Eucalyptus plantations in Israel: an assessment of economic and environmental viability

New Forests (Impact Factor: 1.64). 01/2008; 36(2):135-157. DOI:10.1007/s11056-008-9089-4

ABSTRACT This paper discusses a plantation management approach involving a combination of “short” and “long” rotations designed to
allow farmers to receive income from trees as soon as possible after establishment. We present results from two plots that
represent extreme conditions: (a) a seasonally waterlogged, non-saline site (Nahalal), and (b) a saline site (Ginnegar) located
in the Yizre’el Valley, Israel. Six improved seed sources, four of Eucalyptus camaldulensis and two of E. occidentalis, were examined. The local Israeli seed source of E. camaldulensis (HA) performed best at both sites. In Nahalal, the short rotation thinning of the slower growing (50%) plantation trees could
provide economic returns approximately five years after establishment. The calculated mean annual increment (MAI) of these
trees reached 12.2tha−1year−1. The long rotation, or better performing half of the plantation trees, could be used as a source of sawn timber, providing
higher-value products. By nine years after establishment, the average DBH of the various seed sources reached 25.8±1.9cm.
The calculated MAI of the combined cutting rotations reached 48.3tha−1year−1. Eucalyptus grown under the combined (short- and long-term) management approach at Nahalal was more profitable than many other non-irrigated
local crops. Eucalyptus production in Ginnegar would be less profitable than in Nahalal. However, an additional ecological benefit was provided by
the crop’s ability to lower the water table. When this contribution to regional drainage is taken into account, trees become
economically competitive with other non-irrigated field crops under saline conditions.

0 0
1 Bookmark
  • [show abstract] [hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Fast growing and short-rotation tree crops provide unique opportunities to reclaim phosphate-mined lands in central Florida. Optimum management of the eucalyptus short-rotation woody crop forestry system studied necessitates harvests every 2.5–3.6 years and replanting after 2–5 coppice harvests. The value of phosphate mined land under Eucalyptus amplifolia forestry ranges from $762 to $6507 ha−1 assuming discount rates of 10% and 4%, respectively, establishment costs of $1800 ha−1, planting costs of $1200 ha−1, planting density of 8400 tree ha−1, and a stumpage price of $20 dry Mg−1.
    Journal of Forest Economics. 01/2007;
  • [show abstract] [hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The effects of short-term flooding on soil water content and subsequent tree response were examined in a riparian Eucalyptus camaldulensis forest which was dissected by a series of shallow ephemeral channels, locally known as runners. Twelve isolated plots, each approximately 0.8 ha, were established in three blocks of four treatments. One of the blocks was underlain by a moist, sandy aquifer 2–4 m below the surface. The four treatments were (1) flooding each spring; (2) flooding each summer; (3) flooding each spring plus each summer; (4) control (zero flooding). Depth of water percolation after a summer flooding varied from 1.3 to over 6 m below the surface. Horizontal movement away from the edge of the floodwater ranged from almost zero on some plots to at least 38 m. The extensive horizontal movement was confined within narrow aquifers which occurred under some plots. Trees in plots underlain by a shallow aquifer always had higher xylem pressure potential (XPP, MPa) than other trees, and flooding these plots increased XPP by a non-significant quantity (−0.14 MPa to −0.12 MPa). However, on the other plots, flooding resulted in a statistically significant increase in XPP from −0.45 to −0.10 MPa. The effect of flooding on XPP was evident for between 22.5 and 37.5 m from the floodwater. This was ascribed to root interception and some horizontal movement of water. Increased flood frequency from zero to one to two per year resulted in mean leaf areas of 11.0 cm2, 12.2 cm2 and 13.2 cm2, respectively. Trees in the runner, at 8 or at 38 m from the channels, had mean leaf areas of 12.9 cm2, 13.6 cm2 and 9.9 cm2, respectively. The presence of shallow aquifers increased mean leaf area from 11.5 to 13.3 cm2. Increased flood frequency significantly increased relative growth rate of trees up to 22.5 m from the edge of the floodwater. We conclude that short-term flooding of channels that occupied 15–20% of the forest floor temporarily improved tree moisture status and this increased tree growth rate in up to 70% of the forest.
    Journal of Hydrology - J HYDROL. 01/1993; 150:541-561.
  • [show abstract] [hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Plantings of salt-tolerant tree species are commonly used to manage shallow saline water tables in agricultural lands in Australia. Eucalyptus camaldulensis is often used for this purpose due to its salt tolerance and ability to use groundwater. Salt tolerance studies suggest that Casuarina glauca would also have groundwater management potential, however, little is known about its transpiration and groundwater uptake properties. A combination of stable isotope (H-2 and O-18) techniques and sapflow measurements were used to determine groundwater discharge by both species at three saline sites. This included the use of a three-layer model for determining the proportions of water utilised from various soil depths. At one site, groundwater was the dominant water source for C, glauca in over 70% of sampling times. However, at a higher rainfall site, groundwater was the major water source for this species in only 40% of sampling times. E. camaldulensis relied less on groundwater than C, glauca, utilising water from mid-soil layers to a greater extent. Groundwater was the-dominant water source for this species in 50% and 25% of sampling times at each of the two sites, with lower use of groundwater at the higher rainfall site. Low water use rates were observed in both the species; 1.5 to 3 mm day(-1) in C. glauca and 1 to 3 mm day(-1) in E. camaldulensis. Due to the low water use rates, groundwater discharge rates seldom exceeded 2 mm day(-1), with the maximum discharge rate of 2.6 mm day(-1) being recorded for C. glauca. As C. glauca relied more heavily on groundwater than did E. camaldulensis, and both species exhibited conservative water use rates, under the conditions of this study, C. glauca showed greater potential than E. camaldulensis to discharge saline groundwater. (C) 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.