Case studies of damage to 19‐storey irregular steel moment‐frame buildings under near‐source ground motion

Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics (Impact Factor: 2.31). 06/2007; 36(7):861 - 885. DOI: 10.1002/eqe.657


This paper describes the three-dimensional nonlinear analysis of six 19-storey steel moment-frame buildings, designed per the 1997 Uniform Building Code, under strong ground motion records from near-source earthquakes with magnitudes in the range of 6.7–7.3. Three of these buildings possess a reentrant corner irregularity, while the remaining three possess a torsional plan irregularity. The records create drift demands of the order of 0.05 and plastic rotation demands of the order of 4–5% of a radian in the buildings with reentrant corners. These values point to performance at or near ‘Collapse Prevention’. Twisting in the torsionally sensitive buildings causes the plastic rotations on the moment frame on one face of the building (4–5% of a radian) to be as high as twice of that on the opposite face (2–3% of a radian). The asymmetric yield pattern implies a lower redundancy in the lateral force-resisting system as the failure of the heavily loaded frame could result in a total loss of resistance to torsion. Copyright © 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Download full-text


Available from: Swaminathan Krishnan, Nov 20, 2014
    • "Numerical studies investigating the response of steel moment frames around 20 stories tall (Hall et al., 1995; Hall, 1998; Alavi and Krawinkler, 2004; Krishnan, 2007; Muto and Krishnan, 2011) have indicated that strong pulse-type near-fault excitations cause significant inelastic deformation demands in frame elements that may exceed available capacities. Thus, it is important to consider appropriate ground motion characteristics when studying performance potential of a seismic force-resisting system. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper investigates the two-dimensional nonlinear seismic response of four 20-story tall reinforced concrete special moment resisting frames designed with ASCE 7-10 and ACI 318-11 code provisions. Analytical models of the buildings are subjected to a set of ground motions scaled to the smooth design spectra for the Design Basis Earthquake (DBE) and the Maximum Considered Earthquake (MCE) for a site located in Los Angeles, California. Significant inelastic deformations of beams are observed at both hazard levels, while the deformations at MCE level result in large inelastic tensile strains at the base of the columns. Current code procedures have been found to appreciably underestimate column axial forces and, depending on the procedure used, shear forces in columns, as well. Beam growth effects were found to significantly contribute to the shear forces in the columns near the base. Methods for improving the estimates of column axial and shear forces are presented.
    Earthquake Spectra 02/2013; 31(2). DOI:10.1193/082112EQS267M · 1.32 Impact Factor
  • Source

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Currently, there is a significant campaign being undertaken in southern California to increase public aware-ness and readiness for the next large earthquake along the San Andreas Fault, culminating in a large-scale earthquake response exercise. The USGS ShakeOut scenario is a key element to understanding the likely effects of such an event. A source model for a M7.8 scenario earthquake has been created (Hudnet et al. 2007), and used in conjunction with a velocity model for southern California to generate simulated ground motions for the event throughout the region (Graves et al. 2008). We were charged by the USGS to provide one plausible realization of the effects of the scenario event on tall steel moment-frame buildings. We have used the simulated ground motions with three-dimensional non-linear finite element models of three build-ings (in two orthogonal orientations and two different connection fragility conditions, for a total of twelve cases) in the 20-story class to simulate structural responses at 784 analysis sites spaced at approximately 4 km throughout the San Fernando Valley, the San Gabriel Valley and the Los Angeles Basin. Based on the simulation results and available information on the number and distribution of steel buildings, we have recommended that the ShakeOut drill be planned with a damage scenario comprising of 5% of the estimated 150 steel moment frame structures in the 10-30 story range collapsing (8 collapses), 10% of the structures red-tagged (16 red-tagged buildings), 15% of the structures with damage serious enough to cause loss of life (24 buildings with fatalities), and 20% of the structures with visible damage requiring building closure (32 buildings with visible damage and possible injuries). This paper details the analytical study underlying these recommendations.
Show more