 - 446. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.6253

ABSTRACT We examine the value of additional information in multiple objective calibration in terms of model performance and parameter uncertainty. We calibrate and validate a semi-distributed conceptual catchment model for two 11-year periods in 320 Austrian catchments and test three approaches of parameter calibration: (a) traditional single objective calibration (SINGLE) on daily runoff; (b) multiple objective calibration (MULTI) using daily runoff and snow cover data; (c) multiple objective calibration (APRIORI) that incorporates an a priori expert guess about the parameter distribution as additional information to runoff and snow cover data. Results indicate that the MULTI approach performs slightly poorer than the SINGLE approach in terms of runoff simulations, but significantly better in terms of snow cover simulations. The APRIORI approach is essentially as good as the SINGLE approach in terms of runoff simulations but is slightly poorer than the MULTI approach in terms of snow cover simulations. An analysis of the parameter uncertainty indicates that the MULTI approach significantly decreases the uncertainty of the model parameters related to snow processes but does not decrease the uncertainty of other model parameters as compared to the SINGLE case. The APRIORI approach tends to decrease the uncertainty of all model parameters as compared to the SINGLE case. Copyright © 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.


Available from: Juraj Parajka, Jun 15, 2015
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Conceptual environmental system models, such as rainfall runoff models, generally rely on calibration for parameter identification. Increasing complexity of this type of models for better representation of hydrological process heterogeneity, typically makes parameter identification more difficult. Although various, potentially valuable, approaches for better parameter estimation have been developed, strategies to impose general conceptual understanding of how a catchment works into the process of parameter estimation has not been fully explored. In this study we assess the effects of imposing semi-quantitative, relational inequality constraints, based on expert-knowledge, for model developmentand parameter specification, efficiently exploiting the complexity of a semi-distributed model formulation. Making use of a topography driven rainfall-runoff modeling (FLEXTOPO) approach, a catchment was delineated into three functional units, i.e., wetland, hillslope and plateau. Ranging from simple to complex, three model setups, FLEXA, FLEXB and FLEXC were developed based on these functional units, where FLEXA is a lumped representation of the study catchment, and the semi-distributed formulations FLEXB and FLEXC progressively introduce more complexity. In spite of increased complexity, FLEXB and FLEXC allow modelers to compare parameters, as well as states and fluxes, of their different functional units to each other, allowing the formulation of onstraints that limit the feasible parameter space.We show that by allowing for more landscaperelated process heterogeneity in a model, e.g., FLEXC, the performance increases even without traditional calibration. The additional introduction of relational constraints further improved the performance of these models.
    Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 12/2014; 18:4839-4859. DOI:10.5194/hess-18-4839-2014 · 3.64 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In the present paper multi-temporal Lidar (Light detection and ranging) data and Landsat images are used to assess the spatial variability of snow at the end of the accumulation season (April-May) in a glacierized catchment (167 km(2)) in Tyrol, Austria. Snow cover characteristics in the Tyrolean Alps have been analysed using regular snow measurements and snow course data. Results are used for the conversion of basin-wide Lidar snow depth into snow water equivalent (SWE). When considering different possible error sources, uncertainties of the mean basin-wide SWE obtained from Lidar are between 12% and 16%. Available distributions of SWE and snow covered area (SCA) in the catchment are used for the calibration and validation of the fully distributed hydrological model SES. The study focuses especially on the simulation of snow accumulation and the corresponding variability of snow. Observed accumulation patterns are related to the topography (elevation, slope and curvature), and according parameter settings of the hydrological model are derived by means of Monte Carlo simulations. The majority of the model runs simulates SCA for various datasets with an accuracy of 85-95%. The paper demonstrates that using SWE data is superior to SCA for constraining model parameter ranges. Results at the watershed scale are in agreement with respect to the total water volume of the snow cover with deviations lower than 5% between SWE from Lidar or from the hydrological model.
    Journal of Hydrology 11/2014; 519:3492-3510. DOI:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2013.12.054 · 2.69 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We developed a spatially distributed conceptual melt and runoff model able to cope with debris covered glacier parts. Subdebris melt was calculated based on empirical equations derived from field observations. The model was applied at the Inylchek glaciers. While runoff from Southern Inylchek flows directly into Inylchek River, runoff from Northern Inylchek is blocked by Southern Inylchek and forms Lake Merzbacher. This lake is drained frequently by outburst floods. To calibrate the model, a multi-algorithm, genetically adaptive multi-objective method (AMALGAM) was used. Daily runoff observations from Inylchek River as well as glacier mass balance gradients from other glaciers in the Tian Shan were used as objective functions in three split samples. Runoff simulations yielded Nash–Sutcliffe coefficients mostly higher than 0.9, and the mass balance gradients were simulated in an acceptable range. The results of the different split samples vary considerably. Considering the used objective functions and additional data such as the equilibrium line altitude, we chose the most promising parameter set to calculate the filling of Lake Merzbacher. This analysis indicated answers to several questions concerning the hydrological system of the lake. Apart from calving at the ice dam formed by Southern Inylchek glacier, the lake seemed so be filled predominantly by meltwater from Northern Inylchek glacier. The lake has a permanent runoff, also during the filling process. After the outburst, the channels seemed to be closed quickly.
    Geografiska Annaler Series A Physical Geography 09/2014; 96(4). DOI:10.1111/geoa.12061 · 1.56 Impact Factor