Article

Conflict Nightmares and Trauma in Aceh

Culture Medicine and Psychiatry (Impact Factor: 1.29). 06/2009; 33(2):290-312. DOI: 10.1007/s11013-009-9132-8

ABSTRACT In both the Acehnese and Indonesian languages, there is no single lexical term for “nightmare.” And yet findings from a large
field research project in Aceh that examined post traumatic experience during Aceh’s nearly 30-year rebellion against the
Indonesian state and current mental distress revealed a rich variety of dream narratives that connect directly and indirectly
to respondents’ past traumatic experiences. The results reported below suggest that even in a society that has a very different
cultural ideology about dreams, where “nightmares” as such are not considered dreams but rather the work of mischievous spirits
called jin, they are still a significant part of the trauma process. We argue that it is productive to distinguish between
terrifying and repetitive dreams that recreate the traumatic moment and the more ordinary varieties of dreams that Acehnese
reported to their interviewers. Nightmares that refer back to conflict events do not appear as an elaborated feature of trauma
as the condition is understood by people in Aceh, but when asked further about their dreams, respondents who reported symptoms
suggestive of PTSD were more likely to report PTSD-like dreams, memory intrusions that repeat the political violence of the
past.

0 Bookmarks
 · 
110 Views
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The paper argues that life stories and histories offer different perspectives on the past, with implications for studying the future. A life is proposed as a form of “social site” (Marston, S.A., J.P. Jones III & K. Woodward 2005, 'Human geography without scale', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, vol. 30, pp. 416-432.) where the future is met and negotiated. Unlike the broad sweep of historical narrative, a focus on the site of a life can reveal cumulative losses, futures denied and paths not taken. Life stories challenge historical narrative with alternative futures that ‘might-have-been’; they might therefore usefully be added as a more experimental type to Inayatullah’s taxonomy of historical “traces” (Inayatullah, S. 2012, 'Humanity 3000: A comparative analysis of methodological approaches to forecasting the long-term', Foresight, vol. 14, no. 5, pp. 401-417). A case study based on a life story from Aceh is used to demonstrate ways in which alternative futures can emerge from life stories and then be acted upon. The paper concludes that the experimental power of life stories as historical traces lies not only in the stories themselves but in the unique event of storytelling and its potentially transformative impact on the teller and listener, and hence the future.
    Futures 11/2014; 64:29-37. · 1.29 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: There is considerable debate about the cross-cultural applicability of the posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) category as currently specified. Concerns include the possible status of PTSD as a Western culture-bound disorder and the validity of individual items and criteria thresholds. This review examines various types of cross-cultural validity of the PTSD criteria as defined in DSM-IV-TR, and presents options and preliminary recommendations to be considered for DSM-5. Searches were conducted of the mental health literature, particularly since 1994, regarding cultural-, race-, or ethnicity-related factors that might limit the universal applicability of the diagnostic criteria of PTSD in DSM-IV-TR and the possible criteria for DSM-5. Substantial evidence of the cross-cultural validity of PTSD was found. However, evidence of cross-cultural variability in certain areas suggests the need for further research: the relative salience of avoidance/numbing symptoms, the role of the interpretation of trauma-caused symptoms in shaping symptomatology, and the prevalence of somatic symptoms. This review also indicates the need to modify certain criteria, such as the items on distressing dreams and on foreshortened future, to increase their cross-cultural applicability. Text additions are suggested to increase the applicability of the manual across cultural contexts: specifying that cultural syndromes-such as those indicated in the DSM-IV-TR Glossary-may be a prominent part of the trauma response in certain cultures, and that those syndromes may influence PTSD symptom salience and comorbidity. The DSM-IV-TR PTSD category demonstrates various types of validity. Criteria modification and textual clarifications are suggested to further improve its cross-cultural applicability.
    Depression and Anxiety 09/2011; 28(9):783-801. · 4.29 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: After more than 20 years of sporadic separatist insurgency, the Free Aceh Movement and the Indonesian government signed an internationally brokered peace agreement in August 2005, just eight months after the Indian Ocean tsunami devastated Aceh's coastal communities. This article presents a medical humanitarian case study based on ethnographic data I collected while working for a large aid agency in post-conflict Aceh from 2005 to 2007. In December 2005, the agency faced the first test of its medical and negotiation capacities to provide psychiatric care to a recently amnestied political prisoner whose erratic behavior upon returning home led to his re-arrest and detention at a district police station. I juxtapose two methodological approaches-an ethnographic content analysis of the agency's email archive and field-based participant-observation-to recount contrasting narrative versions of the event. I use this contrast to illustrate and critique the immediacy of the humanitarian imperative that characterizes the industry. Immediacy is explored as both an urgent moral impulse to assist in a crisis and a form of mediation that seemingly projects neutral and transparent transmission of content. I argue that the sense of immediacy afforded by email enacts and amplifies the humanitarian imperative at the cost of abstracting elite humanitarian actors out of local and moral context. As a result, the management and mediation of this psychiatric case by email produced a bureaucratic model of care that failed to account for complex conditions of chronic political and medical instability on the ground.
    Social Science [?] Medicine 04/2014; · 2.56 Impact Factor

Full-text

Download
6 Downloads
Available from
Jan 14, 2015