Robust optimal control of polymorphic transformation in batch crystallization

AIChE Journal (Impact Factor: 2.58). 08/2007; 53(10):2643 - 2650. DOI: 10.1002/aic.11266

ABSTRACT One of the most important problems that can arise in the development of a pharmaceutical crystallization process is the control of polymorphism, in which there exist different crystal forms for the same chemical compound. Different polymorphs can have very different properties, such as bioavailability, which motivates the design of controlled processes to ensure consistent production of the desired polymorph to produce reliable therapeutic benefits upon delivery. The optimal batch control of the polymorphic transformation of L-glutamic acid from the metastable α-form to the stable β-form is studied, with the goal of optimizing batch productivity, while providing robustness to variations in the physicochemical parameters that can occur in practice due to variations in contaminant profiles in the feedstocks. A nonlinear state feedback controller designed to follow an optimal setpoint trajectory defined in the crystallization phase diagram simultaneously provided high-batch productivity and robustness, in contrast to optimal temperature control strategies that were either nonrobust or resulted in long-batch times. The results motivate the incorporation of the proposed approach into the design of operating procedures for polymorphic batch crystallizations. © 2007 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 2007

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The paper presents an experimental validation of a novel methodology for the systematic design of the set point operating curves for supersaturation-controlled, seeded crystallization processes, which produces a desired target crystal size distribution (CSD). The direct design approach is based on the idea of operating the system within the metastable zone (MSZ) bounded by the nucleation and the solubility curves. The proposed approach is based on an analytical CSD estimator, obtained by the analytical solution of the population balance equation for supersaturation-controlled growth-dominated processes. Based on the analytical estimator a design parameter for supersaturation-controlled processes is defined as a function of the supersaturation, time, and growth kinetics. Using the design parameter and the analytical CSD estimator, the temperature profiles in the time domain are determined to obtain a target distribution with a desired shape, while maintaining the constant supersaturation. The resulting temperature profile in the time domain can then be used as a set point for the temperature controller. This methodology provides a systematic targeted direct design approach for practical applications and scale-up. Experimental evaluations of two temperature trajectories designed with the proposed approach were carried out to achieve the desired target shape of the CSD. The experiments illustrate that the proposed targeted direct design approach can be used to systematically design different temperature trajectories and hence batch times, which lead to similar desired product CSD.
    Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 12/2012; 51(51):16677–16687. · 2.24 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This review discusses important research developments and arising challenges in the field of industrial crystallization with an emphasis on recent problems. The most relevant areas of research have been identified. These are the prediction of phase diagrams; the prediction of effects of impurities and additives; the design of fluid dynamics; the process control with process analytical technologies (PAT) tools; the polymorph and solvate screening; the stabilization of non-stable phases; and the product design. The potential of industrial crystallization in various areas is outlined and discussed with particular reference to the product quality, process design, and control. On this basis, possible future directions for research and development have been pointed out to highlight the importance of crystallization as an outstanding technique for separation, purification as well as for product design.
    Frontiers of Chemical Science and Engineering. 7(1).
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The multivariate interaction of the raw materials’ physical properties can be critical to the quality of the final drug product. Although an elegant solution to this problem is the establishment of multivariate specifications this becomes difficult (if not impossible) to implement when the interactions take place across materials that are sourced by different vendors. As an alternate solution, this work presents a feed-forward corollary approach to model predictive control (MPC) to improve the product quality from a lot-driven-operation; where there are no available manipulated variables (MV) in the process. In these special cases the only degree of freedom available to be used as a MV for control is the lot-to-lot variability in the raw materials. This work presents an extension to our earlier work (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2013, 52 (17), pp. 5934–5942) to consider a horizon of n lots to be manufactured. By considering this horizon of future lots (rather than just the next one) our method allows the discretionary use of all materials to ensure that the quality of all the future n lots is within specification. This paper presents a detailed discussion of the objective function used and also reports the results of implementing this method to the manufacture of a pharmaceutical drug product in a commercial manufacturing setting.
    Computers & Chemical Engineering 01/2014; 60:396–402. · 2.45 Impact Factor

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
May 22, 2014