Modeling biophysical controls on canopy foliage water 18O enrichment in wheat and corn

School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, USA
Global Change Biology (Impact Factor: 8.04). 04/2012; 18(5):1769 - 1780. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2486.2012.02648.x

ABSTRACT Leaf water 18O enrichment is an important factor controlling the H218O, C18OO, and O18O exchanges between the biosphere and the atmosphere. At present, there is limited capacity to explain the enrichment mechanisms in field conditions. In this study, three models of varying complexity were used to simulate the leaf water 18O enrichment at the canopy scale. Comparisons were made among the models and with high-frequency isotopic measurements of ecosystem water pools in wheat and corn. The results show that the steady state assumption was a better approximation for ecosystems with lower canopy resistance, that it is important to consider the effect of leaf water turnover in modeling the enrichment and not necessary to deal with time changes in leaf water content, and that the leaf-scale Péclet effect was incompatible with the big-leaf modeling framework for canopy-air interactions. After turbulent diffusion has been accounted for in an apparent kinetic factor parameterization, the mean 18O composition of the canopy foliage water was a well-behaved property predictable according to the principles established by leaf-scale studies, despite substantial variations in the leaf water enrichment with leaf and canopy positions. In the online supplement we provided a discussion on the observed variability of leaf water 18O composition with leaf and canopy positions and on the procedure for correcting isotopic measurements for organic contamination.

Download full-text


Available from: Shichun Zhang, Sep 28, 2015
23 Reads
  • Source
    • "In this study, the slightly contaminated (BB < 1.2) xylem water ıD were corrected based on our calibration Fig. 7. Seasonal variations of ıD in soil stratum (0–100 cm) and xylem water (mean value of xylem water in P. massoniana, P. elliottii and C. lanceolata ± SE) between July 2011 and October 2013 at the experimental site. curves (Xiao et al., 2012). However, the correction curve for ıD (y = −0.23x "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Seasonal drought will become more intense and frequent in some regions due to global climate change, which may lead to significant changes in the competitive interactions and uptake depths of plant water sources. Based on δ18O and δD in xylem and soil water, we investigated the impacts of seasonal drought on plant water sources from July 2011 to October 2013 for a subtropical coniferous plantation in southeastern China. Our results indicated that the studied tree species of Pinus massoniana, Pinus elliottii and Cunninghamia lanceolata appeared to have inter-specific competition for water resources from similar depths. There was a switch of the major water source from shallow soil during the non-drought periods (July to October) to deep soil during the drought periods (November–June). Similar seasonal trend of water uptake was estimated by δ18O and δD. However, relative to the results of δD, water sources predicted by δ18O showed that trees seemed to derive more deep soil water during the drought periods and more shallow soil water during the non-drought periods. The differences of plant water source partitioning based on δ18O and δD were significant during both the drought and non-drought periods, which probably resulted from the artifacts of the cryogenic vacuum distillation and spectral contamination correction. These findings will have important implications for further studies when just one of the dual stable isotopes of δ18O and δD is applied.
    Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 02/2015; 201. DOI:10.1016/j.agrformet.2014.11.020 · 3.76 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Development of optical isotope techniques over the last several years has provided scientists a set of tools for tracing the transport and cycling of CO2 and water vapor between the biosphere and atmosphere. Here, I take a micrometeorological perspective and review these technological advances, assess key instrument performance characteristics, examine how these techniques have been used in the field to improve our understanding of the processes governing the exchange of CO2 and water vapor, and discuss future research directions. Review of the recent literature indicates that: (1) optical techniques have been used to quantify the isotope composition of biosphere–atmosphere exchange using the traditional Keeling mixing line, flux–gradient, eddy covariance, and chamber approaches under a variety of field conditions with near-continuous data records now extending to more than 5-years; (2) high frequency and near continuous isotope measurements at the canopy scale have demonstrated important new insights regarding the behaviour of kinetic fractionation at the leaf versus canopy scales and the controls on ecosystem respiration that could not have been observed previously using traditional methods; (3) based on the assessment of instrument performance, carbon isotope disequilibrium (the difference between the isotope composition of photosynthesis and respiration), carbon turnover rates, and measurement uncertainties, 13C-CO2 investigations are best suited for examining the contributions and changes to ecosystem respiration with a need for more innovative 13C-isotope labeling experiments and compound specific isotope analyses under field conditions; (4) significant progress has been made in measuring the oxygen isotope composition of water vapor fluxes and canopy leaf water enrichment. These new data have provided an opportunity to evaluate models of leaf water enrichment and their application to the canopy scale; and (5) the use of 18O-H2O and 18O-CO2 as tracers of the coupled carbon–water cycle has matured significantly in recent years. Evidence from a range of ecosystems indicates that 18O-CO2 disequilibrium (ranging from 0 to 17‰) is much larger than for 13C-CO2 (typical less than 3‰ in natural C3 ecosystems) making it a useful tracer of coupled carbon and water cycle processes. However, a better understanding of the role of carbonic anhydrase in photosynthetic and respiratory processes under field conditions is now needed in order to make further progress. Finally, the increasing use and development of isotope-enabled land surface schemes along with the acquisition of high temporal resolution isotope data is providing a new opportunity to constrain the carbon and water cycle processes represented in these models.
    Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 06/2013; s 174–175:85–109. DOI:10.1016/j.agrformet.2013.02.009 · 3.76 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In terrestrial ecosystems, partitioning ecosystem-scale evapotranspiration (ET) between plant transpiration and soil evaporation remains a technical challenge. In this paper, we used a newly-developed laser-based isotope analyzer (OA-ICOS) and the Keeling plot approach to partition ET components of a Quercus variabilis plantation in a lithoid hilly area of north China. The results showed that, on day-of-year (DOY) 254, 257, and 263, the modeled leaf water 18O composition (δsL,b) and observed leaf water 18O composition (δL,b) were in substantial agreement and had a significant linear correlation with coefficient of 0.96, indicating that Keeling plot approach and Graig–Gorden model can be used in portioning ET between plant transpiration and soil evaporation in a terrestrial forest ecosystem. Isotopic partition revealed that the percent contribution of transpiration to total ET increased from the morning, reached maximum values at noon, with maximum values of 91.19%, 86.30%, and 85.37% for DOY 254, 257, and 263, respectively, indicating the transpiration from Q. variabilis Blum contributed the most to the total ET in this forest ecosystem. On DOY 260, the stability stratification was unstable, which resulted from the foreign vapor concentration. The increased vapor concentration led to a 80.83% difference between δsL,b and δL,b. The correlation coefficients between δsL,b and δL,b decreased from 0.96 to 0.43 when dataset on DOY 260 was included, indicating foreign vapor increased the uncertainty in the estimation of δ18O of ET (δET) and δ18O of transpiration (δT) in the forest ecosystem. Path analysis results suggested that water vapor concentration was the major factor influencing the partitioning of ET with isotopic approach in the forest ecosystem. Since the increased water vapor concentration and decreased atmosphere δ18O disturbed the estimation of δE, δT, δET, the isotopic approach cannot be used in partitioning ET under this condition on DOY 260. Therefore, under most circumstances the isotopic approach can be used to partition ET for forest ecosystem in a non-steady state (NSS), while water vapor concentration may cause uncertainties.
    Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 01/2014; 184:36–47. DOI:10.1016/j.agrformet.2013.08.006 · 3.76 Impact Factor
Show more