Genes meet geology: fish phylogeographic pattern reflects ancient, rather than modern, drainage connection

Evolution (Impact Factor: 4.61). 10/2001; 55(9):1844-1851. DOI: 10.1111/j.0014-3820.2001.tb00833.x


Abstract We used DNA analysis of the freshwater Galaxias vulgaris complex (Pisces: Galaxiidae) to test a geological hypothesis of drainage evolution in South Island, New Zealand. Geological evidence suggests that the presently north-flowing Nevis River branch of the Clutha/Kawarau River system (Otago) once flowed south into the Nokomai branch of the Mataura system (Southland). The flow reversal is thought to have resulted from fault and fold activity associated with post-Miocene uplift. Mitochondrial DNA sequence data (control region and cytochrome b genes; 76 individuals; maximum divergence 7.1%) corroborate this geomorphological hypothesis: The Nevis River retains a freshwater fish species (Galaxias gollumoides; five sites; 10 haplotypes) that is otherwise restricted to Southland (nine sites; 15 haplotypes). There is no indication that the Nevis River lineage of G. gollumoides lives elsewhere in the Clutha/Kawarau system (> 30 sites). Likewise, two widespread Clutha lineages (G. ‘sp’ D; G. anomalus–G. pullus) are apparently absent from the Nevis (> 30 sites). In particular, G. ‘sp D’ lives throughout much of the Clutha (12 sites, 23 haplotypes), including a tributary of the Kawarau, but is absent from the Nevis itself. Conventional molecular clock calibrations (based on a minimum Nevis-Mataura haplotype divergence of 3.0%) indicate that the Nevis flow reversal may have occurred in the early-mid Pleistocene, which is roughly consistent with geological data. The broad phylogeographic structure evident in the Clutha system is consistent with the sedentary nature of nonmigratory galaxiids. Our study reinforces the value of combining biological and geological data for the formulation and testing of historical hypotheses.

Download full-text


Available from: Graham P Wallis,
12 Reads
  • Source
    • "y . In particular , explaining why lower Taieri ( pullus ; eldoni ) and upper Taieri lineages ( anomalus ; depressiceps ) have not infiltrated the ranges of one another since the Kye Burn capture event remains a challenge . Similarly , the reasons for the continued localised distributions of endemic Teviot ( this study ) and Nevis river lineages ( Waters et al . , 2001 ) are not immediately clear . One possibility , previously suggested by ( Burridge et al . , 2007 ) , is that abiotic factors such as ecologically inhospitable gorges in the Clutha and Taieri river systems have prevented substantial range expansion through main - channel connections . An alternative ecological explanation is that ' foun"
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Geological processes are hypothesised to strongly affect species distributions. In particular, a combination of geological and biological data has suggested that tectonic processes can drive vicariant isolation and speciation in freshwater-limited taxa. Here we synthesise geological and biological evidence to demonstrate a composite geological and biological history for New Zealand's 290-km long Taieri River. Specifically, we assess evidence from structural geology and petrology, combined with phylogenetic and biogeographic analysis of galaxiid fishes, to show that the modern Taieri River was formed via capture of the ancestral Kye Burn during the mid-late Quaternary. Molecular dating analyses support a late-Quaternary timeframe for the geologically-mediated divergence between formerly-connected sister taxa Galaxias depressiceps and G. ‘teviot’. Fish biogeography lends further support to the geological hypothesis, as there is a substantial biogeographic disjunction between the lower- (ancestral) and upper (captured) portions of the Taieri River. Geological and biological data are assessed independently yet yield consilient patterns and timeframes for the evolutionary events inferred. Broadly, this study highlights the interplay between physical and biological processes in a geologically dynamic setting.
    Quaternary Science Reviews 07/2015; 120:47-56. DOI:10.1016/j.quascirev.2015.04.023 · 4.57 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Other than the transfer sometime after 50,000 years ago of the Yamuna River from the Indus to the Ganges (Clift et al. 2012), the timing of specific capture events cannot be reconstructed from the terrestrial evidence alone and in many cases remains unclear or imprecise (Clift and Blusztajn 2005). Within river systems there are often strong relationships between the present distribution of aquatic species and historical drainage patterns (Waters et al. 2001). This is because for exclusively aquatic animals, such as freshwater fish or obligate river dolphins, both the terrestrial environment and the ocean represent formidable barriers to dispersal between drainages. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Despite their endangered status, the taxonomic relationship between the two geographically isolated South Asian river dolphin populations has never been comprehensively assessed and remains contentious. Here we present the first dedicated evaluation of the molecular phylogenetic relationship between the Indus (Platanista gangetica minor) and Ganges (Platanista gangetica gangetica) River dolphins using mitochondrial DNA from the control region and cytochrome b, extracted from museum specimens. The 458 bp partial control region sequences from 26 Indus River dolphin samples exhibited no variation. Only six haplotypes were identified in the 31 (18 Indus; 13 Ganges) complete (856 bp) control region sequences obtained, none were shared between subspecies, and there were five fixed differences between them. Similarly low genetic diversity was found in a 541 bp section of the cytochrome b gene (n = 29). The lack of shared haplotypes and fixed differences resulted in Φ ST for the partial control region sequences of 0.932 (p < 0.0001) and FST of 0.843 (p < 0.0001), indicating the long-term absence of gene flow and clear genetic differentiation between the two geographically isolated populations. An externally calibrated molecular clock estimated that Indus and Ganges dolphins diverged around 550,000 years ago (95 % posterior probability 0.13–1.05 million years ago), possibly when dolphins from the Ganges dispersed into the Indus during drainage capture.
    Journal of Mammalian Evolution 05/2014; 22(1). DOI:10.1007/s10914-014-9265-6 · 2.36 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Understanding how evolutionary histories of freshwater species are tied to the underlying biotic and geological evolution of a region is significant, because their dispersal depends upon direct hydrological connectivity within and across drainage divides and because the history of drainage interconnectivity reflects historical influences of landscape, sea level, and climate (Bermingham and Avise 1986; Bernatchez and Wilson 1998; Waters et al. 2001). Within an otherwise largely arid and geologically quiescent continent, Australia's narrow eastern margin still supports numerous permanent drainages and a diverse endemic freshwater fauna. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The influence of Pleistocene climatic cycles on Southern Hemisphere biotas is not yet well understood. Australia's eastern coastal margin provides an ideal setting for examining the relative influence of landscape development, sea level fluctuation, and cyclic climatic aridity on the evolution of freshwater biodiver-sity. We examined the impact of climatic oscillations and physical biogeograph-ic barriers on the evolutionary history of the wide-ranging Krefft's river turtle (Emydura macquarii krefftii), using range-wide sampling (649 individuals repre-senting 18 locations across 11 drainages) and analysis of mitochondrial sequences (~1.3-kb control region and ND4) and nuclear microsatellites (12 polymorphic loci). A range of phylogeographic (haplotype networks, molecular dating), demographic (neutrality tests, mismatch distributions), and population genetic analyses (pairwise F ST , analysis of molecular variance, Bayesian cluster-ing analysis) were implemented to differentiate between competing demo-graphic (local persistence vs. range expansion) and biogeographic (arid corridor vs. drainage divide) scenarios. Genetic data reveal population genetic structure in Krefft's river turtles primarily reflects isolation across drainage divides. Strik-ing north-south regional divergence (2.2% ND4 p-distance; c. 4.73 Ma, 95% higher posterior density (HPD) 2.08–8.16 Ma) was consistent with long-term isolation across a major drainage divide, not an adjacent arid corridor. Ancient divergence among regional lineages implies persistence of northern Krefft's pop-ulations despite the recurrent phases of severe local aridity, but with very low contemporary genetic diversity. Stable demography and high levels of genetic diversity are inferred for southern populations, where aridity was less extreme. Range-wide genetic structure in Krefft's river turtles reflects contemporary and historical drainage architecture, although regional differences in the extent of Plio–Pleistocene climatic aridity may be reflected in current levels of genetic diversity.
    Ecology and Evolution 03/2014; 4(5). DOI:10.1002/ece3.968 · 2.32 Impact Factor
Show more